Collecting guide Chinese archaic bronzes

Collecting guide: Chinese archaic bronzes

Christie’s Chinese ceramics and works of art specialists explain what to look for when building a collection of Chinese archaic bronzes

1. Familiarise yourself with the different forms

Made in sets to furnish the tombs of China’s elite, Chinese archaic ritual bronzes were used to hold offerings of food and drink to the ancestors of the past. They were produced in huge quantities in a range of shapes, each of which has a specific name. When looking to build a diverse collection, it is important to familiarise oneself with the names of the different forms. Some of the more popular archaic bronze forms include:

The Luboshez Gong. An exceptional and highly important bronze ritual wine vessel and cover, gong. Late Shang dynasty, Anyang, 13th-12th century B.C. 11¾ in (29.8 cm) long. Estimate $4,000,000-6,000,000. Offered in Shang Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christies New York

The Luboshez Gong. An exceptional and highly important bronze ritual wine vessel and cover, gong. Late Shang dynasty, Anyang, 13th-12th century B.C. 11¾ in (29.8 cm) long. Estimate: $4,000,000-6,000,000. Offered in Shang: Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christie's New York

Gong:  A ritual wine vessel with cover (above), often characterised as metamorphic forms of animals.

A very rare bronze ritual wine vessel and cover, fangyi. Late Shang dynasty, 12th century B.C. 8 34 in. (22 cm.) high. Estimate $600,000-800,000. Offered in Shang Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christies New York

A very rare bronze ritual wine vessel and cover, fangyi. Late Shang dynasty, 12th century B.C. 8 3/4 in. (22 cm.) high. Estimate: $600,000-800,000. Offered in Shang: Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christie's New York

Fangyi:  A ritual wine vessel (above) with tapering body of rectangular section and a roof-shaped cover.

A very rare miniature bronze ritual wine vessel and cover, you. Late Shang dynasty, 12th-11th century B.C. 4½  in (11.5  cm) high with handle. Estimate $200,000-300,000. Sold for $495,000 on 13 September 2019 at Christie’s New York

A very rare miniature bronze ritual wine vessel and cover, you. Late Shang dynasty, 12th-11th century B.C. 4½ in (11.5 cm) high with handle. Estimate: $200,000-300,000. Sold for $495,000 on 13 September 2019 at Christie’s New York

You:  A ritual wine vessel (above) with a stout oval body and an overhead handle, usually with a cover.

A finely-cast bronze ritual wine vessel, zun. China, late Shang-early Western Zhou dynasty (12th-10th century B.C.). 26.3 cm (10 38 in). Sold for €200,000 on 23 June 2020 at Christies in Paris

A finely-cast bronze ritual wine vessel, zun. China, late Shang-early Western Zhou dynasty (12th-10th century B.C.). 26.3 cm (10 3/8 in). Sold for €200,000 on 23 June 2020 at Christie's in Paris

Zun: Another ritual wine vessel, flared and with a bulbous mid-section (above).

A finely cast bronze ritual wine vessel, gu. Late Shang dynasty, Anyang, 12th-11th century B.C. 12 in (30.4 cm) high. Estimate $80,000-120,000. Offered in Shang Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christies New York

A finely cast bronze ritual wine vessel, gu. Late Shang dynasty, Anyang, 12th-11th century B.C. 12 in (30.4 cm) high. Estimate: $80,000-120,000. Offered in Shang: Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christie's New York

Gu:  Also a ritual wine vessel, similar to the zun  but with a slender silhouette (as above).

A bronze ritual tripod wine vessel, jue. Late Shang dynasty, 13th-11th century B.C. 8 in. (20.3 cm.) high. Sold for $32,500 on 22-23 March 2018 at Christie’s New York

A bronze ritual tripod wine vessel, jue. Late Shang dynasty, 13th-11th century B.C. 8 in. (20.3 cm.) high. Sold for $32,500 on 22-23 March 2018 at Christie’s New York

Jue:  One of the more striking vessels (above) of the archaic ritual bronze assembly — another ritual wine vessel, with a prominent spout, whorl-capped posts, flared tail and long tripod legs.

The Fu Yi Liding. A bronze ritual tripod food vessel. Late Shang dynasty, Anyang, 12th-11th century B.C. 8¼ in (21 cm) high. Sold for $125,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie’s New York. Sold for $125,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christies New York

The Fu Yi Liding. A bronze ritual tripod food vessel. Late Shang dynasty, Anyang, 12th-11th century B.C. 8¼ in (21 cm) high. Sold for $125,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie’s New York. Sold for $125,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie's New York

Ding:  A ritual cooking vessel (above) with a globular body, tripod legs and a pair of upright handles.

A bronze ritual wine vessel, pou. Late Shang dynasty, 13th-12th century B.C. 13 in (33 cm) diam. Estimate $200,000-300,000. Offered in Shang Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christies New York

A bronze ritual wine vessel, pou. Late Shang dynasty, 13th-12th century B.C. 13 in (33 cm) diam. Estimate: $200,000-300,000. Offered in Shang: Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christie's New York

Pou:  A ritual wine vessel (above) with rounded body, used for storing wine.

