ALICE NEEL (1900-1984)
ALICE NEEL (1900-1984)
ALICE NEEL (1900-1984)
2 More
ALICE NEEL (1900-1984)
5 More
Property from the Family of Agnes Gund
ALICE NEEL (1900-1984)

David and Catherine Saalfield

Details
ALICE NEEL (1900-1984)
David and Catherine Saalfield
signed and dated 'Neel '82' (lower left)
oil on canvas
64 1⁄8 x 44 1⁄8 in. (162.9 x 112 cm.)
Painted in 1982
Provenance
Agnes Gund, New York (acquired directly from the artist, 1982).
By descent from the above to the present owner.
Exhibited
Costa Mesa, Orange County Museum of Art, Alice Neel: Feels Like Home, June 2023-January 2024.
Los Angeles, David Zwirner and London, Victoria Miro, At Home: Alice Neel in the Queer World, September 2024-February 2025, pp. 128 and 140 (illustrated).
Turin, Pinacoteca Agnelli, Alice Neel: I Am the Century, October 2025-April 2026, n.p., no. 46 (illustrated).

Brought to you by

Kathryn Widing
Kathryn Widing Senior Vice President, Senior Specialist, Head of 21st Century Evening Sale

Lot Essay

Alice Neel’s evocative paintings are as much about presence as they are about people. In David and Catherine Saalfield, the artist’s intimate portrait of two of legendary collector and philanthropist Agnes Gund’s children, Neel seeks to record the personality of both sitters as much as their physical appearance. Her animated brushwork and deployment of vibrant neon colors reinvigorated the genre of figuration, infusing her paintings with a renewed sense of painterliness, and also humanity. Painted two years before her death, the present work stands as an epitaph to an artist of remarkable talent and ingenuity, and to the extraordinary people on whom she lavished her artistic attention.

Catherine Gund [Saalfield], Agnes Gund’s daughter and one of the subjects in the present work, recalled her experience of sitting for one of the twentieth century’s greatest portraitists:

Before I sat for Alice Neel in 1982, I imagined stillness as a kind of solitude, me on one side of the canvas, her on the other, two closed rooms. I knew, because I painted too, that her mind would be a crowded place while she worked. What I couldn’t picture was my own side of that quiet: a body arranged and held, asked to stay exactly where it was put. I thought I would be alone in the holding.

The staying still part turned out to be true. In everything else, I was very wrong. The room, it turned out, was already full before we arrived, full of everyone Alice had ever pinned to canvas, all that scrubbed and stroked pigment fixing people mid-thought, caught in expressions no camera has ever managed, because a camera asks for a face and Alice asked for a self. I studied her older paintings the way you study a language you’re about to be spoken in. I recognized a few people from the books. Andy Warhol, eyes shut, the scars laid bare across his chest, like he was enduring rather than posing. Margaret Evans, seven months pregnant and plainly nude, refusing the diaphanous draping pregnancy usually gets hidden behind. James Hunter, a young Black man drafted for Vietnam the week he sat for her, who never returned for the second sitting, so the painting simply stops mid-thought, its cobalt outline showing through more clearly in the unfinished parts than intended. Jackie Curtis, glittered and free of gender, painted with the same unflinching tenderness Alice gave everyone else, no more curiosity, no less.

I wanted to know what she’d find in me, and what she’d found in them. I wanted to know what it felt like sitting where I was about to sit, what they’d been thinking while they sat, and whether any of them recognized themselves when their painting was finished and revealed, or if they only met a stranger wearing their name.

And there were more people still, the ones who wandered into the room through Alice’s talk, our silences breaking open every so often into memories of her Cuba places, her New York days, her lovers, and sons. Her voice was its own kind of brushstroke, laid down between the visible ones. I kept my own company too, painting people in my head while I waited and sat, the way you invent whole lives for strangers on a long train ride because you can’t help but notice all the living of those leaving where they were leaving or going where they were going, and the path you share in the getting there. It struck me as an unusually intimate way to come to know someone, being looked at so hard, for so long, by someone who was also, constantly, telling you who she’d been.

I wasn’t alone on the couch, either. My brother was splayed beside me, his big body loose and certain of its right to the space, mine tucked into whatever shape was left over. I remember drifting off into the odd sensation that he was sitting on top of me, almost literally, but mostly in the way a bright color can sit on top of a dim one and make it recede. My hair was long and straight and brown. I wore jeans and a white button-down, trying, I think now, to be unremarkable enough to simply be seen. He surfaced in a purple tie-dyed T-shirt, knotted hands and feet, and bouncy blond curls for Alice to relish. And she did. Who could resist the disorder, the ease, the unbothered claim he staked on the cushions? She painted that ease like she loved him for it, and something in me, sixteen and half-hidden, went quietly jealous of how simply he could be loved on sight.

