Audio: Property from the Metropolitan Museum of Art
The Master of the Plump-Cheeked Madonnas (active Bruges, first quarter of the 16th century)
1 More
PROPERTY FROM THE METROPOLITAN MUSEUM OF ART, SOLD TO BENEFIT THE EUROPEAN PAINTINGS ACQUISITIONS FUND
The Master of the Plump-Cheeked Madonnas (active Bruges, first quarter of the 16th century)

The Virgin and Child with Saints Dominic, Augustine, Margaret and Barbara

Details
The Master of the Plump-Cheeked Madonnas (active Bruges, first quarter of the 16th century)
The Virgin and Child with Saints Dominic, Augustine, Margaret and Barbara
oil on canvas, transferred from panel
38¾ x 51 in. (98.4 x 129.5 cm.)
Provenance
David P. Sellar, London; his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 6 June 1889, lot 27, as Gerard David.
Jean Dollfus, Paris, by 1904; (+), Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 1 April 1912, lot 83, as Gerard David (50,000 FF to Seligmann).
with Jacques Seligmann, Paris, from whom acquired in 1926 by
Georges Blumenthal, New York, by whom bequeathed in 1941 to
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.
Literature
A. Alexandre, 'La Collection de M. Jean Dolfus', Les arts, III, 1904, p. 4, as Gerard David.
H. Frantz, 'La curiosité: collections Jean Dollfus (tableaux anciens, objets d'art),' L'art décoratif, XXVI, 5 May 1912, pp. 290-291, as Gerard David.
S. Reinach, Répertoire de peintures du moyen age et de la renaissance (1280-1580), V, Paris, 1922, p. 414, as attributed to Gerard David.
S. Rubinstein-Bloch, 'Paintings-Early Schools,' Catalogue of the Collection of George and Florence Blumenthal, I, Paris, 1926, pl. 50, as possibly by Adrian Isenbrandt.
H.B. Wehle and M. Salinger, The Metropolitan Museum of Art: A Catalogue of Early Flemish, Dutch and German Paintings, New York, 1947, pp. 119-120, as 'Ambrosius Benson (?)'.
F. Bologna, 'Nuove attribuzioni a Jan Provost,' Musées Royaux des Beaux-Arts Bulletin, V, 1956, p. 29, n. 18, as not by Benson and related to Provoost.
G. Marlier, Ambrosius Benson et la peinture à Bruges au temps de Charles-Quint, Damme, 1957, p. 335, no. 264, as not by Benson.
E. Larsen. Les primitifs flamands au Musée Metropolitain de New York, Utrecht, 1960, p. 82, as attributed to Ambrosius Benson.
G. Seligman, Merchants of Art: 1880-1960, Eighty Years of Professional Collecting, New York, 1961, p. 120, as Flemish Primitive.
M.W. Ainsworth and K. Christiansen, eds., From Van Eyck to Bruegel: Early Netherlandish Painting in The Metropolitan Museum of Art, exhibition catalogue, New York, 1998, p. 407, as Netherlandish (Antwerp) Painter, 1510.
D. Martens, 'Le Maître aux Madones Joufflues: Essai de monographie sur un anonyme brugeois du XVIme siècle,' Wallraf-Richartz-Jahrbuch LXI, 2000, pp. 112-115, 141, n. 23, figs. 1, 6, 15.
D. Martens, 'Une oeuvre méconnue du Maître aux Madones Joufflues,' Cahiers du Musée des Beaux-Arts de Lyon, 2002, pp. 30-31.
Exhibited
Colorado, Colorado Springs Fine Arts Center, Old Masters from the Metropolitan, 24 April-30 June 1949 (no catalogue).
Lexington, Washington and Lee University, The Metropolitan Museum of Art Loan Exhibit, 30 October 1950-15 January 1951, no. 1, as Ambrosius Benson.
Athens, Georgia Museum of Art, University of Georgia, 15 February-5 April 1951 (no catalogue).
Oxford, Ohio, School of Fine Arts, Miami University, 1 November-5 December 1952 (no catalogue).
Dallas, Dallas Museum of Art, Religious Art of the Western World, 23 March-25 May 1958 (no catalogue).
Wilkes-Barre, Miners National Bank, Loan Exhibition from The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1-15 December 1964, no. 3, as Ambrosius Benson.
Columbus, Georgia, Columbus Museum of Arts and Crafts, A Centenary of a Great Museum: Old Master Paintings, 1 November 1969-31 October 1970.
Billings, Montana, Yellowstone Art Center, Christmas-the Nativity, 1-31 December 1978 (no catalogue).
Bellevue, Washington, Bellevue Art Museum, Five Thousand Years of Faces, 30 January-30 July 1983 (entry by T. Schlotterback).

