Lot Essay
Through the wood represents an important rediscovery in Munnings’ artistic canon and in the story of early twentieth-century British art. An impressionistic tour de force, the painting depicts the artist’s first wife, Florence Carter-Wood, riding side-saddle in the early morning light of the woods around Lamorna in Cornwall.
Portrayals of Florence are rare: Munnings painted a series of her on horseback in the spring of 1912, and she modelled for their friends and fellow artists Harold and Laura Knight regularly in 1910 and 1911 (fig. 1). However, after her tragic early death in July 1914, Munnings literally wrote her out of his life story: there is no mention of her anywhere in his three-volume autobiography. The mystery surrounding their relationship has generated much interest over the years as well as speculation as to the reasons behind her breakdown, and Munnings' relative silence on the matter.
In 1909, Florence Edith Carter-Wood, known as ‘Blote’, the daughter of a wealthy brewer, followed her brother Joey to Newlyn, where he was enrolled as a student at the Art School established by Stanhope and Elizabeth Forbes. The journey to Cornwall was to help her recover from a recent mental health illness and certainly for the first few years it appeared to have the desired effect. Florence became an integral part of the artistic colony in Newlyn, joining the Art School as a landscape painter and modelling for her fellow artists. The community was soon enriched by the presence of Alfred Munnings, or ‘AJ’ as he was affectionately known. He quickly established himself as the epicentre of the regular parties and gatherings in Newyln and Lamorna, the village where he established his studio.
By the end of 1910 Munnings and Florence were engaged, and they married on 19 January 1912 in Westminster. However, all was not well and Florence sunk into despair, purportedly attempting to poison herself with cyanide on their honeymoon. Nevertheless, she returned to Cornwall with her husband and began her recovery. Part of this healing process involved exercising in the countryside of Lamorna valley on her husband’s horses, which inspired Munnings to capture his elegant wife on horseback in the dappled light of a woodland spring. Whilst three other paintings from this series are known, this is the first time that the present work has been seen publicly since it was shown at the Leicester Galleries in 1913.
In the Morning Ride series, Florence posed side-saddle, on either Munnings' brown mare, or a grey, wearing a variety of riding habits: cream, red and black. In the other pictures she wears a straw hat, whereas in the present work she is in the bowler hat that formed part of Munnings’ set of studio props. In each painting the artist has tried to capture the feel of early morning using a variety of techniques and a riot of colours. In Through the Wood thick layers of impasto abound, particularly in the dappled light and the leaves, contrasting with the more thinly applied paint on the woodland floor and brushstrokes so distinct on the left of the canvas that they could almost have been applied with the thumb. Munnings’ understanding of colour shines through: vibrant flashes of yellow indicate the strengthening sun, and hints of orange, pinks and blues among the variegated greens of the foliage create shadow and depth. Nothing remains a solid block of colour, even the tree trunks and the coat of the brown mare contain a myriad of darker tones and rich highlights.
Although he chose to keep The Morning Ride (fig. 2), the most personal of the group and the only painting where Florence is turned towards the viewer, his decision to sign and date the present work and select it for his solo show at the Leicester Galleries demonstrates his confidence in its artistic merits and commerciality. The exhibition was a huge success personally and financially, establishing Munnings’ reputation as a leading artist of the day.
Meanwhile, as Munnings’ career and artistic pursuits drew him away from Lamorna for increasing periods of time, Florence was regularly left behind in Cornwall. Munnings asked their friend Gilbert Evans, the local land agent and Captain in the Royal Monmouthshire R.E. Militia to look after Florence in his absence. Evans’ friendship with Florence deepened as they spent more time together, and their growing affection for each other soon raised speculation about the nature of their relationship. Whether or not they were lovers, Gilbert clearly felt that he should distance himself from a married woman, and, as a result, he joined a Royal Engineers survey party destined for Nigeria. He saw Florence for the last time on Saturday 25 April 1914, when he wrote in his diary, 'She saw me off at Paddington. We parted at 3.15. I went to the train alone and very sad'. Within three months she had taken her life.
Munnings was utterly devastated by his wife’s death, and whilst those who knew the couple, such as the Knights, believed that Florence would have been unhappy whoever she married, one can believe that in his grief Munnings must still have apportioned much of the blame to himself. It was, perhaps, partly for this reason that he stopped speaking of Florence. Certainly, his second wife Violet ensured her predecessor wasn’t mentioned in the first official biography of Munnings and perhaps she too was behind the exclusion of Florence from the autobiography.
Naturally this omission has ensured that the love triangle between Florence, Munnings and Evans has been the subject of much speculation and interest over the decades. It has inspired magazine editorials as well as a novel by Jonathan Smith, Summer in February (1995), which in 2013 was turned into a film starring the actors Dan Evans, Dominic Cooper, Emily Browning and Hattie Morahan. Whatever the truth of Florence and Gilbert’s relationship it was clearly strong enough for Munnings to gift his portrayal of Florence, The Morning Ride, to Gilbert. That painting, along with Harold Knight’s Portrait of Florence, remained in the Evans family until they were sold in these Rooms in 2000 and 2016, respectively. In each instance they generated strong interest, testament to the enduring fascination engendered by this Cornish ménage à trois.
