René Magritte (1898-1967)
Artist's Resale Right ("Droit de Suite"). Artist's… Read more PROPERTY FROM AN IMPORTANT PRIVATE BELGIAN COLLECTION
René Magritte (1898-1967)

Les fleurs de l'abîme

René Magritte (1898-1967)
Les fleurs de l'abîme
signed 'Magritte' (lower left); inscribed and numbered '"LES FLEURS DE L'ABIME" (I)' (on the reverse)
oil on canvas
21 ¼ x 28 ¾ in. (54.1 x 73 cm.)
Painted in 1928
Galerie L’Epoque [Paul Gustave Van Hecke], Brussels, by 1929.
Galerie Le Centaure, Brussels, 1929.
(probably) Jean Bastien, by 1931.
Claude Spaak, Brussels, by whom acquired in the 1930s.
Obelisk Gallery, London.
Harry Torczyner, New York, by whom acquired from the above in 1961, until at least 1979.
Christian Fayt, Knokke.
Private collection, Brussels, by whom acquired from the above in the late 1980s, and thence by descent to the present owner.
G. Marlier, 'Du Trompe l'œil', in Le Centaure, no. 7, Brussels, 1 April 1929, p. 180 (illustrated).
S. Dalí, ‘Documental-París-1929’, in La Publicitat, Barcelona, 23 May 1929, p. 1.
P. Colin, La Peinture belge depuis 1830, Brussels, 1930, pl. 414, p. 428 (illustrated).
J. Reichardt, 'René Magritte', in Apollo Magazine, vol. LXXV, no. 440, October 1961, p. 115 (illustrated).
P. Waldberg, René Magritte, Brussels, 1965, p. 340 (illustrated p. 59).
H. Torczyner, Magritte, The True Art of Painting, London, 1979, pp. 74 & 143 (illustrated pl. 90, p. 74).
D. Sylvester, ed., René Magritte, Catalogue raisonné, vol. I, Oil Paintings, 1916-1930, Antwerp, 1992, no. 239, pp. 286-287 (illustrated p. 286).
R.-M. Jongen, René Magritte ou la pensée imagée de l'invisible, réflexions et recherches, Brussels, 1994, p. 92.
Exh. cat., Magritte, Montreal, 1996, p. 69 (illustrated).
D. Sylvester, Magritte, Brussels, 2009, pp. 116, 284 & 421 (illustrated p. 116).
B. Soltzfus, 'Ekphrasis in Magritte and Verne, Voyages extraordinaires to the Center of Art', in The Comparatist, vol. 35, May 2011, pp. 69 & 83.
(probably) Brussels, Palais des Beaux-Arts, Guiette, Magritte, Picard, December 1931 – January 1932, no. 30.
(probably) Brussels, Palais des Beaux-Arts, Exposition René Magritte, May – June 1933, no. 23.
Brussels, Galerie des Éditions La Boétie, Surréalisme, December 1945 – February 1946, no. 72.
London, Obelisk Gallery, Magritte: Paintings, Drawings, Gouaches, September – October 1961, no. 7, p. 10 (illustrated p. 11).
Minneapolis, Walker Art Center, The Vision of René Magritte, September – October 1962, no. 5 (illustrated).
New York, The Museum of Modern Art, René Magritte, December 1965 – February 1966, no. 9 (illustrated p. 25); this exhibition later travelled to Waltham, Rose Art Museum, Brandeis University, April - May 1966; Chicago, Art Institute, May – July 1966; Pasadena, The Art Museum, August – September 1966; and Berkeley, University Art Museum, University of California, October – November 1966.
New York, Sidney Janis Gallery, Exhibition of Paintings by René Magritte, December 1977, no. 4a.
Brussels, Palais des Beaux-Arts, Rétrospective Magritte, October – December 1978, no. 79 (illustrated).
New York, Arnold Herstand, René Magritte: Paintings, November – December 1986, n.n.
Ostend, Provinciaal Museum voor Moderne Kunst, René Magritte, June - August 1990, no. 21, pp. 122 & 270 (illustrated p. 123).
Berkeley, University Art Museum, University of California, Anxious Visions - Surrealist Art, October - December 1990, p. 287 (illustrated p. 85, pl. 104).
Verona, Galleria d'Arte Moderna di Palazzo Forti, Da Magritte a Magritte, July - October 1991, no. 33, p. 273 (illustrated p. 83; with incorrect dimensions).
Brussels, Musées Royaux des Beaux-Arts de Belgique, Magritte, March - June 1998, no. 62, p. 92 (illustrated).
Barcelona, Fundació Joan Miró, Exposició René Magritte, November 1998 - February 1999, no. 27, p. 177 (illustrated p. 104).
Humlebaek, Louisiana Museum of Modern Art, René Magritte, August - November 1999, no. 20, p. 78 (illustrated p. 28); this exhibition later travelled to Edinburgh, Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art, December 1999 - March 2000; and San Francisco, Museum of Modern Art, May - September 2000, pp. 43 & 100 (illustrated p. 43, pl. 16).
Paris, Galerie nationale du Jeu de Paume, Magritte, February - June 2003, p. 75 (illustrated).
Mexico City, Museo del Palacio de Bellas Artes, El Mundo Invisible de René Magritte, March - July 2010 (illustrated p. 92).
Special notice

