• Christies auction house James Christie logo

    Sale 11898

    Exceptional Sale

    13 April 2016, New York, Rockefeller Plaza

  • Lot 8

    AN ITALIAN INLAID MARBLE TOP

    ROME, CIRCA 1580-1600, ATTRIBUTED TO PIETRO CARLI

    Price Realised  

    Estimate

    AN ITALIAN INLAID MARBLE TOP
    ROME, CIRCA 1580-1600, ATTRIBUTED TO PIETRO CARLI
    With a central oval of alabastro fiorito within a narrow border of stylized flowers, the inner field with bold volute scrolls of lumachella orientale interspersed with scrolling flowering stems and trailing beads, the ends with flower-filled baskets, the center of each main border with a pelta shield of breccia quintilina and military trophies, the weapons with blades of translucent alabaster, flanked by angled trophies and shields of bianco e nero antico, each corner with a cartouche-shaped trophy of alabastra a tartaruga and semesanto, within a narrow outer band of pietra nefritica and a moulded outer edge of giallo antico
    57 in. x 39 1/4 in. (144.7 cm. x 99.6 cm.)


    Contact Client Service
    • info@christies.com

    • New York +1 212 636 2000

    • London +44 (0)20 7839 9060

    • Hong Kong +852 2760 1766

    • Shanghai +86 21 6355 1766

    Contact the department

    This spectacular inlaid marble top, completely unknown to the market since it was acquired by the current owner's father in Madrid 1963, is an outstanding example of Roman commesso work from circa 1600. It displays a central oval of richly figured alabastro fiorito within bold volutes of lumachella orientale and lush flowering foliage, while the borders of military trophies are equally sumptuous, employing panels of rare and precious stones such as breccia quintilina and alabastra a tartaruga, so-called because it resembles the richly mottled effect of tortoiseshell. The rediscovery of this table top is particularly exciting as it can be attributed to a Florentine marble craftsman Pietro Carli, probably active in Rome at the end of the 16th century, on the basis of its close similarities to a signed example in All Souls College, Oxford.

    Rare marbles and hardstones have been prized since antiquity and the extravagant display of coloured marbles was emblematic of the supreme power and prestige of ancient Rome. This rich tradition was kept alive through the elaborate mosaics of Byzantine architecture and the patterned use of marbles in the Middle Ages. The Renaissance fueled a renewed passion for the arts of ancient Rome, and enlightened connoisseurs were able to reuse the rare coloured marbles of which Rome was such a rich source. The art of commesso, which was revived in the 16th century, was a technique of inlaying various sections of differently coloured marbles and semi-precious stones to form a design and consciously imitated the mosaic-work and inlaid marble floors of ancient Rome known as opus sectile.

    EARLY HISTORY OF ROMAN COMMESSO WORK

    In Rome, commesso work was particularly associated with enlightened architects and designers such as Jacopo Vignola (1507-73), who provided the designs for the celebrated table supplied to Alessandro Farnese circa 1565, now in the Metropolitan Museum, New York, and Giovanni Antonio Dosio (1533-1609). Their work attracted the interest of wealthy, sophisticated patrons such as Cardinal Giovanni Rici of Montepulciano and Cosimo I Medici, whose fascination for the art of inlaying marbles led to the foundation of the celebrated Medici workshop by his son Ferdinando. In 1565 the Bishop of Viterbo, Sebastiano Gualterio, owned three inlaid marble tables, with centres of alabaster '… of brocatello white and black, greens, and other rare stones', which, although earlier, must have been broadly similar to the table top offered here (see A. Giusti, Pietre Dure Hardstone in Furniture and Decorations, London, 1992, p. 12).
    The earliest versions of these table tops, produced in Rome in the middle of the 16th Century, would usually consist of a plain rectangular panel of a rare ancient stone, usually a form of alabaster, within relatively plain geometric borders. Interestingly, a 1568 inventory of the Palazzo Farnese refers to table tops solely by recording them as panels of rare marbles, implying that the display of the central panel of a single stone was their primary purpose. The distinctive pelta-shields of the borders of the Farnese table are clearly echoed in the border of the table top offered here (see Giusti, op.cit., p. 10).

