Lot Essay
"You can almost hear Neel talking at the Whitney. Talking to her friends, lovers, children and grandchildren as she painted them. Talking strangers into sitting for her, like the lean, nattily dressed Fuller Brush Man whom she painted in 1965, learning in the process that he was a Holocaust survivor,” the New York Times’ chief art critic Roberta Smith wrote in her review of the Whitney retrospective dedicated to Alice Neel. Fuller Brush Man stands highly within the loquacious portraits selected for the exhibition and its prominence in the promotion of the exhibition across New York city would coincidentally reunite the work with the family of till-then anonymous sitter.
In Fuller Brush Man, Alice Neel captures the defiant spirit of who was then uncovered to be Mr Dewald Strauss, who, as described by the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s label, “escaped from Dachau and immigrated to America. He returned to Germany as an Allied soldier, earning a Purple Heart for his service. With his alert stance and open expression, Strauss meets Neel’s gaze with clear-eyed sincerity, revealing an unabashed positivity in his eager pursuit of the American dream.” Holocaust survivor turned door-to-door brush salesman on the Upper West Side of New York, his portrait embodies the artist's insistence on engaging with her immediate surroundings and the people who inhabited them: not celebrities or icons, but the man who knocked on her door.
The portrait’s prominent inclusion in the exhibition brought it to the attention of the sitter’s family, reuniting them with an image of their father whose very existence had been unknown to them. So profoundly moving was this discovery for Mr. Strauss’s son that he subsequently chronicled the experience in a book, embarking on a journey to recover and share his father’s remarkable life story. In doing so, he gave a name and a personal history to one of the many previously unidentified sitters in Alice Neel’s oeuvre, illuminating the extraordinary capacity of portraiture to restore lost connections between art, memory and lived experience.
Neel was a longtime resident of New York, and the city served as her most faithful subject. She paints Strauss at rest in his everyday garb, a slightly wrinkled suit pulled together by a matching bow. The contrasting blues draw attention to his elongated hands, whose umber undertones and pink knuckles read as marks of resilience, of a man wrestling with the dismays of his past and the boundless opportunities he hopes America will provide. Strauss smiles and peers directly into the viewer's eye, ready to offer the "free samples" visible in his suit pocket. Neel depicts her subject at his very best: persuasive and "perennially optimistic" about his future (quoted in P. Hills, “Alice Neel: Art as a Form of History” in Alice Neel: Paintings of Two Decades, exh. cat., University Art Gallery, Boston, 1980, pp. 6).
Neel and Strauss met on the Upper West Side in what Ann Sutherland Harris calls one of Neel's "more interesting stories" (quoted in A.S. Harris, “The Human Creature,” Portfolio, Volume 1, no. 5, December 1979-January 1980, pp. 73-74). The Fuller Brush Man succeeded in convincing her to buy forty dollars' worth of brushes. She recognized the talent behind the salesman, and the two eventually became friends.
With her socialist leanings, Neel initially thought Strauss to merely be a cog in the capitalist machine. Strauss was required to meet a daily quota of 30 brushes a day. The image of the salesman in a single lonesome one as evident by this single portrait format. The Fuller Brush Man is a powerful sitter in his ability to the change the opinion of its painter. Neel saw that the Fuller Brush Man was a man “who survived Dachau to live a life that seemed to her hardly worth living” (ibid).
Born in Philadelphia in 1900, Neel trained at the city’s School of Design for Women. While she painted landscapes, urban vistas and still lives, human beings were Neel’s favorite subject. Throughout her life, she painted men, women, children, couples, and the spaces they occupied, ranging from the young, rich and poor, all of whom are rendered with a timeless validity. In a period that prized abstraction, Cubism and Abstract Expressionism, Neel found a new way to approach an outdated genre of realist portraiture. As an observer of people and settings, she concentrated on the specific, honing in on their singularities, rather than focusing on a particular type. Neel keenly explored her sitters’ personalities and settings, and skillfully translated them into paint. The resulting portraits are unique in that the subject’s outward attributes and appearance reveal their inner self and era in which they lived.
Strauss's face was shown across New York alongside such masterpieces as Mother and Child (Nancy and Olivia) and Andy Warhol in the promotion of Alice Neel’s retrospective. The choice is telling: of all Neel's sitters, from celebrities to art-world icons, it was the unassuming salesman who was selected to represent her vision to the public.
