CORNELIS CORNELISZ. VAN HAARLEM (HAARLEM 1562-1638)
CORNELIS CORNELISZ. VAN HAARLEM (HAARLEM 1562-1638)
CORNELIS CORNELISZ. VAN HAARLEM (HAARLEM 1562-1638)
2 More
Heroes & Lovers: Property of a Distinguished Collector
CORNELIS CORNELISZ. VAN HAARLEM (HAARLEM 1562-1638)

Hercules and Achelous

Details
CORNELIS CORNELISZ. VAN HAARLEM (HAARLEM 1562-1638)
Hercules and Achelous
signed and dated 'AO 90. / CCornely . H fe' (lower left, on the rock)
oil on canvas
75 3⁄8 x 95 ½ in. (191.4 x 242.5 cm.)
Provenance
(Possibly commissioned by) Jacob Rauwart (c. 1530-1597), De Sevenstarre, Amsterdam, by descent to his son,
(Probably) Claes Rauwart (1564-1612), De Sevenstarre, Amsterdam; his deceased sale, on the premises, Amsterdam, 29 August 1612, lot 30, as "een doeck Hercules CC." ("a canvas [representing] Hercules [by] C[ornelis] C[ornelisz.]"), where acquired for 103 florins by,
(Probably) Hendrick van Os (1555⁄6-1615⁄21), Amsterdam.
(Possibly) inventory of the estate of Herman Becker (c. 1617-1678), Amsterdam, 19 October 1678, fol. 285v: "In de sal naest het voorhuijs" ("In the room next to the entrance hall"), "Een Hercules vn Mr. Corn van Haarlem" ("a Hercules by Mr. Corn[elis] van Haarlem").
Potschien collection, Berlin, circa 1925, and by descent in 1977.
Confiscated by the East German Government, 24 September 1985,
Transferred to the Staatliche Museen zu Berlin (East), in December 1986,
Donated under duress to the Staatliche zu Museen Berlin (East), 16 March 1989,
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin Preussischer Kulturbesitz, 1989-2008,
Restituted in 2008 to a private collection, Europe, and by whom sold,
[Property of a Private European Collector]; Christie's, New York, 15 April 2008, lot 25, where acquired by the present owner.
Literature
A. Bredius, "Rembrandtiana," Oud Holland, XXVIII, no. 4, 1910, p. 198.
A. Bredius and O. Hirschmann, Künstler-Inventare: Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts, V, The Hague, 1918, p. 1740.
H.J. Postma, "De Amsterdamse verzamelaar Herman Becker (ca. 1617-1678): Nieuwe gegvens over een geldschieter van Rembrandt," Oud Holland, CII, 1988, p. 17.
J. L. McGee, Cornelis Corneliszoon van Haarlem (1562–1638): Patrons, Friends and Dutch Humanists, Nieuwkoop, 1991, pp. 220, 224.
"Jahresberichte der Museen und Sammlungen für 1988 und 1989," Forschungen und Berichte, XXXI, 1991, p. 339.
B. von Henning Bock, et al., Gemäldegalerie Berlin: Gesamtverzeichnis, Berlin, 1996, pp. 33, 329, no. 1223, illustrated.
P.J.J. van Thiel, Cornelis Cornelisz van Haarlem 1562-1638: A monograph and catalogue raisonné, Doornspijk, 1999, pp. 30, 43, 99, 110, 193, 345-346, no. 134, fig. 58, plate II.
L.W. Nichols, "Cornelis van Haarlem Haarlem," Burlington Magazine, CLV, no. 1319, 2013, p. 121.
P. Barolsky, Ovid and the Metamorphoses of Modern Art: From Botticelli to Picasso, New Haven and London, 2014, pp. 209-210, fig. 102.
A. Godetsky, "Relative values: Locating the animal in three paintings by Cornelis van Haarlem," Netherlands Yearbook for History of Art, LXXI, 2021, pp. 116-143, fig. 3.
P. Barolsky, "Ovid and the Art of Metamorphoses at the Met," Arion: A Journal of Humanities and the Classics, XXIX, no. 2, Fall 2021, pp. 84, 86, fig. 5.
Exhibited
Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, 1986-2006, inv. no. 2280.
Berlin, Bode-Museum, 2006-2008, inv. no. 96-12.
New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art, on loan, 2008-2018.

