THE GRAND DUKE MICHAEL PAVLOVICH SERVICE
A magnificent French Empire silver-gilt dinner-service
No VAT will be charged on the hammer price, but VA… Read more THE PROPERTY OF A GENTLEMAN 
THE GRAND DUKE MICHAEL PAVLOVICH SERVICE A magnificent French Empire silver-gilt dinner-service

MARKS OF MARTIN-GUILLAUME BIENNAIS AND JEAN-CHARLES CAHIER, PARIS, 1809-1819

Details
THE GRAND DUKE MICHAEL PAVLOVICH SERVICE
A magnificent French Empire silver-gilt dinner-service
Marks of Martin-Guillaume Biennais and Jean-Charles Cahier, Paris, 1809-1819
Comprising,
A large two-handled soup-tureen, cover, liner and stand, the stand on six twin lion's paw and foliage feet, the vase-shaped tureen with two acanthus, anthemion and demi-Bacchante bracket handles, with plain two-handled liner and detachable domed cover with Bacchus, leopard and Bacchante finial, the stand, body and cover each applied twice with crown monogram, one on stand lacking, the stand applied with putti, scaly dolphins and bulls' masks, the body with a band of winged demi-male figures hung with garlands between, mark of Cahier, marked on stand, stem, calyx, bowl, liner, cover and finial, 20¾in. (53cm.) wide, 426oz. (13,247gr.)

A pair of plain circular soup-tureens each on spreading circular foot, with anthemion borders, the sides applied with two winged putti handles, one with trumpet, the detachable domed cover with bud finial and acanthus calyx, the bodies and covers each engraved twice with monogram and crown, mark of Biennais, marked in bases only, the covers unmarked, possibly later replacements
14½in. (36.5cm.) long, 202oz. (6,286gr.)

An oval soup-tureen and cover on spreading foot, the two bracket handles with rosette terminals, the detachable domed cover with acanthus bud finial, the body and cover applied with monogram and crown, mark of Biennais, marked on body, cover and handles, the finial unmarked, 18in. (46cm.) long, 105oz. (3,284gr.)

A small oval soup-tureen and cover, on spreading foot, the two bracket handles with fluted terminals, the detachable domed cover with acanthus bud finial, the body engraved twice with a monogram with crown above, the cover similarly applied twice, mark of Cahier, marked on body, cover and calyx, the finial unmarked, 12½in. (31.8cm.) long, 54oz. (1,700gr.)

A pair of vegetable-dishes, stands and covers, plain circular, each with anthemion border, the detachable domed covers with acanthus bud and calyx finials, each engraved once with monogram with crown above, the covers, by Cahier, the dishes, maker's mark lacking, the stands, by Biennais, marked on dishes, stands and covers, the stands, 10½in. (26.6cm.) long, the dishes, 9¼in. (23.5cm.) long, 139oz. (4,325gr.)

A pair of vegetable-dishes and covers, similar, smaller, similarly engraved, maker's mark lacking, except one dish by Cahier, marked on dishes and covers, the finials unmarked, 8in. (20.5cm.) long, 65oz. (2,032gr.)

A pair, similar, plain, the detachable domed covers with acanthus bud finials, the dishes and covers engraved with a monogram with crown above, one dish by Biennais, one by Cahier, the covers with French control marks, one cover by Biennais, the finials unmarked, 7 7/8in. (20cm.) long, 103oz. (3,208gr.)

A pair of sauce-boats and ladles, each sauce-boat oval on conforming foot and with reeded anthemion scroll handle, with Vetruvian rosette scroll border, the reeded ladles chased with monogram with crown above, the sauce-boats similarly engraved twice, one sauce-boat by Biennais, the other by Cahier, one ladle with indistinct maker's mark, the other unmarked, the sauce-boats 9 1/8in. (23cm.) long, 48oz. (1,518gr.)
A set of eight double salt-cellars, each on six twin lion's paw feet and octagonal base, the frame on six winged demi-lion monopodiae and with detachable central Bacchante and garland handle, each with detachable plain circular bowls, the bases chased with anthemion and scrolls and applied with monogram with crown above, four by Cahier, four by Biennais, marked on bases, frames and bowls, 7¾in. (19.5cm.) long, 232oz. (7,235gr.)

A plain oval warming-stand and domed cover, with hot-water compartment and drop-ring handles, the cover engraved twice with monogram with crown above, the stand by Biennais, the cover by Cahier, marked on base and cover, 22in. (56cm.) long, 256oz. (7,985gr.)

A set of forty-seven dinner-plates, each with anthemion border and engraved with monogram with crown above, mark of Biennais, 9½in. (24cm.) diam., 900oz. (27,990gr.)

A set of four second-course dishes, similar, each circular and with anthemion border, similarly engraved, by Cahier, 10¾in. (27.2cm.) diam., 104oz. (3,235gr.)

A set of six, similar, similarly engraved, by Biennais, 11¾in. (30cm.) diam., 172oz. (5,351gr.)

