Baron François-Pascal-Simon, called Baron Gérard (Rome 1770-1837 Paris)
THE PROPERTY OF A EUROPEAN NOBLE FAMILY
Baron François-Pascal-Simon, called Baron Gérard (Rome 1770-1837 Paris)

Daniel Proving Susanna's Innocence

Details
Baron François-Pascal-Simon, called Baron Gérard (Rome 1770-1837 Paris)
Daniel Proving Susanna's Innocence
signed with initials and dated 'F.G. 1790.' (on the step, lower right)
oil on canvas
44 7/8 x 57 5/8 in. (114 x 146.5 cm.)
Provenance
In the collection of the artist until his death; (+) sale, Paillet-Bonnefons, Paris, 27 [=1st day] April 1837, lot 22.
Monsieur de Genoude, by 1847; from whom acquired by
Henri-Alexandre Gérard (1818-1903), the nephew of the artist, and by descent to the present owners.
Literature
C. Lenormant, François Gérard, peintre d'histoire, Paris, 1846, p. 18.
H.A. Gérard, Oeuvre du Baron François Gérard, Paris, 1857, V and VII.
Idem, Correspondance de François Gérard peintre d'histoire avec les artistes et les personnages de son temps, Paris, 1867, p. 6.
Idem, Lettres adressées au Baron François Gérard peintre d'histoire par les artistes et les personnages célèbres de son temps, Paris, 1888, pp. 4-5.
G. Lacambre, De David à Delacroix, la peinture française de 1774 à 1830, exhibition catalogue, Paris, 1974, p. 428.
J.-F. Heim, C. Béraud and P. Heim, Les salons de peinture de la révolution française (1789-1799), Paris, 1989, pp. 219 and 222.
A Sérullaz, Gérard, Girodet, Gros L'Atelier de David, exhibition catalogue, Paris, 2005, p. 73.
Exhibited
Salon of 1793, no 113.
Paris, Palais des Beaux-Arts de la Ville de Paris, David et ses élèves, 7 April - 9 June 1913, no. 117.
Engraved
by E. Rosotte.

Lot Essay

The subject is taken from the book of Daniel (Old Testament, Greek Addenda to the book of Daniel, XIII), set during the Exile in Babylon. Susanna, a young and beautiful wife, was secretly desired by two Elders who plotted to seduce her after seeing her bathing. Having failed, they accused her of adultery and she was condemned to death. The young Daniel cross-examined the Elders, and, by the device of separating them from each other, proved Susanna's innocence; the Elders were themselves sentenced to death instead. The choice of this particular moment in Susanna's history provides an important insight into the artist's intent: previous artists had generally preferred to depict the intimate and sensuous scene of Susanna's bath, in the present work, however, emphasis is given to the triumph of justice, understood as an exemplum virtutis.

A drawing related to this painting, squared and highly finished, is in the collection of the Louvre, Paris; it was part of a group of 171 drawings that were bought by the Louvre from the descendants of Baron Gérard in 1972. The drawing bears the inscription: 'La chaste Suzanne justifié par le jeune David (sic) tableau du concours pour le grand prix de Rome en 1790. Il n'a pas ( ?) été terminé'; it is probably a ricordo, made between 1790 and 1793, rather than a preparatory work (E. Lerner in A. Sirullaz, op. cit).

We are grateful to Miss Elodie Lerner for her assistance in the cataloguing of this and the following lot; Miss Lerner has written her thesis on Gérard's work as a history painter. We are also grateful to Philippe Bordes who draws parallels between the present composition and that of Susanna and the Elders by Antoine Coypel (Saint Quentin, Musée Municipal Triboulloy).

More from Important Old Master Paintings, Part I

View All
View All