    Later in the century, while retaining the basic scheme of a larger central panel and geometric borders, the designs of Roman table tops became more elaborate, with more naturalistic elements such as flowers and trailing foliage being introduced, often with distinctive beaded arabesques as on this table top. Examples of this group, include the following:
    -One in the J. Paul Getty Museum Los Angeles, previously in the collection of Alfred de Rothschild, Halton, Buckinghamshire, and by descent to Edmund de Rothschild, Exbury, Hampshire (illustrated in C. Bremer-David, Decorative Arts An Illustrated Summary Catalogue of the Collections, Malibu, 1993, p. 189, cat. 320)
    -One in the Villa Borghese, Rome (illustrated in Giusti, op. cit., p. 30)
    -One in the Prado Museum, Madrid, first inventoried in the Royal Spanish collection in 1636 (illustrated in A. González-Palacios, Las Colecciones Reales Españolas de Mosaicos y Piedra Duras, Madrid, 2001, p. 65, cat. 3
    -An example sold in these rooms, 21 October 2004, lot 1224 ($455,500)

    A POSSIBLE ATTRIBUTION
    The table top offered here belongs to a select and distinct group of just before 1600 which are among the mostly richly ornamented of this period. They incorporate even more elaborate and figural designs to the borders, particularly in the form of eye-catching military trophies with the blades of the weapons inlaid in the same distinctive translucent alabaster as on this table. The table top offered here is remarkably close in design to an example in All Souls College, Oxford (illustrated here), which also features the same bold volutes framing the central oval, the distinctive flower-filled baskets to either end of the main field and an outer edge of giallo antico. The All Souls table top has the rare feature of being signed in its outer border ‘M.PIETRO CARLI FIO[RENTINO] FECIT’ and was formerly acquired by either Alfred or James Morrison for their celebrated collection at Fonthill, before being sold at auction in 1936 (see A.M. Giusti, Pietre Dure and the Art of Florentine Inlay, London, 2005, p. 38, fig. 27 and p. 42; and S. Swynfen Jervis and D. Dodd, Roman Splendour, English Arcadia, London, 2015, p. 45, fig. 50).

    Such are the similarities in design and choice of marbles in these two marble tops that an attribution of the top offered here to Carli is also feasible. Tantalisingly, very little is known of this marble craftsman, although a bill from 1569 for a table top being prepared for Ferdinando I de Medici records ‘Pietro detto el Fiorentino’ as being responsible for its creation, which could refer to the same maker. The fact that he is clearly of Florentine origin raises some interesting questions, as this group of marble tops is traditionally thought to have been made in Rome, and Florentine work of the period is most closely associated with the Medici workshops, which had a quite different, distinctively naturalistic style with a more pronounced use of hardstones (as opposed to marbles) on a black ground. Was he a Florentine craftsman who worked in Rome, or were there other workshops working in Florence outside the Medici Opificio delle Pietre Dure, whose work has mistakenly been identified as Roman?

    The recent publication of a series of designs for inlaid marble tops by the architect and designer Giovanni Vincenzo Casale (now in the Biblioteca Nacional, Madrid), dated to around 1570, also leads to the possibility that this group of table tops could actually be dated 20-30 years earlier than previously thought. One of the Casale designs is reproduced here, featuring very similar military trophies and the large scale volutes to to the central field. It is also fascinating to note that it specifies which marbles are to be used in the various elements- brocatello for the volute scrolls, for instance.

    The most celebrated table top of the group with military trophies is that from the collection of the Spanish courtier Don Rodrigo Calderón (c. 1576-1621), now in the Prado Museum, Madrid (see González-Palacios, op. cit., p. 69, cat. 5 and also illustrated here), while another superb example recently came onto the market, acquired by the 3rd Earl of Warwick from the Grimani family of Venice (sold Sotheby’s, London, 10 December 2015, lot 202, £1,625,000). The Calderón table, which was acquired by Don Rodrigo in the early 1600s, was traditionally thought to have been a gift from Pope Pius V to Don John of Austria after his celebrated victory at the battle of Lepanto in 1571, which would make some sense given the clear depiction of Turkish warriors in the main field, although González-Palacios treats this provenance with caution.

    Further examples of the military trophy group include one in the Museu Nacional de Arte Antiga, Lisbon, illustrated in González-Palacios op. cit., p. 53, one formerly in the Barilla collection, sold Sotheby’s, London, 11 December 2002, lot 25 (£336,650) and a further example in the Museo Nacional de Artes Decorativas, Madrid, illustrated in González-Palacios op. cit., p. 249, cat. 46 and previously sold Sotheby’s New York, 5 November 1998, lot 393 ($2,752,500).

    Christie's would like to thank Gaye Morgan, Librarian in Charge and Conservator, Codrington Library, All Souls College for her kind help in preparing this cataloguing entry.








    Provenance

    Acquired by the present owner’s father from the dealer Rafael Romero Fernandez, Madrid in 1963


    Pre-Lot Text

    PROPERTY OF A PRIVATE COLLECTOR