John La Farge (American, 1835-1910)
John La Farge (American, 1835-1910)

The Virgin and St. John the Evangelist at the Foot of the Cross

Details
John La Farge (American, 1835-1910)
The Virgin and St. John the Evangelist at the Foot of the Cross
oil on panel, shaped top
95½ x 29½ in. (243 x 75 cm.)
Painted in 1862-3
a pair (2)
Provenance
Commissioned by the Reverend William Quinn, New York, 1862-3.
Peirce and Co., Boston, 19-20 November 1878, unsold and returned to the artist.
John La Farge, New York and Newport, RI, 1878-1884; Ortgies and Co., New York, 17 April 1884, lot 36 to William Collins Whitney, New York, (d. 1904).
By descent to his son, Harry Payne Whitney, New York, (d. 1930).
By descent to his wife, Mrs. Harry Payne (Gertrude Vanderbilt) Whitney, New York, 1930-1931.
Gifted to the Whitney Museum of American Art, New York, 1931.
with Knoedler and Co., New York, 1950 from where purchased by Cornelius Vanderbilt Whitney, New York, 1950.
Almost certainly purchased by Duarte Pinto Coelho, 1983, as part of the sale of the house and contents at Trujillo, Spain.
Exhibited
New York, National Academy of Design, Catalogue of the Thirty-Eighth Annual Exhibition, 1863, no. 1.
New York, Art Students' League, [Monthly Exhibition], January 1880.
New York, American Art Galleries Summer Exhibition of Paintings by American Artists 9-30 June, 1883.
New York, American Art Association, Exhibition of Paintings by Members of the Art Club of New York, 12-28 February 1883, no. 83 and 84.
New York, Ferargil Galleries, Watercolors, Stained Glass, and Oil Paintings by John La Farge, February 1923 (not listed).
New York, Whitney Museum of American Art, Summer Exhibition, 3 May-12 November 1932, no. 53 and 54.
New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art, An Exhibition of the Work of John La Farge, 23 March-26 April 1936, no. 11 and 12 (illus.).

If you wish to view the condition report of this lot, please sign in to your account.

Sign in
View condition report

Lot Essay

Born in New York, John la Farge studied to become a lawyer until he was inspired to pursue his artistic goals following a trip to Paris. When he returned he took up the study of painting under the tutelage of William Morris Hunt (1824-1879) at Newport, Rhode Island. As well as being a prolific painter, La Farge was an innovative book illustrator and designed murals and stained glass windows.

As La Farge's first attempt to create a "great decorative ensemble" for a religious context, this part triptych occupies an important role in the artist's career. The commission unfortunately is only vaguely understood. Around 1862, La Farge was asked by Reverend William Quinn to design an altarpiece for Saint Peter's Roman Catholic Church in New York City. Saint Peter's was the first Catholic parish in New York, founded just after the Revolutionary War. Its church on Barclay Street dated from 1837 and Quinn had been pastor of the church since 1849.
The altarpiece was to take the form of a triptych representing the Crucifixion of Christ in the centre panel with Saint John the Evangelist on the right and the Virgin Mary on the left. Only the two side panels were executed. Few details are known about why the altarpiece was never completed aside from the observation of several early critics that the triptych was rejected by the Church.
In his design, La Farge drew upon Italian altarpieces of the quattrocento. The poses and attenuated silhouettes of the figures are especially reminiscent of work from the Byzantine and Sienese schools of the late fourteenth and early fifteenth centuries. Unlike such precedents, however, La Farge gave the narrative a modern feeling through the introduction of an atmospheric landscape and breath-taking perspective. He set the narrative before an expansive landscape that stretches far into the distance as if giving a view from Mount Calvary. The view actually looks east from the ledge above the west side of Nelson's Pond, the body of water visible in the middle distance. Beyond the pond is a stretch of meadows and dunes and Second Beach in Middletown, Rhode Island, adjacent to where La Farge lived at the time. The figures partake of this quest for modern realism. The features of Saint John are those of William James, La Farge's companion in William Morris Hunt's Newport studio and close friend during the early 1860s (cf. a study for the head, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston). The features of the Virgin Mary are those of the artist's wife, Margaret Mason Perry La Farge. Many sketches for a dead crucified Christ, rendered realistically with his broken anatomy slumped over and still nailed to the cross, are found in sketchbooks and on loose sheets in portfolios dating from around this time.

We are grateful to James L. Yarnall, Ph.D., Associate Professor in the Department of Art, Salve Regina University, Newport, Rhode Island for this catalogue entry.

More from The Duarte Pinto Coelho Collection From the distinguished decorator's houses in Madrid and Trujillo, Spain

View All
View All