1 page, 4to, personal letterhead. [with:] a carbon tls of brenner's letter to einstein, and a copy of the new york times article." />
Sales totals are hammer price plus buyer’s premium and do not reflect costs, financing fees or application of buyer’s or seller’s credits.
FINE PRINTED BOOKS AND MANUSCRIPTS INCLUDING AMERICANA
16 December 2004
New York, Rockefeller Plaza
EINSTEIN, Albert. Typed letter signed ("A. Einstein") to Aliza Brenner, 3 May 1948. 1 page, 4to, personal letterhead. [With:] A carbon TLS of Brenner's letter to Einstein, and a copy of the New York Times article.
EINSTEIN DEFENDS HIS DENUNCIATION OF "TERRORISTIC ELEMENTS...IN OUR RANKS" IN PALESTINE
Einstein offers a diplomatic (if not entirely grammatical) reply to a critic who took strong issue with his denunciation of Jewish violence in Palestine, as expressed in his 12 April 1948 letter to The New York Times, co-authored with Rabbi Leo Baeck. Einstein here writes, "I see from your letter...that you have misinterpreted the intention of our letter to the New York Times. We have not denied in any way to our people [the option] to stand and fight for their right. What we intended was to do our share to help prevent that our acts might be such that a peaceful solution will be made impossible. It is not our fault that terroristic elements have become influential in our ranks and are favored even by the American Jews in their dangerous and even criminal enterprises and methods. Great damage is done thereby to the moral value of our whole Palestine work and also to the attitude of the outside world towards us--from which, after all, our future depends. The proposals Dr. Baeck and myself made in the letter to the New York Times in no way involved any renunciation of our national independence and rights of immigration."
In their Times letter, Einstein and Baeck had stated, "we feel it to be our duty to declare emphatically that we do not condone methods of terrorism and of fanatical nationalism any more if practiced by Jews than if practiced by Arabs. We hope that responsible Arabs will appeal to their people as we do to the Jews. Were war to occur, the peace would still leave the necessity of the two peoples working together, unless one or the other were exterminated or enslaved. Short of such a calamity, a decisive victory by either would yield a corroding bitterness. Common sense dictates joint efforts to prevent war and to foster cooperation now."
Appealing to Jews in Palestine as well as around the world, Einstein and Baeck urged them "not to permit themselves to be driven into a mood of despair or false heroism which eventually results in suicidal measures. While such a mood is understandable as a reaction to the wanton destruction of six million Jewish lives in the last decade, it is neverthless destructive morally as well as practically." Any peaceful solution had to be "based on the concern for the welfare and cooperation of both Jews and Arabs in Palestine." Mrs. Brenner, who was born and raised in Palestine, answered this by saying: "I don't think I am an extremist and I know that 95 of the Yishuv in Palestine are like me. We are not asking for more than the right to live in peace and raise our children in freedom. Is this too much to ask?" Einstein's rejoinder explicitly reiterates his commitment to peace as well as to the Jewish people's right of self-defense.
THE PROPERTY OF A LADY
Register to Bid: Please register online at www.christies.com
or contact the Christie's Bid Department at:
NY: +1 212 636 2437
London: +44 (0)20 7389 2658
Monday-Friday, 9am-5pm local times