Lot Essay
The present panel is an autograph replica of the central composition of a triptych by Jacob Cornelisz. van Oostsanen, dated 1517, in the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam (inv. no. SK-A-4706). Executed on an identical scale and bearing the date ‘1520’ on the pediment, it presumably once formed the centre of a triptych, perhaps flanked by wings depicting donors accompanied by their patron saints. Two further versions of the composition are known, dated 1536 (present whereabouts unknown) and 1537 (Cambridge, Fitzwilliam Museum). Its autograph status was already recognised by Friedländer in 1906, while infrared reflectography (available upon request) reveals an extensive and fully developed underdrawing, closely comparable to that of the Rijksmuseum painting, with contour lines and hatching applied in multiple directions. This profusion of drawn lines, often exceeding what was strictly necessary to establish the composition, is characteristic of Oostsanen’s draughtsmanship.
The origins of this composition can be traced to Oostsanen’s earlier graphic work, notably his Adoration of the Magi from the woodcut series The Life of the Virgin of 1507, in which the eldest king similarly bends to kiss the Christ Child’s hand while the younger Magus presents his gift in profile. Both motifs recall the work of Geertgen tot Sint Jans, while the broader conception of the scene finds a closer parallel in Oostsanen’s painted Adoration of 1512 in the Detroit Institute of Arts (fig. 1), in which the figures are likewise gathered beneath a dilapidated structure, its roof reduced to exposed rafters and remnants of thatching. At the centre, the Virgin gazes tenderly at the Christ Child seated on her lap, while Melchior, the eldest of the three Magi, bends to kiss his hand. Caspar, kneeling in profile, presents an elaborately worked goblet, while Balthazar, standing at the left, holds an orb, their gifts of frankincense and myrrh alluding respectively to Christ’s divinity and mortality. Joseph, conspicuous in his brilliant red cloak, looks on from the middle ground.
Only around thirty paintings can be attributed to Oostsanen, six of which bear his monogram. The survival of a sequence of dated works nevertheless allows his stylistic development to be traced with some precision, from the meticulous, almost draughtsmanly handling of the Noli me tangere (Kassel, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister) and Crucifixion (private collection), both dated 1507, to the softer, more painterly technique of his later works, culminating in the Saul and the Witch of Endor of 1526 (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum). This evolution was also shaped by his artistic exchanges with his gifted assistant, Jan van Scorel (1495–1562), and his contemporary, Cornelis Engebrechtsz. (c. 1465–1527).
Distinctive marks on the reverse of the Baltic oak panel are an extremely rare and important survival, providing valuable insight into the processing, supply and transportation of artists’ supplies in the sixteenth century. The panel shows a densely gathered group of incised lines, two running straight along the wood grain, intersected by three diagonal incisions. These can be identified as cargo or timber merchants’ marks, made after the tree was felled and the planks hewn but before it was shipped to the Netherlands. It has been suggested that the lines represent different offspring from merchant families, with marks added with every new generation (private communication with Dr. Ian Tyers, July 2019). Typically, such marks would have been planed or sanded down when the wood was processed by panel makers in the Netherlands, and so their existence here represents an extraordinary survival, providing a fascinating insight into the complexities of the trade in artists’ materials.
A note on the provenance:
Alfred Sommerguth (1859-1950) was a German-Jewish businessman who made his fortune as director and co-owner of the tobacco company Loeser & Wolff, one of the largest tobacco manufacturers in pre-war Germany. After selling his shares in 1920, he served as an official of the Ministry of the Interior in Berlin. He and his wife Gertrude (1879-1954) were prominent members of 20th-century Berlin society and passionate collectors. Together they assembled a wide-ranging collection of Dutch and Italian Old Masters as well as French and German Impressionists.
In the 1930s, increasing anti-Jewish measures enacted by the Nazi government forced the couple to register their assets, and their property became a systematic target of the state. To meet the discriminatory Reich flight tax (Reichsfluchtsteuer), much of the collection was sold in Berlin at forced sales in 1939 and 1941. The Sommerguths themselves fled Germany in 1941, travelling via St. Gallen and Cuba to New York, where Alfred died in 1950 and Gertrude in 1954.