We are grateful to Lorian Peralta-Ramos, Tristram Lewis and the Curatorial staff at The Munnings Museum for their assistance in preparing this catalogue entry.
Portrayals of Florence are rare: Munnings painted a series of her on horseback in the spring of 1912, and she modelled for their friends and fellow artists Harold and Laura Knight regularly in 1910 and 1911 (fig. 1). However, after her tragic early death in July 1914, Munnings literally wrote her out of his life story: there is no mention of her anywhere in his three-volume autobiography. The mystery surrounding their relationship has generated much interest over the years as well as speculation as to the reasons behind her breakdown, and Munnings' relative silence on the matter.
In 1909, Florence Edith Carter-Wood, known as ‘Blote’, the daughter of a wealthy brewer, followed her brother Joey to Newlyn, where he was enrolled as a student at the Art School established by Stanhope and Elizabeth Forbes. The journey to Cornwall was to help her recover from a recent mental health illness and certainly for the first few years it appeared to have the desired effect. Florence became an integral part of the artistic colony in Newlyn, joining the Art School as a landscape painter and modelling for her fellow artists. The community was soon enriched by the presence of Alfred Munnings, or ‘AJ’ as he was affectionately known. He quickly established himself as the epicentre of the regular parties and gatherings in Newyln and Lamorna, the village where he established his studio.
By the end of 1910 Munnings and Florence were engaged, and they married on 19 January 1912 in Westminster. However, all was not well and Florence sunk into despair, purportedly attempting to poison herself with cyanide on their honeymoon. Nevertheless, she returned to Cornwall with her husband and began her recovery. Part of this healing process involved exercising in the countryside of Lamorna valley on her husband’s horses, which inspired Munnings to capture his elegant wife on horseback in the dappled light of a woodland spring. Whilst three other paintings from this series are known, this is the first time that the present work has been seen publicly since it was shown at the Leicester Galleries in 1913.
In the Morning Ride series, Florence posed side-saddle, on either Munnings' brown mare, or a grey, wearing a variety of riding habits: cream, red and black. In the other pictures she wears a straw hat, whereas in the present work she is in the bowler hat that formed part of Munnings’ set of studio props. In each painting the artist has tried to capture the feel of early morning using a variety of techniques and a riot of colours. In Through the Wood thick layers of impasto abound, particularly in the dappled light and the leaves, contrasting with the more thinly applied paint on the woodland floor and brushstrokes so distinct on the left of the canvas that they could almost have been applied with the thumb. Munnings’ understanding of colour shines through: vibrant flashes of yellow indicate the strengthening sun, and hints of orange, pinks and blues among the variegated greens of the foliage create shadow and depth. Nothing remains a solid block of colour, even the tree trunks and the coat of the brown mare contain a myriad of darker tones and rich highlights.
Although he chose to keep The Morning Ride (fig. 2), the most personal of the group and the only painting where Florence is turned towards the viewer, his decision to sign and date the present work and select it for his solo show at the Leicester Galleries demonstrates his confidence in its artistic merits and commerciality. The exhibition was a huge success personally and financially, establishing Munnings’ reputation as a leading artist of the day.
Meanwhile, as Munnings’ career and artistic pursuits drew him away from Lamorna for increasing periods of time, Florence was regularly left behind in Cornwall. Munnings asked their friend Gilbert Evans, the local land agent and Captain in the Royal Monmouthshire R.E. Militia to look after Florence in his absence. Evans’ friendship with Florence deepened as they spent more time together, and their growing affection for each other soon raised speculation about the nature of their relationship. Whether or not they were lovers, Gilbert clearly felt that he should distance himself from a married woman, and, as a result, he joined a Royal Engineers survey party destined for Nigeria. He saw Florence for the last time on Saturday 25 April 1914, when he wrote in his diary, 'She saw me off at Paddington. We parted at 3.15. I went to the train alone and very sad'. Within three months she had taken her life.
Munnings was utterly devastated by his wife’s death, and whilst those who knew the couple, such as the Knights, believed that Florence would have been unhappy whoever she married, one can believe that in his grief Munnings must still have apportioned much of the blame to himself. It was, perhaps, partly for this reason that he stopped speaking of Florence. Certainly, his second wife Violet ensured her predecessor wasn’t mentioned in the first official biography of Munnings and perhaps she too was behind the exclusion of Florence from the autobiography.
Naturally this omission has ensured that the love triangle between Florence, Munnings and Evans has been the subject of much speculation and interest over the decades. It has inspired magazine editorials as well as a novel by Jonathan Smith, Summer in February (1995), which in 2013 was turned into a film starring the actors Dan Evans, Dominic Cooper, Emily Browning and Hattie Morahan. Whatever the truth of Florence and Gilbert’s relationship it was clearly strong enough for Munnings to gift his portrayal of Florence, The Morning Ride, to Gilbert. That painting, along with Harold Knight’s Portrait of Florence, remained in the Evans family until they were sold in these Rooms in 2000 and 2016, respectively. In each instance they generated strong interest, testament to the enduring fascination engendered by this Cornish ménage à trois.
We are grateful to Lorian Peralta-Ramos, Tristram Lewis and the Curatorial staff at The Munnings Museum for their assistance in preparing this catalogue entry.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