The Fuller Brush Man stands among the artist's seminal paintings, featured in major exhibitions at institutions including the Whitney Museum of American Art and the Philadelphia Museum of Art. This rich exhibition history owes much to the power of Strauss as a subject. Most recently, the work was included in the Metropolitan Museum of Art's 2021 exhibition Alice Neel: People Come First, the first New York museum retrospective of the artist in twenty years. The exhibition's title could well describe the painting itself. Strauss, an ordinary man carrying an extraordinary history, embodies precisely the humanist conviction that people, whoever they may be, come first.
In Fuller Brush Man, Alice Neel captures the defiant spirit of who was then uncovered to be Mr Dewald Strauss, who, as described by the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s label, “escaped from Dachau and immigrated to America. He returned to Germany as an Allied soldier, earning a Purple Heart for his service. With his alert stance and open expression, Strauss meets Neel’s gaze with clear-eyed sincerity, revealing an unabashed positivity in his eager pursuit of the American dream.” Holocaust survivor turned door-to-door brush salesman on the Upper West Side of New York, his portrait embodies the artist's insistence on engaging with her immediate surroundings and the people who inhabited them: not celebrities or icons, but the man who knocked on her door.
The portrait’s prominent inclusion in the exhibition brought it to the attention of the sitter’s family, reuniting them with an image of their father whose very existence had been unknown to them. So profoundly moving was this discovery for Mr. Strauss’s son that he subsequently chronicled the experience in a book, embarking on a journey to recover and share his father’s remarkable life story. In doing so, he gave a name and a personal history to one of the many previously unidentified sitters in Alice Neel’s oeuvre, illuminating the extraordinary capacity of portraiture to restore lost connections between art, memory and lived experience.
Neel was a longtime resident of New York, and the city served as her most faithful subject. She paints Strauss at rest in his everyday garb, a slightly wrinkled suit pulled together by a matching bow. The contrasting blues draw attention to his elongated hands, whose umber undertones and pink knuckles read as marks of resilience, of a man wrestling with the dismays of his past and the boundless opportunities he hopes America will provide. Strauss smiles and peers directly into the viewer's eye, ready to offer the "free samples" visible in his suit pocket. Neel depicts her subject at his very best: persuasive and "perennially optimistic" about his future (quoted in P. Hills, “Alice Neel: Art as a Form of History” in Alice Neel: Paintings of Two Decades, exh. cat., University Art Gallery, Boston, 1980, pp. 6).
Neel and Strauss met on the Upper West Side in what Ann Sutherland Harris calls one of Neel's "more interesting stories" (quoted in A.S. Harris, “The Human Creature,” Portfolio, Volume 1, no. 5, December 1979-January 1980, pp. 73-74). The Fuller Brush Man succeeded in convincing her to buy forty dollars' worth of brushes. She recognized the talent behind the salesman, and the two eventually became friends.
With her socialist leanings, Neel initially thought Strauss to merely be a cog in the capitalist machine. Strauss was required to meet a daily quota of 30 brushes a day. The image of the salesman in a single lonesome one as evident by this single portrait format. The Fuller Brush Man is a powerful sitter in his ability to the change the opinion of its painter. Neel saw that the Fuller Brush Man was a man “who survived Dachau to live a life that seemed to her hardly worth living” (ibid).
Born in Philadelphia in 1900, Neel trained at the city’s School of Design for Women. While she painted landscapes, urban vistas and still lives, human beings were Neel’s favorite subject. Throughout her life, she painted men, women, children, couples, and the spaces they occupied, ranging from the young, rich and poor, all of whom are rendered with a timeless validity. In a period that prized abstraction, Cubism and Abstract Expressionism, Neel found a new way to approach an outdated genre of realist portraiture. As an observer of people and settings, she concentrated on the specific, honing in on their singularities, rather than focusing on a particular type. Neel keenly explored her sitters’ personalities and settings, and skillfully translated them into paint. The resulting portraits are unique in that the subject’s outward attributes and appearance reveal their inner self and era in which they lived.
Strauss's face was shown across New York alongside such masterpieces as Mother and Child (Nancy and Olivia) and Andy Warhol in the promotion of Alice Neel’s retrospective. The choice is telling: of all Neel's sitters, from celebrities to art-world icons, it was the unassuming salesman who was selected to represent her vision to the public.
The Fuller Brush Man stands among the artist's seminal paintings, featured in major exhibitions at institutions including the Whitney Museum of American Art and the Philadelphia Museum of Art. This rich exhibition history owes much to the power of Strauss as a subject. Most recently, the work was included in the Metropolitan Museum of Art's 2021 exhibition Alice Neel: People Come First, the first New York museum retrospective of the artist in twenty years. The exhibition's title could well describe the painting itself. Strauss, an ordinary man carrying an extraordinary history, embodies precisely the humanist conviction that people, whoever they may be, come first.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