Artist's Resale Right ("Droit de Suite"). Artist's Resale Right Regulations 2006 apply to this lot, the buyer agrees to pay us an amount equal to the resale royalty provided for in those Regulations, and we undertake to the buyer to pay such amount to the artist's collection agent.

Brought to you by

Olivier Camu
Olivier Camu

Lot Essay

‘One cannot speak about mystery, one must be seized by it’ – René Magritte
(Magritte, from an interview with Suzi Gablik, Studio, March 1967)

Instead of being astonished by the superfluous existence of another world, it is our one world, where coincidences surprise us, that we must not lose sight of’ – René Magritte
(Magritte, ‘Nature and Mystery,’ in K. Rooney & E. Plattner, eds., René Magritte: Selected Writings, transl. J. Levy, Richmond, 2016, p. 181)

Infused with an eerie sense of disquiet, Les fleurs de l’abîme (The Flowers of the Abyss) is a captivating composition that emerged during one of the most productive and innovative years of René Magritte’s career. The artist had moved from Brussels to Paris in the autumn of 1927, drawn to the French capital’s lively art scene and in particular, the hive of artists and writers active in the city’s Surrealist circles. It was here that Magritte’s visual language truly began to solidify, as he boldly set out to challenge and undercut established traditions of representation in painting and forge a distinctive new path within Surrealism. Discussing this period of his career, Magritte explained: ‘The pictures painted […] from 1926 to 1936 were also the result of a systematic search for a disturbing poetic effect which, produced by the deployment of objects taken from reality, would give the real world from which they were borrowed a disturbing poetic meaning through a quite natural interchange’ (Magritte, quoted in D. Sylvester, Magritte, Brussels, 2009, p. 284). Featuring one of the artist’s most iconic leitmotifs, the spherical iron sleigh bells known as grelots, Les fleurs de l’abîme centres around such an intriguing juxtaposition of elements, as the organic and the decidedly man-made are fused together to form an uncanny, mysterious plant that feels at once disconcertingly familiar and yet completely alien.

While Magritte’s early correspondence from Paris suggests he was already personally acquainted with several key Surrealist figures before moving to the city, including André Breton, Louis Aragon, and Benjamin Péret, it was not until his arrival in the French capital that he was able to truly engage with the visual artists involved in the movement. It was thanks to his close friend Camille Goemans, who had arrived in Paris shortly before Magritte, that the artist came to know Joan Miró, Max Ernst, Jean Arp and Salvador Dalí. Exposure to such different approaches to image-making stimulated Magritte’s creativity, resulting in a period of intense artistic evolution that led to a series of breakthroughs, including his explorations on the theme of metamorphosis and the emergence of his infamous ‘word paintings’ which played with the connections between image and language in unexpected ways. However, Magritte remained something of an outsider to the Surrealists during this time, both intellectually and geographically, living as he did in the suburbs rather than the centre of the city and deliberately staying away from the automatic techniques of his contemporaries. This allowed him to cultivate a highly personal aesthetic, rooted in strange disjunctions and disconcerting juxtapositions, that remained distinctly his own.

