• Christies auction house James Christie logo

    Sale 7595

    20th Century British Art

    6 June 2008, London, King Street

  • Lot 78

    Graham Sutherland, O.M. (1903-1980)

    Thorn Head

    Price Realised  

    Estimate

    Graham Sutherland, O.M. (1903-1980)
    Thorn Head
    signed and dated 'Sutherland 1950-1' (lower left), signed again, inscribed and dated again 'THORN HEAD 1950-1/G. SUTHERLAND' (on the reverse)
    oil on canvas
    26½ x 19¾ in. (67.3 x 50.2 cm )


    Contact Client Service
    • info@christies.com

    • New York +1 212 636 2000

    • London +44 (0)20 7839 9060

    • Hong Kong +852 2760 1766

    • Shanghai +86 21 6355 1766

    The motif of the thorn head originated in the commission Sutherland received in 1944 to paint a large Crucifixion for St. Matthew's Church, Northampton. This was eventually executed in the second half of 1946, but in the meantime, the artist noted, 'my mind became preoccupied with the idea of thorns (the crown of thorns) and wounds made by thorns: then on going into the country I began to notice thorn trees and bushes. Especially against the sky, the thorns on the branches established a limit of aerial space. They were like dividers pricking out points in space in all directions, encompassing the air, as it were solid and tangible. I'd never noticed this before: but all kinds of ideas for pictures started to come into my mind. Apart from the large 'Thorn Trees' I had several ideas for Thorn Head. A sort of 'pricking' and demarcation of a hollow headshaped space enclosed by the points' (see 1946 statement, reprinted in M. Hammer, Graham Sutherland: Landscapes, War Scenes, Portraits 1924-1950, London, Dulwich Picture Gallery, 2005, p. 156).

    In the extended series of pictures that resulted from this epiphany, the forms of thorn bush and human head become inextricably fused, evoking Christ's Crown of Thorns but also wartime imagery such as barbed wire, and a general air of menace and violence. When the thorn pictures were first exhibited, in early 1946, they certainly possessed a powerful contemporary resonance, causing one critic to remark that 'these jagged forms are the flora appropriate to a crucified world in which atrocity has become endemic' (see R. Marvell, 'New Pictures', The New Statesman and Nation, 16 February 1946, p. 119).

    Sutherland returned to the Thorn Head image obsessively during the post-war years, and this picture is one of his final variations on the theme. In comparison with its predecessors, the treatment here is notably severe and sculptural, typifying a move in Sutherland's art away from the more colourful and decorative idiom that he had evolved during the late 1940s, in response to the light and landscape of the South of France. A revealing contrast may be drawn with the 1949 Thorn Head in the collection of the Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art, Edinburgh. In creating the present picture, Sutherland may have had in mind the bather and head pictures that Picasso painted around 1930, contemplating the Apollinaire monument project, which likewise featured emphatically modelled, grisaille forms set against flat backdrops.

    Around the time that he executed the work under discussion, Sutherland talked revealingly about his thorn pictures in a radio interview, explaining his preference for blue backgrounds. The pictures were, in essence, 'about cruelty': 'I attempted to give the idea a double twist, as it were, by setting them in benign circumstances: a blue sky, green grass, Crucifixions under warmth - and blue skies are, in a sense, more powerfully horrifying ...' (see G. Sutherland, 'Thoughts on Painting', The Listener, 6 September 1951, reprinted in Hammer, op. cit., p. 145).

    M.H.

    In a letter to Peter Meyer dated 2 November 1951, Sutherland wrote, 'My Dear Peter, I'm delighted that you are to have the Thorn Head & that you like it. To tell the truth I had forgotten that when you said, in my studio, that you liked it - you had implied that you might like to own it. Robert assured me that such was the case & that is why - with great temerity, I left it with him. I'm very glad you like it. But I am wondering if I may ask you the inevitable question - which is awful cheek & a worse nuisance. Would you lend the Thorn Head if I need it for the Venice Biennale? [Thorn Head] is rather special & I do want to try & collect my very best things. If you don't want to lend, I shall understand & I won't blame you. When I painted that picture I did have in the back of my mind the fact that it would make a good 'pendant' for another Thorn' (private correspondence).

    Special Notice

    No VAT will be charged on the hammer price, but VAT at 15% will be added to the buyer's premium which is invoiced on a VAT inclusive basis.


    Provenance

    Purchased by the present owner in 1951 for £126.


    Literature

    D. Cooper, Graham Sutherland, London, 1961, p. 79, pl. 111C.


    Exhibited

    Venice, British Council, XXVI Biennale, Exhibition of works by Sutherland, Wadsworth, Adams, Armitage, Butler, Chadwick, Clarke, Meadows, Moore, Paolozzi, Turnbull, June - October 1952, no. 51: this exhibition travelled to Paris, Musée National d'Art Moderne, November - December 1952; Amsterdam, Stedelijk Museum, January 1953, no. 49; and Zürich, Kunsthaus, March 1953, no. 49.
    London, Arts Council of Great Britain, Tate Gallery, An Exhibition of Paintings and Drawings by Graham Sutherland, May - August 1953, no. 55.
    Kassel, Museum Fridericianum, Documenta: Art of the 20th Century, July - September 1955, no. 607.