• Sale 7605

    Old Master and 19th Century Drawings

    8 July 2008, London, King Street

  • Lot 65

    Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes (Fuendetodos 1746-1828 Bordeaux)

    Bajan riñendo (They go down quarrelling) or Vision de bajar riñendo (Vision: going down quarrelling)

    Price Realised  

    Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes (Fuendetodos 1746-1828 Bordeaux)
    Bajan riñendo (They go down quarrelling) or Vision de bajar riñendo (Vision: going down quarrelling)
    inscribed by the artist in black chalk 'Vision de bajar riñendo' (over 'Bajan riñendo') and numbered by the artist '2' in black chalk (corrected by him to '1' or possibly '5' in pen and ink) at upper centre (album D) and with Madrazo's number '47' (Madrazo album III) in pen and ink at upper right
    brush and grey wash, scraping
    9¼ x 5 5/8 in. (234 x 143 mm.)


    Contact Client Service
    • info@christies.com

    • New York +1 212 636 2000

    • London +44 (0)20 7839 9060

    • Hong Kong +852 2760 1766

    • Shanghai +86 21 6355 1766

    This drawing comes from Album D, also called Witches and Old Women Album. Before its reappearance only 21 sheets were known, all except one in public collections. The surviving drawings are only numbered as high as '23' and the album was probably left unfinished. They are on a strong Dutch paper, the same as used in Album B, known as the Madrid Album.
    Two women are falling through the air: one, grinning broadly, grabs the hair of the other who screams in pain. It is hard to know if the two figures (is it a couple?) who are floating at the top (one is holding a tambourine) are embracing each other or are in the midst of a serious fight. The descent of the figures is emphasized by the movement of their clothing. Intense patches of black and grey tones along with overlaid rapid, free strokes and the scraping creating lighter areas also help to suggest the falling movement. The two figures at the top are completely covered by dark wash almost as if they are only shadows. In contrast, portions of the bodies of the two old women in the foreground are left blank, conveying an almost sculptural quality and giving the illusion that they are ready to spring from the page.
    Goya had at first titled the drawing in black chalk at the bottom centre: 'Bajan riñendo' (They go down quarrelling), but he later added the words 'Vision de' and corrected 'Bajan' into 'bajar', transforming the inscription into 'Vision de bajar riñendo' (Vision: going down quarrelling). If the number inscribed by Goya in brown ink over a previous '2' in black chalk is in fact a '1', then this sheet began the album. It is revealing of Goya's method of organizing his albums that the drawing he then numbered '2' (in the Louvre, Gassier, 1973, op. cit., no. 96 [D.2]) is titled 'Suben alegres' (They rise merrily). In contrast to the present drawing, the latter shows a woman, holding castanets in her right hand and a punctured tambourine in her left, flying through the air, accompanied by an old man. As he rises, he grips a tambourine with both hands. The joy on their faces contrasts dramatically with the expression of terror of the woman whose hair is grabbed on the present sheet. It is a common idea that when things are going badly, they go 'down', but everyone is happy when things are 'up'. This theme could indeed be illustrated fully in this drawing if we accept the fact that the two figures at the top are actually rising while embracing each other. The two other would then be falling only because they started a fight... The first few pages of Album D and some later ones also show flying figures.
    Rising through the air and floating are often seen as symbols of sexual pleasure. Goya used this image with the same meaning in several works, as in Capricho 68, Linda maestra (A fine Teacher!) (fig. 1) where two naked witches fly on a broomstick.
    There has been much debate about the dating of the drawings from Album D. As they are on the same paper as Album B used in 1796-7, and as Goya in the 'Sueños' drawings (P. Gassier, The drawings of Goya. The sketches, studies and individual drawings, London, 1975, nos. 43-4) used for prints of the Caprichos (1799) had depicted the transformation into witches and warlocks of bawds and clerics who indulged in vice, Pierre Gassier was inclined to date Album D around 1800. Eleanor Sayre placed these drawings much later, circa 1816-7. Juliet Wilson-Bareau, in the Hayward Gallery exhibition catalogue, pushed the date even later, circa 1819-1823, comparing the scenes in Album D to the Black Paintings that Goya executed around 1820 in his property known as the Quinta del Sordo (House of the Deaf Man). With their broad and expressionistic brushwork, the images of Album D seem also to announce the miniatures on ivory that Goya would paint later in Bordeaux : 'these album drawings both describe and suggest, moving easily between a perfectly controlled grasp of sharp, expressive detail and a splendidly broad, free manner - "more like the brushwork of Velázquez than of Mengs", as Goya wrote of his miniatures' (J. Wilson-Bareau, Goya drawings from his private albums, exhib. cat., London, Hayward Gallery, 2001, p. 136). The grimacing stocky figures in Vision de bajar riñendo can also be compared to those drawn in the two Bordeaux Albums executed in black chalk between 1825 and 1828. In these Goya represented flying figures on several occasions (see, for example, Gassier, 1973, op. cit., nos. 404 [G46], 443 [H27], 448 [H32] or 471 [H59]).
    These images of figures flying against a blank background, possibly inspired by compositions of Giovanni Battista Tiepolo whom Goya deeply admired, would appeal later to many artists of the 20th Century, especially Surrealists like Max Ernst (fig. 2) who explored the subject in many of his works, making it one of the central themes of his oeuvre.