Brought to you by

Paige Kestenman
Paige Kestenman Vice President, Senior Specialist, Co-Head of 20th Century Evening Sale

Lot Essay

Signed and dated 1590, this monumental Hercules and Achelous ranks among Cornelis Cornelisz. van Haarlem’s grandest and most ambitious paintings. Executed in the same year as his Massacre of the Innocents in the Rijksmuseum, the canvas transforms a mythological encounter into an arresting demonstration of pictorial mastery. The work’s life-size protagonists are locked in a fierce struggle whose outcome is imminent: Hercules is about to wrench the horn from the bull’s head and overcome his adversary. The closely interlocked forms of man and beast give the group an almost sculptural presence, while the contrasting textures of flesh, hide, and fur enrich the image’s visual immediacy. At once a representation of heroic triumph and a vehicle for Cornelis’s command of the human form, the painting presents the artist at his most expressive and assured.

One of the exploits associated with Hercules’s Twelve Labors, the subject derives from Book IX of Ovid’s Metamorphoses. It illustrates his contest with Achelous, a river god in bull form who, like Hercules, seeks the hand of Deianira, Princess of Calydon. Achelous attempts to evade defeat by first assuming the form of a man, then a serpent, and finally a bull; none of the transformations could withstand Hercules’s strength. Recounting his defeat, Achelous describes the force of the hero’s assault: “I changed once more to a savage bull and returned to the fray. He attacked from the left and clasped my muscular neck in his arms; I then dashed forward, but Hercules followed and pulled against me; soon he had forced my hard horns down till they caught in the soil, and had me flat on top of the sand. But he still wasn’t satisfied. Grasping one of my horns in his brutal hand, he broke it, tough as it was, and tore it away from my forehead, leaving me maimed (Ovid, Metamorphoses, D. Raeburn, trans., London, 2004, IX: 81-87).”

Cornelis depicts the encounter just before the decisive act. The bull’s broad, golden flank dominates the foreground, its lowered head counterbalanced by Hercules’s taut arms and firmly braced leg. The hero bends over his adversary, his muscular hands gripping its horns, which he twists in opposition to the animal’s heaving neck and tense body. With his knee pressed into its back, Hercules throws his full weight upon his opponent, whose own physical exertion is underscored by the marks left by its front hoofs in the right foreground. Behind Hercules billows the mane of the Nemean lion’s pelt, thereby recalling an earlier triumph over a similarly formidable beast.

Employing a continuous narrative, Cornelis includes smaller episodes alluding to other heroic exploits in the background. At left, Hercules confronts the Lernaean hydra, whose many heads repeatedly regenerated and whose defeat constituted the second of his Twelve Labors. At right, he lifts the giant Antaeus from the ground, depriving him of the contact with the earth that replenished his strength. Their diminutive scale emphasizes the extraordinary presence of the foreground protagonists. Beside Hercules and Antaeus, three naiads fill Achelous’s broken horn with fruit and flowers, thereby transforming it into a cornucopia, the enduring classical emblem of abundance. This metamorphosis underscores the heroic result of the violent struggle, as Hercules’s triumph becomes an enduring symbol of plenty.

Born in Haarlem in 1562, Cornelis (fig. 1) was the son of a prominent cloth merchant and later adopted the name of his native city. When his parents fled Haarlem in 1573 during the Spanish occupation, he remained to train with Pieter Pietersz. He subsequently traveled to Antwerp, where he studied with Gillis Coignet, before returning to Haarlem in 1580. Three years later, he received his first major commission for Banquet of Members of the Haarlem Calivermen Civic Guard, a militia portrait today in the Frans Hals Museum, Haarlem. By the time he painted Hercules and Achelous, Cornelis had established himself as one of Haarlem’s foremost artists, the recipient of some of the city’s most prestigious commissions. In 1590, the same year he executed the present work, Haarlem’s burgomasters commissioned a pair of paintings for the Prinsenhof, or city hall, for which they paid him the considerable sum of 600 Flemish pounds (Van Thiel 1999, pp. 32-36). His prominence in Haarlem’s artistic life was matched by his civic involvement: he belonged to the Saint James militia and served as a regent of the Oudemannenhuis, or Old Men’s Almshouse.

The present painting was painted in the intensely creative milieu that emerged from Cornelis’s close association with Hendrick Goltzius and the painter, theorist, and biographer Karel van Mander, who arrived in Haarlem in 1583. Commonly known as the “Haarlem Academy,” their collaborative enterprise centered on mastering the human figure through drawing from life (Van Thiel 1999, pp. 59-90). Van Mander in his Schilder-Boeck, an art-theoretical treatise with biographies of artists published in Haarlem in 1604, described their endeavor as an academy for studying “from life” (see W.S. Melion, Karel van Mander and his Foundation of the Noble, Free Art of Painting, Leiden, 2023, pp. 58-61). The academy was a highly innovative development in the sixteenth-century Low Countries, and its emphasis on draughtsmanship helped transform Netherlandish art around 1600.

