RELEASE: Christie’s Hong Kong 2012 Spring Sale of Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art presents: Masterpieces of the Enameller’s Art from the Mandel Collection

Hong Kong

Christie’s Hong Kong 2012

Spring Sale of Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art presents: 

                                           Masterpieces of the Enameller’s Art from the Mandel Collection

Wednesday, 30 May 2012

James Christie Room, Hong Kong Convention & Exhibition Centre

Hong Kong – Christie’s will present a spectacular array of masterpieces in cloisonné enamel from the Mandel Collection as part of its upcoming Spring Sale of Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art, to be held on 30 May 2012 at the Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Centre. Comprising 30 lots with a total estimate of over HK$40 million/US$5 million, the collection consists of beautiful cloisonné enamel works from the Qing dynasty (17th/18th century), and mostly from the Qianlong period (1736-1795). Cloisonné is an ancient form of metalwork that involves inserting enamel paste made from tinted ground glass into a network of bent copper wire cells soldered onto a bronze or copper surface. When fired at low temperature, the enamel fuses to the body of the object, which is then applied with gold for added brilliance. Magnificent yet delicate, intricate and structured, these works of art exemplify the technical brilliance of craftsmen at the time, while revealing the aesthetic sensitivity and cultural symbolism of the period. This selection was carefully assembled by American collectors Dr Samuel and Annette Mandel,   and features a wide range of Imperial decorative and ceremonial items. For the connoisseur of Chinese cloisonné works, this collection offers a rare opportunity to acquire a group of extraordinary masterpieces with impeccable provenance.  

Rarity in pairs

Leading the sale is a pair of magnificent cloisonné enamel caparisoned elephants from the Qing period (18th century) (illustrated above, estimate: HK$4,000,000-6,000,000/US$518,000-777,000). Admired for its strength, wisdom and longevity in Buddhist religion, the elephant figure was often found in the halls and throne rooms throughout the Imperial palaces. The pair in this sale is made in mirror image, each draped with a harness decorated with a dragon against a background of ruyi clouds, jagged rocks and raging waves, and each carrying a square vase on a gilt bronze saddle.  In addition to their superb quality, these figures have a prestigious provenance which includes the Winston Churchill Estate (by repute), Greek shipping magnate Aristotle Onassis and the Estate of renowned opera singer Maria Callas. A pair of similar elephants is known to be at the Forbidden City, flanking the throne in the hall where the Emperor received his officials and the Empress Cixi summoned ministers to audiences during the reigns of Tongzhi and Guangxu. 

 Another pair of exquisite animals is the very rare peacock censers from the Qianlong period (1736-1795) (illustrated right, estimate: HK$3,000,000-5,000,000/US$385,600-643,000). Peacocks were prized by Emperor Qianlong, who derived great pleasure in watching them in the gardens at court. The luminescent colours and intricate patterns of cloisonné is the perfect medium to replicate the bright colours and resplendent feathers of this beautiful bird, which is modelled perfectly in enamelled shades of turquoise blue and red here. Likely used for ceremonial purposes, this pair is all the more valuable because incense burners in the form of peacocks are extremely rare and seldom come to auction.

 Continuing on the theme of auspicious creatures is a large pair of “Hundred Deer” vases, zun, of the Qianlong period (1736-1795) (illustrated left, estimate: HK$1,800,000-2,500,000/US$231,400-321,000).  The motif of the ‘hundred deer’ dates back to the middle Ming period (late 16th to early 17th century), and the idea of the deer and their young being protected from hunters by Imperial decree was a theme appreciated by Emperor Qianlong.  On the current pair of vases, the deer, symbolising career advancement and long life, are joined by cranes, symbolising longevity. 

 Apart from animal figures, the Chinese fascination with foreigners often led to stylised and whimsical depictions of the human figure of a foreigner in Chinese works of art.   This feature can be seen in a very rare pair of foreigner pricket candle holders of the Qianlong period (1736-1795) in this collection (illustrated right, estimate: HK$2,500,000-3,500,000/US$321,000-450,000). Two figures of foreigners dressed in elaborately decorated vests covering their rounded bellies are on bended knee, smiling and supporting a drip pan.   The current pair had been exhibited in 2007 at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York.

                                                       The cloisonné enamel censer: a balance of beauty and form

 An example of the fine balance of beauty and form is the Chinese censer, illustrated by the large Imperial cloisonné enamel archaistic vessel and cover Fangding, with a Qianlong four-character mark and of the Qianlong period (1736-1795) (illustrated left, estimate: HK$4,000,000-6,000,000/US$514,000-770,000). Based on the shape of ancient bronze vessels from the Zhou dynasty (1046 BC-256 BC), this work features motifs from both ancient times (kui dragons and taotie masks) and the 17th/18th century (Buddhist lions, scrolling chrysanthemums and the phoenix). The juxtaposition of archaic and contemporary decorative elements shows how craftsmen integrated the old and the new in ever creative ways. The present lot is especially important because of its rare large size and its Imperial provenance, indicated by the Qianlong reign mark. 

 Another censer, the Imperial tiered censer and cover of the Qianlong period (1736-1795) is truly a magnificent work of art (illustrated right, estimate: HK$4,000,000-6,000,000/US$518,000-777,000). Multi-tier cloisonné censers of octagonal shape and of this large size are very rare and were mostly used by the Imperial court, where a pair of censers with similar shape, size and tiers was recorded at the emperor’s steps up to the throne in the Palace of Heavenly Purity of the Forbidden City.  These censers were not just for decoration; they were also used by the Imperial household as charcoal-burning braziers for additional heating during the cold Beijing winters.  Heating commenced on the first day of the 11th lunar month - ‘Stove Lighting Day’ -- and each member of the household was allocated an amount of fuel based on their rank.

