Lot Essay
Professor Seymour Slive relates the present lot to Ruisdael's drawing The Old Haarlem Lock at the Martelaarsgracht, Amsterdam
in the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, although he does not support an attribution to Ruisdael, S. Slive, op. cit., pp. 493-494. While the composition of each drawing is similar, they appear not to show the same buildings. It has been suggested that the underlying structure in black chalk and the details added in ink are by two different hands. The authorship of the black chalk elements, particularly visible in the upper right corner, has been linked to Ruisdael himself, while the second draughtsman responsible for the outlines and figures may have been a pupil or a close contemporary.
We are grateful to Dr. Hans-Ulrich Beck for his kind help with the provenance of the drawing.
in the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, although he does not support an attribution to Ruisdael, S. Slive, op. cit., pp. 493-494. While the composition of each drawing is similar, they appear not to show the same buildings. It has been suggested that the underlying structure in black chalk and the details added in ink are by two different hands. The authorship of the black chalk elements, particularly visible in the upper right corner, has been linked to Ruisdael himself, while the second draughtsman responsible for the outlines and figures may have been a pupil or a close contemporary.
We are grateful to Dr. Hans-Ulrich Beck for his kind help with the provenance of the drawing.