But I don’t think I was mistaken, either, that she loved me too, just differently, in a slower way where you come to love something that doesn’t announce itself, that you have to sit with before it opens. His was the kind of attention that arrives all at once. Mine, I think, she had to go looking for. I didn’t have language for it yet, but I wonder now if she’d already sensed the shape of what made me different, that a year or so later, when I came out, it wouldn’t land as a surprise so much as a fact settling into a contour she’d already been quietly painting toward. She never asked. I never told her. But something about the way she looked past the easy, obvious light my brother gave off, and kept looking at me anyway, felt like a rehearsal for being loved as exactly who I was, not in spite of it. I’ve come to suspect that’s the harder love to earn, the kind that has to find you rather than the kind you hand someone at the door.

And since Alice was a friend of my mother’s, I also felt my mother there in the room observing us, a third gaze layered right on top. Earlier that year, I’d sat, stood really, for Robert Mapplethorpe’s legendary camera. Both times, being looked at that closely, in my adolescent body, so shy of my own outline, felt like I was teetering on the edge. I understood, without being able to articulate it, that this attention was not my mother’s, was not about her world of artists and openings, museums and rarefied air, and was at the very same time impossible to separate from it. She had made the room I was being seen in, even when she wasn’t also standing or sitting in it.

The most powerful presence in the room was Alice, of course, the true center of gravity. She was the reason my brother and I were sitting together at all, having sat together for years at dinner tables, school desks, the movies, and in cars… but never on purpose, never solely with the objective of sitting together. This time things were changed. The question in that room wasn’t what we looked like; it was what our convening would give away, what the sculpted version of two siblings, posed, self-conscious, confident, or otherwise, would reveal about the walls each of us had built, and hadn’t.

We barely spoke when we were in Alice’s studio. We went, we sat, we stayed quiet and mostly alert, stationary, full of intrigue and expectation, awaiting direction sometimes but most often anecdotes from Alice, her voice breaking open again with a story. After a session, we’d loosen and lean around the easel, trying to catch what she’d been doing. To us? About us? With us? At home, I pored over books of her other work, half dreading, half hoping she’d stretch our noses the way she’d stretched someone else’s, lengthen our fingers, elongate our already long legs, like she had on other canvases. I wondered how much of that legendary cobalt blue outline—the fast, plain sketch of where our bodies simply were to live inside the gessoed frame—would survive underneath the rest, faint but legible, so that anyone looking closely enough later, our mother, a stranger, even us, could find Alice’s initial thought, her earliest plan, still breathing there. A palimpsest of her breath. And mine.

Years after the portrait was finished and hung in our apartment, my mother and I stood in front of it together and she asked if I liked it. And there it was, the question I’d spent so much time wondering about everyone else, now aimed, finally, at me. As a painting, it’s undeniable, a gorgeous captivation, the weight of two bodies rendered in full, skin and eye, turn of the lip, the exact torque of the torso, the almost unbearable acuteness of it. It’s an Alice Neel. Her work doesn’t so much move me as locate something in me, old and achy that I didn’t know (had forgotten?) I was carrying, and she says, it’s right here, where you, weak from the power of my excruciating humanness, left it.

But I had to admit something else that lived in my own heart. I wasn’t glad to see my vulnerability depicted there. A teenage person, a girl by the looks of it, desperately trying to emerge from underneath, behind, below her brother, is not an image I want to revisit regularly. But it happened. It’s there. And Alice, almost alone among everyone in the proverbial room that time, actually saw it happening, and had the fearless genius insight to leave it in.

For me, the painting has come to feel separate from Alice, whose work I still seek out to this day. I rarely saw her after those sessions. She died less than two years later, but I can remember the strange, specific warmth of being so thoroughly looked at, bathed almost, in her attention. The canvas is what’s left of that feeling now, a trace of a woman who took me on with no judgment and no soft-focus sentimentality. She took me into her world by translating mine, by showing me her people, her past, herself, and then handing me back, finally, a version of myself I hadn’t yet had any nerve to see. I think she was grateful for that exchange, in her way. Her sitters were, after all, how she kept leaving herself and going into someone else, over and over, for fifty years. I am still, and always, so grateful that she did.

More from 21st Century Evening Sale

View All
View All