If you wish to view the condition report of this lot, please sign in to your account.

Sign in
View condition report

Lot Essay

In 2000, Didier Martens assembled a group of seven paintings around this serene altarpiece, which he considered to be the most important work by an anonymous Bruges painter active in the first half of the 16th century (op. cit.). Stylistically, these paintings resemble the mature work of Gerard David and Ambrosius Benson, yet are distinguished by the idiosyncratically rounded, full faces of the figures. On the basis of this key and consistent identifying trait, Martens named the artist 'The Master of the Plump-Cheeked Madonnas'.

The present picture is a sacra conversazione, a format popular in mid-15th-century Italy, in which saints from different epochs are grouped together in a single space. The Virgin and Child are enthroned within a vast, verdant landscape with carefully-observed architecture in the distance. They are attended by a court of two male and two female saints, arranged in a frieze-like manner. As Martens has observed, the Mary and Christ figures appear to have been inspired by the designs of Rogier van der Weyden, which were still widely circulating in Bruges around 1500. Martens further noted that the pattern for the Virgin and Child was also used in a painting formerly in the Musées de Liège by a painter in the Circle of Joos van Cleve (ibid., pp. 114-155, fig 3.).

Saint Dominic (1170-1221), the founder of the Dominican Order, stands at the far left, dressed in his black and white habit. Before him is a dog with a lighted torch in its mouth, the traditional emblem of the Dominicans, who, due to the ferociousness of their faith and as a pun on Saint Dominic's name, were known as the "dogs of God" (domini canes). Saint Augustine of Hippo (354-430) stands to his right, wearing a red and gold mitre decorated with an embossed relief of the Virgin and Child standing on a crescent moon. He holds a crozier and a heart, a symbol of his religious fervor. Flanking the Virgin is Saint Margaret trampling a dragon. According to the Golden Legend, the Prefect of Antioch wished to marry her, but she refused and was jailed. While praying for her true enemy to be revealed, she was swallowed whole by the devil in the form of a dragon. After making the sign of the cross, she burst forth unscathed, and as such became the patron saint of pregnant women. Dressed in an elegant green gown with golden damask sleeves, the radiant Margaret reads from her prayer book while gesturing in benediction with her right hand. As Martens has noted (ibid., p. 114), similar figures are found in the wings of two Bruges altarpieces, the first by the Master of Saint Ildefonse (Musée de Cluny, Paris), and the second by a follower of Pieter Pourbus (Musées Royaux des Beaux-Arts, Brussels). In the present painting, Saint Barbara appears at far right, holding a martyr's palm and standing before the tower in which she was imprisoned by her father, Dioscurus, to protect her from suitors. These four saints would have been selected by the patrons, and may have held special significance for the owners of the chapel where the panel was originally displayed. While no donor figures are present, they may have appeared with additional saints in altar wings as this panel likely once formed the central element of a triptych.

The detailed treatment of the vegetation in the foreground is reminiscent of tapestries, the costliest and most luxurious art form of the 16th century. Many of the flowering plants and herbs are identifiable and were chosen for their symbolic significance, including wild strawberries, snapdragons, dandelions (a symbol of Christ's passion), sage, and lily of the valley. Such a meticulous description of plant life is typical of Bruges painting of the late 15th and early 16th centuries, and is often found in the work of artists active in the circle of Gerard David. Sensitively-rendered details such as the reflection of the trees on the surface of the water and the minute travelers in the background point to the Master's talent for combining spiritual vision with earthly beauty.

More from Renaissance

View All
View All