Lot Essay
The quality of the carving on this screen is extremely fine. Indeed, in Wang et al., it is described as "the best remaining example of its type"
A comparable twelve-panel screen, but without the upper 'cut-out' apertures, was sold in our Hong Kong saleroom, October 30-31, 1994, lot 419
Compare, also, the eighteenth century twelve-panel screen included by John Kwang-Ming Ang in the exhibition, The Beauty of Huanghuali, and illustrated in the Catalogue, no. 26. While the background scrollwork and large lower panels containing stylized shou characters recall the motifs on the present screen, the quality of the carving on the present screen is finer and more detailed. See, also, the twelve-panel Kangxi screen with stylized auspicious characters against scrollwork, inset with the original paintings, belonging to Charles R. Gracie and Sons Inc., illustrated by Sarah Handler, "The Chinese Screen", JCCFS, Summer 1993, pp. 26-27
A comparable twelve-panel screen, but without the upper 'cut-out' apertures, was sold in our Hong Kong saleroom, October 30-31, 1994, lot 419
Compare, also, the eighteenth century twelve-panel screen included by John Kwang-Ming Ang in the exhibition, The Beauty of Huanghuali, and illustrated in the Catalogue, no. 26. While the background scrollwork and large lower panels containing stylized shou characters recall the motifs on the present screen, the quality of the carving on the present screen is finer and more detailed. See, also, the twelve-panel Kangxi screen with stylized auspicious characters against scrollwork, inset with the original paintings, belonging to Charles R. Gracie and Sons Inc., illustrated by Sarah Handler, "The Chinese Screen", JCCFS, Summer 1993, pp. 26-27