These Dutch Mannerists, as they are sometimes known, looked both to antiquity and the Renaissance as well as contemporary northern art to develop a representational language in which close observation supported deliberate artifice. Mannerism, which had emerged in Italy in the first half of the sixteenth century, prized the elongation and attenuation of form, often as a way of heightening the ingenuity of pictorial invention. In Haarlem, these interests found particularly forceful expression in the male nude. Cornelis reveled in the depiction of muscular bodies placed in extreme, animated poses. In the Fall of the Titans (fig. 2) of 1588, now in the Statens Museum for Kunst, Denmark, for instance, the subject became a vehicle for showing the male nude from multiple angles, the falling bodies displaying an extraordinary variety of foreshortened attitudes (Van Thiel 1999, pp. 325-327, no. 87). As he had in that work, in Hercules and Achelous Cornelis appears to have drawn inspiration for certain figural motifs from prints: the hero’s outstretched arms are strikingly reminiscent of the figure at lower right in Marcantonio Raimondi’s Climbers (fig. 3), an engraving done after Michelangelo’s Battle of Cascina, which had likewise informed certain figural forms in the Massacre of the Innocents (fig. 4) produced the same year (Van Thiel 1999, pp. 306-307, no. 41).

Sculpture, particularly the bronze statuettes of the Delft sculptor Willem Danielsz. van Tetrode (c. 1525–1580), provided the Haarlem artists with another important point of reference. Studying in Rome in the 1550s, Tetrode responded powerfully both to the muscular force of Hellenistic sculpture and to the work of Michelangelo. The sculptor’s bronze statuettes often provided compelling models for the younger Haarlem masters. The striding pose and emphatic musculature of the principal figure in Goltzius’s Great Hercules (fig. 5) engraving of 1589, for example, is closely related to Tetrode’s Hercules Pomarius, just as the diminutive Hercules and Antaeus in the right background is almost certainly based on Tetrode’s small bronze of the pair (fig. 6), in which the giant similarly tries to wrest himself free from Hercules’s grip by bracing himself against Hercules’s head (itself a motif based on a Giambologna composition [see S.H. Goddard and J.A. Ganz, Goltzius and the Third Dimension, exh. cat., Williamstown 2001]).

The relationship between Hercules and Achelous and Goltzius’s Great Hercules, made only a year apart, is similarly suggestive. In the print’s left background (fig. 7), Hercules wrestles Achelous in his bovine form. The intertwined figures, though seen from a different angle, appear to anticipate the central group in Cornelis’s canvas, raising the possibility that the two artists studied a common model that could be turned and examined from successive viewpoints. Although no such sculptural group has yet been securely identified, the correspondence attests to close artistic exchange and shared interest in the expressive possibilities of the body in motion. (At the time of his death in 1638, Cornelis owned over sixty sculptures, including plaster casts of both a bull and a Hercules [Van Thiel, 1999, pp. 257, 271, 273].) If a small bronze lay at the root of the conceit of Hercules and Achelous, its translation into a canvas of such exceptional scale would represent a characteristically Mannerist inversion: transforming an object that could be held in the hand into an image of overwhelming physical presence.

The heroic subject’s appeal extended beyond the opportunities it afforded for the display of artistic virtuosity. Since the Middle Ages, Hercules’s victories over monstrous opponents had been understood as emblematic of virtue vanquishing vice. His defeat of Achelous would thus evoke the continual struggle to master the animalistic impulses of human behavior: in overcoming the beast, the hero also symbolically conquers the instincts that threaten reason and moral order. The resulting cornucopia gives this victory a constructive outcome, replacing the violence of the encounter with an image of fertility and plenty. A related interpretation understands Hercules’s conquest of the river god as the restraint of waters that might otherwise overflow their banks and inundate the surrounding fields. By subduing Achelous, the hero protects the land, its agriculture, and its resources, ensuring the prosperity of the region.

Such associations held particular resonance in the nascent Dutch Republic, where the protection and cultivation of the land were inseparable from the management of water. Hercules was often invoked as an embodiment of the Dutch in their rebellion against Spain, his strength and perseverance offering a compelling image of a polity asserting its independence (For a geopolitical reading of the painting within the context of the violent struggle for political autonomy in the northern Netherlands [see Godetsky 2021, especially pp. 128-130]). For an artist working in Haarlem, a center of resistance to Spanish rule, these meanings would have been especially pertinent. The painting’s multivalent nature, well suited to Mannerist circles, would have invited myriad interpretations of its account of heroic triumph.