    We thank Juliet Wilson-Bareau for her kind help in cataloguing this drawing.

    Special Notice

    VAT rate of 5% is payable on hammer price and at 15% on the buyer's premium


    Provenance

    By descent to the artist's son, Javier Goya y Bayeu (1784-1854), and by descent to his son, Mariano Goya y Goicoechea, after 1854.
    Federico de Madrazo, around 1855-60.
    Paul Lebas; Paris, Drouot, 3 April 1877, lot 86 ('Ils descendent'; 20 Francs to E. Féral).


    Pre-Lot Text

    PROPERTY FROM A SWISS PRIVATE COLLECTION (LOTS 65, 66 AND 67)

    The following three drawings come from two of Goya's celebrated Private Albums. They constitute a major rediscovery as although known from old descriptions, they were untraced since 1877 when they were included in a sale at the Hôtel Drouot in Paris, titled Catalogue de 105 dessins par Francisco Goya, from which - apart from the holdings in the Museo nacional del Prado - came the great majority of Goya's drawings in museums and collections around the world.

    The Private Albums
    In 1796 Goya, at the age of fifty, began filling pages of albums with drawings of people observed in various attitudes and occupied in various ways, singly or in groups. He was to keep up this practice until the end of his life, some thirty years later. In all he created eight albums of varying length and size which originally included some 550 drawings. In 1958 Eleanor Sayre described and defined the characteristics of the eight albums, suggesting a chronology and labelling the albums with the letters A to H ('An Old Man Writing. A Study of Goya's Albums', Boston Museum Bulletin, LVI, pp. 116-36). Twelve years later in their monumental Goya His Life and Work with a catalogue raisonné of the paintings, drawings and engravings (London, 1970), Pierre Gassier and Juliet Wilson catalogued every known sheet from the albums and illustrated them in the order laid down by Goya. In 1973 Gassier published The Drawings of Goya. The Complete Albums (London; the original French edition appeared in the same year) where he studied each album separately, proposed a new chronological order, and illustrated actual size the drawings then known. Seven years ago Juliet Wilson-Bareau organized the first exhibition solely devoted to the albums (Goya drawings from his private albums, London, Hayward Gallery, 2001). The present text owes a lot to her catalogue and to her introduction to it.
    The drawings from the albums are not preparatory studies for pictures or prints, although some images from Albums A and B, the Sanlucar and Madrid Albums, drawn in the mid 1790s, were the starting point for prints in his famous set of eighty Caprichos published in 1799. Drawing as a preliminary to painting was of no interest to Goya. He drew directly on the canvas with his brush. As Eleanor Sayre stated, the albums are 'not notebooks containing a casual assembly of portrait heads, drapery studies and composition sketches. Neither were they any longer sketchbooks preserving the intermittent record of places he saw and picturesque figures which might be used again. They had been transmuted by him into journals, drawn not written, whose pictorial entries of varying length pertained predominantly to what Goya thought rather than what he saw' (1958, op. cit., p. 120). The drawings in the albums show Goya's 'intuitive grasp of the human condition [that] was based on observation but not limited by it or by convention or by canons of taste and tradition. Human passions, human desires, human fears are his unique concern expressed through a vast range of subjects, from mundane aspects of everyday reality to the most profoundly spiritual themes' (Wilson-Bareau, 2001, op. cit., p. 23).