   Auspicious creatures and divine symbols

 The colours and intricacy of cloisonné enamel lend themselves to lively depictions of both real and mythical creatures.   In addition to the lots featured in pairs above, the rare large fishbowl (Qianlong period 1736-1795) is also a splendid example of animal motifs (illustrated left,  estimate: HK$2,500,000-3,500,000/US$321,000-450,000).  Set in a luscious landscape filled with fruit trees, waterfalls and flowers, the deer and cranes on the exterior are joined by red carp and a range of crustaceans and fish on the inside.  The motifs are clear: the exterior symbolises a long and happy life, and the interior symbolises purity and clarity. 

In contrast, more ferocious creatures such as the eagle, dragon and mythical beasts are featured in a champion vase and cover of the Qing dynasty (17th/18th century) (illustrated right, estimate: HK$1,200,000-1,800,000/US$154,000-231,400). The champion vase was conceived as a trophy and dates back to the Han dynasty (206 BC- 220 AD).

# # #

IMAGES available for download:'s%20Hong%20Kong%20Auctions/WOA/RELEASE/Mandel%20Collection/Images/  

Visit Christie’s Website at

Complete catalogue available online at or via the Christie’s iPhone app

 Christie’s Hong Kong Spring 2012 Auctions Schedule


Christie’s Hong Kong Office Viewing Gallery

Saturday, 21 April



Public viewing begins on 24 May

Hong Kong Convention & Exhibition Centre

Friday, 25 May


Saturday, 26 May


Asian 20th Century & Contemporary Art (Evening Sale)

Sunday, 27 May


Asian 20th Century Art (Day Sale)

Asian Contemporary Art (Day Sale)


Monday, 28 May

Chinese Classical Paintings and Calligraphy

Tuesday, 29 May

Chinese Modern Paintings


Wednesday, 30 May

Masterpieces of the Enameller’s Art from the Mandel Collection

The Imperial Sale

Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art



About Christie’s

Christie’s, the world's leading art business, had global auction and private sales in 2011 that totaled £3.6 billion/US$5.7 billion. Christie’s is a name and place that speaks of extraordinary art, unparalleled service and expertise, as well as international glamour. Founded in 1766 by James Christie, Christie's has since conducted the greatest and most celebrated auctions through the centuries providing a popular showcase for the unique and the beautiful. Christie’s offers over 450 auctions annually in over 80 categories, including all areas of fine and decorative arts, jewellery, photographs, collectibles, wine, and more. Prices range from US$200 to over US$100 million. Christie's also has a long and successful history conducting private sales for its clients in all categories, with emphasis on Post-War and Contemporary, Impressionist and Modern, Old Masters and Jewellery.  Private sales totaled £502 million / US$808.6m in 2011, an increase of 44% on the previous year.

 Christie’s has a global presence with 53 offices in 32 countries and 10 salerooms around the world including in London, New York, Paris, Geneva, Milan, Amsterdam, Dubai, Zürich, and Hong Kong. More recently, Christie’s has led the market with expanded initiatives in growth markets such as Russia, China, India and the United Arab Emirates, with successful sales and exhibitions in Beijing, Mumbai and Dubai.

*Estimates do not include buyer’s premium. Sales totals are hammer price plus buyer’s premium and do not reflect costs, financing fees or application of buyer’s or seller’s credits.


About Christie’s

Founded in 1766, Christie’s is a world-leading art and luxury business. Renowned and trusted for its expert live and online auctions, as well as its bespoke private sales, Christie’s offers a full portfolio of global services to its clients, including art appraisal, art financing, international real estate and education. Christie’s has a physical presence in 46 countries, throughout the Americas, Europe, Middle East, and Asia Pacific, with flagship international sales hubs in New York, London, Hong Kong, Paris and Geneva. It also is the only international auction house authorized to hold sales in mainland China (Shanghai).

Christie’s auctions span more than 80 art and luxury categories, at price points ranging from $200 to over $100 million. In recent years, Christie’s has achieved the world record price for an artwork at auction (Leonardo da Vinci’s Salvator Mundi, 2017), for a 20th century artwork (Andy Warhol’s Shot Sage Blue Marilyn, 2022) and for a work by a living artist (Jeff Koons’ Rabbit, 2019). Christie's is also recognised as a reference for prestigious single owner collections, having auctioned 8 of the 10 most important collections in history.

Christie’s Private Sales offers a seamless service for buying and selling art, jewellery and watches outside of the auction calendar, working exclusively with Christie’s specialists at a client’s individual pace.

Recent innovations at Christie’s include the groundbreaking sale of the first NFT for a digital work of art ever offered at a major auction house (Beeple’s Everydays, March 2021), with the unprecedented acceptance of cryptocurrency as a means of payment. As an industry leader in digital innovation, Christie’s also continues to pioneer new technologies that are redefining the business of art, including use of hologram technology to tour life-size 3D objects around the world, and the creation of viewing and bidding experiences that integrate augmented reality, global livestreaming, buy-now channels, and hybrid sales formats. 

Christie’s is dedicated to advancing responsible culture throughout its business and communities worldwide, including achieving sustainability through net zero carbon emissions by 2030, and actively using its platform in the art world to amplify under-represented voices and support positive change.

Browse, bid, discover, and join us for the best of art and luxury at: or by downloading Christie’s apps. The COVID-related re-opening status of our global locations is available here.