During their flight from Nazi Germany, the Sommerguths managed to bring 44 works of art to Switzerland, among them the present picture. Of these, the couple deposited half with the Kunstmuseum St. Gallen for safekeeping. By 1946, however, only ten remained in the museum’s possession, while the others, including the present lot, had left the institution under circumstances that remain unclear.
The origins of this composition can be traced to Oostsanen’s earlier graphic work, notably his Adoration of the Magi from the woodcut series The Life of the Virgin of 1507, in which the eldest king similarly bends to kiss the Christ Child’s hand while the younger Magus presents his gift in profile. Both motifs recall the work of Geertgen tot Sint Jans, while the broader conception of the scene finds a closer parallel in Oostsanen’s painted Adoration of 1512 in the Detroit Institute of Arts (fig. 1), in which the figures are likewise gathered beneath a dilapidated structure, its roof reduced to exposed rafters and remnants of thatching. At the centre, the Virgin gazes tenderly at the Christ Child seated on her lap, while Melchior, the eldest of the three Magi, bends to kiss his hand. Caspar, kneeling in profile, presents an elaborately worked goblet, while Balthazar, standing at the left, holds an orb, their gifts of frankincense and myrrh alluding respectively to Christ’s divinity and mortality. Joseph, conspicuous in his brilliant red cloak, looks on from the middle ground.
Only around thirty paintings can be attributed to Oostsanen, six of which bear his monogram. The survival of a sequence of dated works nevertheless allows his stylistic development to be traced with some precision, from the meticulous, almost draughtsmanly handling of the Noli me tangere (Kassel, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister) and Crucifixion (private collection), both dated 1507, to the softer, more painterly technique of his later works, culminating in the Saul and the Witch of Endor of 1526 (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum). This evolution was also shaped by his artistic exchanges with his gifted assistant, Jan van Scorel (1495–1562), and his contemporary, Cornelis Engebrechtsz. (c. 1465–1527).
Distinctive marks on the reverse of the Baltic oak panel are an extremely rare and important survival, providing valuable insight into the processing, supply and transportation of artists’ supplies in the sixteenth century. The panel shows a densely gathered group of incised lines, two running straight along the wood grain, intersected by three diagonal incisions. These can be identified as cargo or timber merchants’ marks, made after the tree was felled and the planks hewn but before it was shipped to the Netherlands. It has been suggested that the lines represent different offspring from merchant families, with marks added with every new generation (private communication with Dr. Ian Tyers, July 2019). Typically, such marks would have been planed or sanded down when the wood was processed by panel makers in the Netherlands, and so their existence here represents an extraordinary survival, providing a fascinating insight into the complexities of the trade in artists’ materials.
A note on the provenance:
Alfred Sommerguth (1859-1950) was a German-Jewish businessman who made his fortune as director and co-owner of the tobacco company Loeser & Wolff, one of the largest tobacco manufacturers in pre-war Germany. After selling his shares in 1920, he served as an official of the Ministry of the Interior in Berlin. He and his wife Gertrude (1879-1954) were prominent members of 20th-century Berlin society and passionate collectors. Together they assembled a wide-ranging collection of Dutch and Italian Old Masters as well as French and German Impressionists.
In the 1930s, increasing anti-Jewish measures enacted by the Nazi government forced the couple to register their assets, and their property became a systematic target of the state. To meet the discriminatory Reich flight tax (Reichsfluchtsteuer), much of the collection was sold in Berlin at forced sales in 1939 and 1941. The Sommerguths themselves fled Germany in 1941, travelling via St. Gallen and Cuba to New York, where Alfred died in 1950 and Gertrude in 1954.
During their flight from Nazi Germany, the Sommerguths managed to bring 44 works of art to Switzerland, among them the present picture. Of these, the couple deposited half with the Kunstmuseum St. Gallen for safekeeping. By 1946, however, only ten remained in the museum’s possession, while the others, including the present lot, had left the institution under circumstances that remain unclear.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
