• Christies auction house James Christie logo

    Sale 2091

    Important American Silver

    17 January 2008, New York, Rockefeller Plaza

  • Lot 185

    A GEORGE III SILVER TROPHY TRAY: WON BY HAIL TO REASON

    MARK OF TIMOTHY RENOU, LONDON, 1804

    Price Realised  

    A GEORGE III SILVER TROPHY TRAY: WON BY HAIL TO REASON
    MARK OF TIMOTHY RENOU, LONDON, 1804
    Oval, with reeded border and two leaf-clad handles, the field engraved with grape scroll border and a coat-of-arms, the reverse with presentation inscription New York Racing Association, The Hopeful, Saratoga, 1960, Won by Patrice Jacobs' Hail to Reason, marked on reverse
    22¾ in. (57.7 cm.) long; 80 oz.


    Contact Client Service
    • info@christies.com

    • New York +1 212 636 2000

    • London +44 (0)20 7839 9060

    • Hong Kong +852 2760 1766

    • Shanghai +86 21 6355 1766

    Saleroom Notice

    Please note that a party with a financial interest may be bidding on this lot.


    Pre-Lot Text

    HAIL TO REASON


    Nearly 50 years before the dramatic tale of Barbaro played out to a spellbound public, his great-grandsire had endured an injury crisis of his own. Hail to Reason was the dominant two-year-old in the summer and autumn of 1960, racing in the colors of Ethel D. and Hirsch Jacobs's young daughter, Patrice. (Patrice Jacobs was to be involved with champion horses over many years. In 1972, she married Louis Wolfson and together the two bred and raced the Harbor View Farm home-bred Affirmed, which in 1978 became the 11th and most recent winner of the Triple Crown.)
    On a fateful Sunday morning, Hail to Reason stepped on a loose horseshoe on the race track and severely fractured the sesamoid bones in the left forefoot. In those days, veterinarians were not routinely available at the race track on a Sunday morning, but Mr. Jacobs and his son John took immediate action on their own, fashioning a plaster of Paris cast for the injured leg. With later expert veterinary assistance, Hail to Reason was saved for stud duty, being one of the lucky horses that did not develop laminitis as a secondary result of the original injury. (His injury was far less complicated than that of Barbaro, which ultimately was victimized by development of laminitis.)
    The saving of Hail to Reason had a profound and positive effect on the international Thoroughbred scene. He sired winners of each of America's Triple Crown races: Proud Clarion (Kentucky Derby), Personality (Preakness Stakes), and Hail to All (Belmont Stakes). Moreover, he sired Roberto, winner of the seminal event in the history of the Thoroughbred, the historic Epsom Derby in England. Roberto was just one of Hail to Reason's excellent sons which followed the sire's pattern of becoming outstanding stallions on their own. It is Roberto's son Dynaformer which in turn sired the fallen hero Barbaro.
    Other important sons of Hail to Reason include Halo, sire of Kentucky Derby winners Sunny's Halo and Sunday Silence. No fewer than eight individuals in the close-up ancestry of Sunday Silence were bred or raced by Bieber-Jacobs Stable. Sunday Silence, Horse of the Year in 1989, was exported as a stallion to Japan, where his fame transcended the sport into great renown among the general public.
    Thus, when Hirsch Jacobs bred the bargain mare No Third Chance to Turn-to and thereby produced Hail to Reason, it was one of the masterstrokes in his unique career.


    --Edward L. Bowen

    IMAGE CAPTION: Stymie, by Richard Stone Reeves, print, 1967, Courtesy of Jacobs Family