Giuliano di Simone (active in Lucca 1383-1397)
PROPERTY FROM THE ESTATE OF EDWIN L. WEISL, JR. (Lots 202-205, 248) Edwin L. Weisl, Jr. was among the last of a generation of collectors who were passionate about the arts of the early Italian Renaissance. His acquaintance with Robert Lehman, his father's close friend and confidant, and through him with Bernard Berenson, were formative experiences that determined his own almost obsessive preoccupation with the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries in Siena, Florence, and Venice. Throughout a busy life in legal and public service, he invariably preferred debating artistic discoveries or obscure attributions (about which he was astonishingly well-informed) rather than political or economic principles (about which he was scarcely less well-informed), and the news he wished to hear was of his friends in the art world rather than from Wall Street or in Washington. He and his wife Barbara - who had herself emerged from the art world as a critic and friend of such modern masters as Franz Kline and Willem de Kooning - furnished their homes on the model of Berenson's Villa I Tatti. More than anything else, it seemed they enjoyed, to a degree rarely encountered today, the company of their paintings, sculptures, textiles, ceramics, and above all books, and the urgency, honesty, and integrity of their feelings for these things with which they surrounded themselves was utterly infectious. A former United States assistant attorney general for land and natural resources (1965-7) and the civil division (1967-9), and the director of the New York State Democratic Campaign in 1964, Ed Weisl was also the Commissioner of Parks, Recreation, and Cultural Affairs for the City of New York under the Beame administration, from 1973 to 1975. After graduating from Yale in 1951 and Columbia Law School in 1956, he began his legal career at Simpson, Thatcher, and Bartlett, the firm to which he returned after his time in Washington. His artistic interests later led him to become the president of the International Foundation for Art Research and to serve on the board of directors of the Robert Lehman Foundation, the Council of the Villa I Tatti (Harvard Center for Renaissance Studies), and the visiting committee of the Department of European Paintings at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Given his claim to have spent his entire law-school career looking at pictures in Columbia University's Art History Library, these events hardly seem surprising. Although the art world was his great and abiding love, he was also intensely proud of his naval service as a lieutenant (j.g.) on the Destroyer the U.S.S. Beatty in the Korean War, as well as of his prominent if "behind-the-scenes" role in Lyndon Johnson's Civil Rights program in Mississippi and Alabama in the late 1960s. His generosity to the Metropolitan Museum and his unfailing, enthusiastic commitment to the activities of the Robert Lehman Foundation remain as a permanent contribution to the cultural life of the one city he loved even more than his spiritual home in the Tuscany of the Renaissance. Angela J. Weisl and Laurence B. Kanter.
Giuliano di Simone (active in Lucca 1383-1397)

The Lamentation

Details
Giuliano di Simone (active in Lucca 1383-1397)
The Lamentation
tempera and gold on panel
7 1/8 x 23 7/8 in. (18.1 x 60.6 cm.)
Provenance
Jocelyn Museum of Art, Omaha; Sotheby's, New York, 6 October 1998, lot 97A, as 'School of Lorenzo Monaco', where purchased by the late owner.
Literature
Linda Pisani, 'Giuliano di Simone', Sumptuosa tabula picta: pittori a Lucca tra gotico e rinascimento, Livorno, 1998, pp. 184 and 194, fig 137.

Lot Essay

In attitudes of pious contemplation, seven figures are gathered around the dead Christ, whose body rests on the knees of the Virgin Mary, St. Mary Aegyptica (?) and St. Anne. In his traditional position at the head of Christ, Joseph of Arimathea holds the three nails, instruments of the Passion. Next to him, St. John the Evangelist supports Christ's torso and at Christ's feet kneels St. Mary Magdalen, behind whom stands Nicodemus. Christ's body, while apparently laid on the knees of the female saints, is presented, almost eucharistically to the viewer. While the narrative is enlivened by a vibrant palette of contrasting reds, blues and greens, Giuliano sets an appropriatly mournful mood through subtle allusions to the Crucifixion: the bloody base of the cross, the foot of a ladder and a skull and above all through the powerfully conceived rocky landscape, whose crevices modeled in deep shades of grey converge upon and envelop the protagonists at the dismal scene.

Giuliano di Simone is a Lucchese artist whose career was first defined (in 1971) by Alvar Gonzales-Palacios, who grouped a corpus of panels and frescoes around a signed and dated Virgin and Child Enthroned of 1389 in Castiglione di Garfagna. This artist, who was an exact contemporary of Angelo Puccinelli, was evidently influenced by the boldly modeled, neo-Giottesque narrative style of Spinello Aretino, who worked around Lucca in the 1380s. While Boskovits and, more recently Pisani, hypothesize that Giuliano was already producing works that demonstrate a knowledge of Florentine painting in the 1370s - and may indeed have been in Florence himself - it is for his paintings executed in the idiom of Spinello that Giuliano is best known. These include a magnificent Crucifixion (Kunsthaus, Zurich) and a beautiful Madonna and Child with four saints, angels and Eve (Galleria Nazionale, Parma), similar to a tabernacle of an almost identical composition also by Giuliano in the Louvre, Paris.

This moving predella panel was deaccessioned by the Jocelyn Art Museum in 1998, when it was catalogued as a work from the circle of Lorenzo Monaco. It does bear a superficial resemblance to a predella of the same subject by Lorenzo (private collection, New York) first published by Gaudenz Freuler in 1993. This parallel was noted by Pisani (op. cit.) who was the first to publish this predella as a work by Giuliano. The attribution, however, was made by Pia Palladino, who recognized the authorship of this panel and proposed that it formed part of a now dismembered altarpiece, the central element of which, a Madonna and Child, is in Moriano Castello, Lucca. The lateral panels (one of which is cut in half) are now in S. Martino, Bargecchia, the church for which the triptych may have originally been painted and that stands next to what was once the church of S. Lorenzo in Conca. In poor condition, the Moriano altarpiece has been variously considered both an early and late work. Pisani dates it to the mid 1380s after Spinello's arrival in Lucca but prior to the Castiglione Garfagnara Madonna and Child.

More from Important Old Master Paintings, Part II

View All
View All