Central to Magritte’s artistic practice at this time was the adoption of common-place, everyday objects, from the pipe to the tuba, the iron sleigh-bells to the bilboquet, which were then placed in improbable situations or transformed through a series of visual conundrums to generate enigmatic, multi-layered scenes. The grelot was a central protagonist in these works, and had first appeared within the artist’s oeuvre in the 1926 composition Le gouffre argenté (Sylvester, no. 87), floating freely within a strange chasm that can be glimpsed through a gap in the stage-like wall. These familiar jingle bells, typically found on the harnesses of horses or decorating sleighs, were rooted in memories from the artist’s childhood, and appeared in a variety of guises throughout Magritte’s oeuvre, floating in the air in strange configurations (Sylvester, nos. 240 & 241), placed reverentially in a wicker chair (Sylvester, no. 298), or as nodules on strange rippling pieces of sheet metal (Sylvester, no. 330). Here, the artist re-locates the bells, placing them in a cluster at the centre of a small plant in such a manner that their shiny metallic forms appear to be budding flowers or ripe fruit, rather than the cold, hollow vessels they are. Clinging to the side of a sheer cliff, just beyond the edge of the plateau above, the plant appears enticingly out of reach, its verdant green leaves and lustrous bell-flowers drawing our attention, but ultimately remaining beyond our grasp.

For Magritte, part of the appeal of using the grelot lay in the fact that it was a distinctly mass-produced item, its smooth finish and distinctive shape fabricated to a standardised format. In comparison to the bilboquet, which was often altered or anthropomorphised by the artist to enhance its visual intrigue, the grelot appears almost perfectly uniform across its many appearances within Magritte’s oeuvre, its spherical shape sharply consistent, its profile unchanging from canvas to canvas. This deliberate consistency accentuates the banality of the object, making its dislocation to such strange contexts all the more powerful, whether they be enlarged to massive proportions and suspended in mid-air, seen drifting weightlessly through a strange landscape, or nestled in the centre of a fleshy cluster of leaves atop a rocky outcrop. In this transformation of the exceedingly ordinary into the curiously extraordinary, Les fleurs de l’abîme illustrates one of the key concepts which drove Magritte’s art at this time: ‘Our secret desire is for a change in the order of things,’ he explained, ‘and it is appeased by the vision of a new order… the fate of an object in which we had no interest suddenly begins to disturb us’ (Magritte, quoted in S. Whitfield, Magritte, exh. cat., London, 1992, p. 110).

Here, the dislocation of the grelots is somewhat disconcerting, as if their perfect forms and enticing, reflective surfaces belie a potentially threatening secret. The dark, folding, rippling mountainous terrain, reminiscent in many ways of the slag heaps that dotted the landscape around the artist’s childhood home of Hainaut, lend the scene a foreboding atmosphere, whilst simultaneously emphasising the incongruity of the fertile, blooming plant within this otherwise barren environment. In this way, the composition appears to fulfil Magritte’s vision for the bells, which he outlined in ‘La ligne de vie’ in 1938: ‘I’d prefer to believe that the iron bells hanging from our fine horses’ necks grew there like poisonous plants on the edge of precipices’ (Magritte, quoted in H. Torczyner, Magritte: Ideas and Images, transl. R. Miller, New York, 1977, p. 93). As such, Les fleurs de l’abîme shares the same dark intensity that was a hallmark of Magritte’s paintings from this Parisian period, carrying overtones of suspense, anxiety and danger as to what may happen next in the enigmatic narrative he proposes. This overwhelming sense of unease is accentuated by the inherent mystery of the grelot itself, its characteristic jingle-jangle caused by an object concealed within the perfect sphere, which we can perceive through the sound it makes, but which we cannot see. Instead, we can only catch a glimpse of its shadowy form through the narrow slit that bisects the bell as it dances around the inside of the sphere.

It is this interplay between the perceptible and the imperceptible, the visible and the invisible, which allows Les fleurs de l’abîme to resonate so powerfully in the imagination of the viewer. These innocuous, joyful bells are suddenly transformed into silent, hybrid forms that captivate and confound in equal measure, causing us to question our understanding of their very nature. In this way, Magritte suggests the endless potential for mystery and revelation that exists in the world around us, presenting a scene so unexpected and jarring that it demands our attention and prompts us to reconsider our reality. Indeed, the image proved so striking that Salvador Dalí chose to highlight the composition in one of his reports on the contemporary art scene in Paris, published in the Catalan newspaper Le Publicitat in May 1929. While the motif of the grelot-plant would appear in several subsequent works by the artist through the 1930s and 40s, it would never again be granted such prominence within the composition, nor carry such a menacing aura.

More from The Art Of The Surreal Evening Sale

View All
View All