Four meat-dishes, each oval and with anthemion border, similarly engraved, various sizes, three by Cahier, one lacking maker's mark, 13¾in. (35cm.) to 18in. (46cm.) long, 178oz. (5,547gr.)
The monogram and crown are those of Grand Duke Michael Pavlovitch (1798-1849), son of Tsar Paul 1 (r.1798-1801) and brother of Tsar Alexander 1 (r.1801-1825) and Tsar Nicholas 1 (r.1825-1855)
Provenance
The majority supplied to Grand Duke Michael Pavlovich (1798-1849) son of Tsar Paul I (r.1798-1801) and brother of Tsar Alexander I (r.1801-1825) and Tsar Nicholas I (r.1825-1855)
Probably Alexander Lyudvigovich, 2nd Baron Stieglitz (d.1884), St. Petersburg
Confiscated either from the Stieglitz family or the Stieglitz Museum by the Soviet Government, circa 1917
Property of a Lady; Christie's London, 30 June 1965, lot 117 (part).
Literature
Dessins originaux d'orfèvrerie et de meubles ornés de bronze provenant de l'atelier de Biennais, orfèvre de Napoleon 1er et attribués a Percier, Paris, 1801, on which the central tureen is based
S. Grandjean, 'A Dinner Service by Biennais at the Rijksmuseum', Connoisseur, October 1958, pp.84-87
Connaissance des Arts Collection, Les Grands Orfèvres, Paris, 1965, pp.288-289 (part)
Masterpieces of English and European Silver and Gold, Sydney, 1980 The Glory of the Goldsmith, Magnificent Gold and Silver from the Al-Tajir Collection, 1989, no.20 p.34 (part)

Exhibited
London, Christie's, The Glory of the Goldsmith, Magnificent Gold and Silver from the Al-Tajir Collection, 1989, no.20 (part)
Sydney, The Art Gallery of New South Wales, Masterpieces of English and European Silver and Gold, January, 1980
Special notice
No VAT will be charged on the hammer price, but VAT at 17.5% will be added to the buyer's premium which is invoiced on a VAT inclusive basis

Lot Essay

Grand Duke Michael Pavlovich was the fourth son of Tsar Paul 1 and his wife Marie Feodorovna, Princess of Würtemberg. He received a military education and travelled extensively throughout Russia; he was appointed Commander of the Guards' Infantry Brigade, and took part in the war against Turkey to liberate Greece. He was awarded the Order of St. George and in 1831 became Chief of all Military Schools in Russia. He married his cousin Princess Helen of Würtemberg by whom he had six daughters. He died in 1849 at the age of 51.

It is difficult to imagine a more perfect setting for the vast silver-gilt dinner service ordered from Martin-Guillame Biennais and Jean-Charles Cahier by Grand Duke Michael Pavlovich than the latter's magnificent Russian neoclassical palace, designed by Carlo Rossi and now the home of the State Russian Museum in St. Petersburg. Paid for in part by his father, Tsar Paul 1 (r.1798-1801) and then by his brothers, Tsar Alexander 1 (r.1801-1825) and Tsar Nicholas 1 (r.1825-1855), the palace cost some 9 million roubles to complete. It was built between 1819 and 1823 with every detail of the interior design being overseen by its great architect. Indeed the interiors were considered to be the finest in Russia until the reconstruction of the Hermitage in 1837 following a disastrous fire.

Both Michael and his elder brother Nicholas patronised the leading Parisian silversmiths of the day, among them Biennais and Cahier. Indeed, the two firms seem to have co-operated on Michael Pavlovitch's huge commission, as their marks are found on differing but component parts of some of the same large objects. It is thought that in 1821 Biennais, who had no likely successor, sold his business, including designs and archives, to Cahier. Although he was well placed with the restored Bourbon regime, Cahier's business eventually foundered and he went bankrupt in 1828.

It appears that, like so many artistic treasures in Russia, the service was confiscated, this time from the museum founded by Baron Stieglitz, following the Revolution and sold off by the Soviet Government in the 1920s or 1930s to raise much-needed foreign currency. It is interesting to note that the vastly wealthy Baron Stieglitz adopted a daughter who was said to be the illegitimate child of Grand Duke Michael Pavlovich.
A substantial part of the service next appeared as a single lot at auction at Christie's in London in 1965. Since then a number of pieces including a tea and coffee service and table silver have been sold off, while other pieces, such as the smaller tureens, have been re-united with it. Examples from the service can be found in the Hermitage, St. Petersburg and the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam. By far the most significant item, a magnificent soup-tureen and cover, weighing some 14 kilos, by Cahier and clearly derived from a Percier and Fontaine design, remains as the centrepiece of the service that forms the present lot. The pair to it is to be found in the Santo Spirito Foundation in Lisbon.

We are grateful to Marina Lopato of the Hermitage Museum, St. Petersburg for information on the history of the Michael Pavlovich service in the 19th and early part of the 20th century.

More from Russian Works of Art

View All
View All