A NOTE ON PROVENANCE
Although no commission is documented, the painting’s exceptional scale (the canvas was assembled from three pieces of fabric) suggests that, rather than being executed for the open market, it was conceived as a specific commission. One known precedent for the inclusion of Herculean subjects within a domestic setting may be found in Frans Floris’s now-lost cycle of ten paintings of the hero’s deeds made for the Antwerp home of the merchant Nicolaas Jongelinck (1517-1570), and disseminated through engravings by Cornelis Cort. Indeed, the emphasis on the hero’s muscular physique and the forceful placement of his knee against the bull’s back find parallels in Floris’s designs, an edition of which appears in Cornelis’s posthumous inventory.

Jacob Rauwart (c. 1530-1597), one of the wealthiest collectors in late sixteenth-century Amsterdam and most probably the first owner of the picture, is one especially intriguing potential patron. An amateur painter who had studied with Maarten van Heemskerck, Rauwart lived in the Sevenstarre, or the Seven Stars, on Warmoesstraat. Van Mander repeatedly praised Rauwart’s collection in his Schilder-Boeck, describing it as among the finest he had ever seen. Rauwart’s profound connection with Cornelis is indicated by the many works by the painter in his collection. Among them was Two followers of Cadmus devoured by a dragon (fig. 8) at the National Gallery, London, the collaboratively produced engraving after which Cornelis and Goltzius dedicated to Rauwart (Van Thiel 1999, pp. 340-342, no. 120). (Inscribed lower left: “D. Iacob. Raeuwaerdo singulari Picturae alumno, et Chalcographiae admiratori amicitiae ergo D[ono]. D[edicavit].”; “Master Jacob Rauwart, singular student of Painting and admirer of Copperplate engraving, presented as a gift of our friendship.”) Although Cornelis painted the latter work two years before the present, slightly larger picture, the two canvases appear unequivocally related in their treatment of violent encounters between man and beast.

Fifteen years after Rauwart’s death, the collection was dispersed in his son’s posthumous four-day sale conducted in August 1612 under the supervision of the regents of the Amsterdam Orphan’s Chamber (Weeskamer). The 498-lot auction realized more than 14,000 guilders, an extraordinary sum (equivalent to the cost of a substantial, well-situated house in Amsterdam [see M.J. Bok, “Art-Lovers and their Paintings,” in Dawn of the Golden Age, G. Luijten and A. van Suchtelen, eds., Amsterdam, 1993, p. 148]). The present work is probably identifiable with lot 30, which was acquired by Hendrick van Os for 103 guilders, among the highest prices of the sale, indicating the esteem in which the work would have been held in the decades immediately after its creation.

Van Os (1555⁄6-1615⁄21), a prominent merchant and collector originally from Antwerp, belonged with his younger brother, Dirck, to Amsterdam’s highest commercial echelons. When the Dutch East India Company was established in 1602, the registration of shares took place in Dirck’s house, and the brothers together subscribed more than 47,000 guilders; a further investment of 11,700 guilders followed in 1612. Their financial prominence was accompanied by a discerning interest in art. According to Van Mander, Hendrick’s collection included paintings by Gillis van Coninxloo, Hans von Aachen, Paulus Bril, and Jacques de Gheyn II, as well as Venetian paintings by Palma Giovane (see S. Cohen-Nilsen, “Een schilerij van Jacomo Palma il Giovane in een vroeg zeventiende-eeuwse verzameling,” Oud Holland, CXIII, 1999, pp. 175-180). Van Os’s status as a distinguished collector is attested to by the dedication of Jacob Matham’s Saint Sebastian engraving, which hails the merchant as a connoisseur and patron of the arts. (Inscribed lower center: “Eximio ac praeftanti viri Henrico ab Os mercantour Amstelodami rari omnis artificii, inprimis caelaturae, caelatique operis unico admiratori artificiuque Mecaenali.”; “To the exceptional and outstanding man Hendrik van Os, merchant of Amsterdam, a rare admirer of all art, especially of engraving and engraved work, and a true Maecenas of the arts.”) The acquisition of Hercules and Achelous thus would have brought the painting into another significant collection whose owner was closely engaged with the artistic culture from which it had emerged.

The work is likely next recorded in the 1678 estate inventory of Herman Becker (c. 1617-1678), an Amsterdam merchant with close ties to the Baltic. At the time of his death, Becker owned over 200 paintings, ranging from Albrecht Dürer and Lucas van Leyden to Peter Paul Rubens and Rembrandt. Becker also lent money to artists, accepting works of art as collateral, and appears to have held a particular admiration for Rembrandt, whom he counted among his borrowers and whose paintings formed the largest group by a single master in his collection.

More from 20th Century Evening Sale

View All
View All