    Their unique individual character
    Goya created these albums for his own satisfaction, and in his lifetime they were seen only by him and his close friends and family, and it is unlikely that they were seen in their original condition by anyone else. Though drawings from the same album can vary widely in their subject matter, Goya seems to have planned the albums as single works, each one as a coherent whole. In fact, Goya numbered all the albums himself except the first, which indicates that the sequence of the drawings was a matter of considerable importance to him. He liked to oppose one drawing to the next. For instance, Bajan riñendo (They go down quarrelling) (lot 65), representing women falling while fighting, was the first page of Album D, also called Witches and Old Women Album, and was directly followed by Suben alegres (They rise up joyfully), now in the Louvre (Gassier, op. cit., 1973, no. 96), showing an old couple happily playing the tambourine while flying...
    Each album is consistent in technique and the type of paper used. Goya preferred Dutch paper (as in Album D whence comes lot 65), but also used Spanish (as in Album F whence come lots 66 and 67) or French paper as circumstances dictated. Six of the eight albums consist of brush and wash drawings, but the last two, also called Bordeaux Albums, are executed in black chalk. No arbitrary changes of technique occur from one sheet to the next. For the drawings in wash, there is virtually no black chalk underdrawing. Sometimes a pale, almost invisible, tracery of dots and lines reveals the initial placement of a figure on the page. This kind of indication can be observed on the Constable Lampiños stitched inside a dead horse (lot 67), especially on the body of the animal. Goya also used a scraper - probably an etcher's tool, a knife or a razor - to lighten certain areas, to remove a patch of wash, to modify an element in the drawing. This kind of reworking is noticeable on Bajan riñendo (lot 65).
    The inscriptions or captions play a key role in the albums: according to Gassier, who characterized them as commentary-captions, 'their telling, incisive style reflects the artist's personality and amounts to an actual signature. [Inscriptions] point the irony, express surprise, venture a statement, but never overstate... Often Goya exclaims or wonders, but his true originality and incomparable force lies in his way of apostrophizing his figures, questioning, advising, comforting, or even threatening them' (op. cit., 1973, p. 14).


    Goya's albums after the artist's death
    The history of the albums is gradually becoming clearer. We do not know what the original eight albums looked like. Some were bound notebooks, but others were loose sheets perhaps kept in a folder. At Goya's death they passed to his son Javier (1784-1854) who dismembered the albums and arranged the drawings in three larger bound volumes, although it seems that he respected the page order established by his father. But these composite albums containing around 450 sheets were broken up after Javier's death in 1854 when they were sold by Javier's son Mariano to the painter Federico de Madrazo (1815-1894), who replaced his father as Director of the Prado in 1860. According to Juliet Wilson-Bareau 'Madrazo evidently set aside almost 300 sheets, for sale or for gifts and presentations, and sorted the remaining sheets - some 170 - into three groups, destroying in fact the original sequencing. These he numbered in pen and ink in three different ways: in the upper right corner, the upper centre, and again in the upper right corner, with a curving bracket that distinguishes this numbering from the first. All the drawings - apart from those already given or sold - were then pasted onto sheets of pink paper and the majority were bound in three volumes' (op. cit., p. 24). The three re-discovered drawings are still on their original pink paper backing, which has been trimmed to the edges of the sheets.
    It is the contents of two of the three volumes, once again dismembered, that appeared at auction in Paris on 3 April 1877. The auctioneer's book mentions the name of Paul Lebas as the seller but the latter was probably acting on behalf of Federico de Madrazo who in 1868 had lost his posts as Director of the Prado and as First Court Painter and would presumably not have wished to be identified as the owner of this treasure. The sale went almost unnoticed and its importance was only established in 1972 by Pierre Gassier in a major article (P. Gassier, 'Une source inédite de dessins de Goya en France au XIXe siècle', Gazette des Beaux-Arts, LXXX, 1972, pp. 110-120). The drawings, sold individually, briefly described, and totalling 105 lots, fetched between 6 and 140 French Francs. The prices seem respectable, but not outstanding if we compare them to those achieved thirteen years earlier at the Delacroix studio sale, where some of Delacroix's drawings were sold for more than 2,000 French Francs apiece. The main buyers at the 1877 sale were French collectors like Emile Calando, the Baron de Beurnonville and Paul Meurice. It is also known that the expert for the sale, Eugène Féral (1832-1900) made purchases on behalf of Victor Hugo. All the drawings in the 1877 sale were pasted onto large blue card mounts to which these three are still attached. One can still see the pinholes at the top of each mount made by the tacks that were used to hang them unframed on the walls of the Hôtel Drouot. At the sale, two drawings (Repentance and Constable Lampiños) remained unsold and the other one (Bajan riñendo) was knocked down to Féral, a fact that could indicate that like the two others it was returned to the seller or that all three sold after the sale to an unknown collector. They have remained together, unnoticed, and recorded only by their description in the Drouot sale catalogue. The fact that the three drawings are in exceptional condition owes much to the fact that they have never been framed nor exposed to light.

    A recent assessment of the 1877 sale catalogue by Juliet Wilson-Bareau reveals that, following the reappearance of these three sheets, a further twelve drawings remain to be rediscovered. The importance of the 1877 sale as the principal source of Goya's finest drawings cannot be underestimated, and the three very different sheets presented here are superb examples of the inexhaustible fertility of Goya's imagination.


    Literature

    P. Gassier, 'Une source inédite de dessins de Goya en France au XIXe siècle', Gazette des Beaux-Arts, LXXX, 1972, p. 116 (as lost).
    P. Gassier, The Drawings of Goya. The Complete Albums, London, 1973, p. 164, 'Lost drawings': D.j.