Lot Essay
The present work, produced in 1909, is amongst Sargent’s most striking male portraits in charcoal. The handsome sitter cuts a dashing figure, and, somewhat unusually amongst Sargent’s portraits, is shown in profile which allows his elegant features to be highlighted.
Walter Murray Guthrie was the third son of James Alexander Guthrie, 4th Baron of Craigie and a director of the Bank of England, and Ellinor Stirling, daughter of Admiral Sir James Stirling (a very fine portrait of Ellinor by Frederic, Lord Leighton is at the Yale Centre for British Art). Guthrie worked in his family’s merchant banking business, Chalmers, Guthrie & Co. in London, however he found a new passion in renovating Torosay Castle on the Isle of Mull which he inherited in 1897.
Guthrie’s daughter, Bridget Miller, in a letter to David McKibbin recalls some of the circumstances of the drawing:
‘It was a gift from Sargent to my mother & was drawn in two hours & and we all think as others do that it was one of his best charcoal drawings. My father was v[ery] ill at the time (diabetes before insulin appeared) & hence the speed in which he drew the picture.’
(Quoted from R. Ormond, John Singer Sargent: The Charcoal Portraits, New Haven and London, 2025, p. 187)
Sadly, at the age of 42 and only two years after the portrait was executed, Guthrie died due to complications from diabetes.
Sargent was great friends with the Guthrie family and completed several portrait commissions on their behalf. This association started as early as 1895 when Sargent painted Walter Guthrie’s sister, Agnes Anstruther-Thomson. He would go on to draw another of Guthrie’s sisters, and his nephews and cousins in a family relationship spanning several decades.
Walter Murray Guthrie was the third son of James Alexander Guthrie, 4th Baron of Craigie and a director of the Bank of England, and Ellinor Stirling, daughter of Admiral Sir James Stirling (a very fine portrait of Ellinor by Frederic, Lord Leighton is at the Yale Centre for British Art). Guthrie worked in his family’s merchant banking business, Chalmers, Guthrie & Co. in London, however he found a new passion in renovating Torosay Castle on the Isle of Mull which he inherited in 1897.
Guthrie’s daughter, Bridget Miller, in a letter to David McKibbin recalls some of the circumstances of the drawing:
‘It was a gift from Sargent to my mother & was drawn in two hours & and we all think as others do that it was one of his best charcoal drawings. My father was v[ery] ill at the time (diabetes before insulin appeared) & hence the speed in which he drew the picture.’
(Quoted from R. Ormond, John Singer Sargent: The Charcoal Portraits, New Haven and London, 2025, p. 187)
Sadly, at the age of 42 and only two years after the portrait was executed, Guthrie died due to complications from diabetes.
Sargent was great friends with the Guthrie family and completed several portrait commissions on their behalf. This association started as early as 1895 when Sargent painted Walter Guthrie’s sister, Agnes Anstruther-Thomson. He would go on to draw another of Guthrie’s sisters, and his nephews and cousins in a family relationship spanning several decades.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