The Ran Fu Bing He. A rare bronze ritual tripod wine vessel and cover, he. Late Shang-early western Zhou dynasty, 11th century B.C. 13 in (33 cm) high. Estimate $450,000-550,000. Offered in Important Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art on 18-19 March 2021 at Christies New York  

The Ran Fu Bing He. A rare bronze ritual tripod wine vessel and cover, he. Late Shang-early western Zhou dynasty, 11th century B.C. 13 in (33 cm) high. Estimate: $450,000-550,000. Offered in Important Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art on 18-19 March 2021 at Christie's New York  

He:  A ritual wine vessel and cover (above), supported on either two or three legs with a spout rising diagonally from the shoulder, opposite a C-form handle.

A bronze ritual wine vessel, hu. Late Shang dynasty, 12th century B.C. 13¾ in (35 cm) high. Estimate $200,000-300,000. Offered in Shang Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christies New York

A bronze ritual wine vessel, hu. Late Shang dynasty, 12th century B.C. 13¾ in (35 cm) high. Estimate: $200,000-300,000. Offered in Shang: Early Chinese Ritual Bronzes from the Daniel Shapiro Collection on 18 March 2021 at Christie's New York

Hu:  A classic pear-shaped ritual wine vessel (above), sometimes with a cover.

The Ge Zu Ji Gui, a large bronze ritual food vessel. Early Western Zhou dynasty, 11th-10th century B.C. 15 in (38 cm) across handles. Sold for $555,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie’s New York

The Ge Zu Ji Gui, a large bronze ritual food vessel. Early Western Zhou dynasty, 11th-10th century B.C. 15 in (38 cm) across handles. Sold for $555,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie’s New York

Gui:  A ritual food vessel (above) with a compressed globular body, raised on a waisted foot, with a pair of loop handles usually decorated with animal heads.

The Ge Zuo Cong Yi Fangding. A rare bronze ritual rectangular food vessel. Early Western Zhou dynasty, 11th-10th century BC. 8½ in (21.5 cm) high. Estimate $500,000-700,000. Sold for $555,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie’s New York

The Ge Zuo Cong Yi Fangding. A rare bronze ritual rectangular food vessel. Early Western Zhou dynasty, 11th-10th century BC. 8½ in (21.5 cm) high. Estimate: $500,000-700,000. Sold for $555,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie’s New York

Square forms: Many of the standard shapes also appear in ‘square’ or fang  versions, including the fangzun, fanghu and fangding. Of great significance to the ancient ruling elites, square vessels are much more rare.

2. Look out for inscriptions

From the latter part of the Shang dynasty (1600-1100 BC) onwards, some Chinese bronze ritual vessels were marked with inscriptions which can indicate for whom the object was made, when, and for what purpose. 

Inscription on the interior of the Luboshez Gong, possibly a clan sign, of four footprints around what has been interpreted as two hands holding an album or book
Inscription on the interior of the Luboshez Gong, possibly a clan sign, of four footprints around what has been interpreted as two hands holding an album or book

Late Shang-dynasty and early Western Zhou-dynasty (11th-10th century BC) vessels tend to have simpler inscriptions, while those on Western Zhou-dynasty vessels (9th-8th century BC) tend to be longer and more complex. Inscriptions make a vessel more rare, and add to its value.

Dating these markings is key: in some cases, they will have been added by a collector long after the piece was originally produced.

3. Consider for whom the vessel may have been made

Chinese archaic bronze vessels often have extensive provenance, with ownership dating back hundreds of years. It makes sense that the finest examples often come from important and well-known collections, because they would have been commissioned by China’s most powerful figures.

The Shao Fangding. A rare and important bronze ritual rectangular food vessel. Late Shang dynasty, Anyang, 11th century B.C. 8⅛ in (20.7 cm) high. Sold for $1,095,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie’s New York

The Shao Fangding. A rare and important bronze ritual rectangular food vessel. Late Shang dynasty, Anyang, 11th century B.C. 8⅛ in (20.7 cm) high. Sold for $1,095,000 on 22 March 2019 at Christie’s New York

These vessels are often inscribed with significant clan marks, indicating the calibre of the patronage surrounding their manufacture. They are surviving symbols of China’s royalty and elite.

4. Take note of condition

The condition issues of archaic bronzes are not always immediately obvious. It is always important to take an X-ray of a bronze to check for hidden damage, because cracks or corrosion may have been carefully concealed using sophisticated restoration techniques.

5. Familiarise yourself with the different periods associated with ancient bronzes

Objects that fall under the category of ‘ancient Chinese bronzes’ span a period ranging some 1,800 years — from the Shang dynasty (1600-100 BC) to the Han (206 BC- 220 AD). It is important to understand the different styles associated with each period. The more ‘classic’ vessels — those most closely associated with archaic Chinese bronzes — were typically produced in the Shang (1600-1100 BC) and Western Zhou (1100-771 BC) dynasties.

A very rare and important silver-inlaid bronze corner mount. Warring States period, 4th-3rd century B.C. 4⅛ x 3⅛  in (10.5 x 7.9  cm). Sold for $271,500 on 17 March 2017  at Christie’s New York

A very rare and important silver-inlaid bronze corner mount. Warring States period, 4th-3rd century B.C. 4⅛ x 3⅛ in (10.5 x 7.9 cm). Sold for $271,500 on 17 March 2017 at Christie’s New York

New and more elaborate shapes, techniques and decoration were introduced in the Spring and Autumn period (770-476 BC), Warring States period (475-221 BC) and Han dynasty (206 BC-220 AD). Advancements in metalwork led to the use of intricate gold, silver and turquoise inlay in Warring States vessels, ornaments, fittings and blades. Complex designs including scrolls and interlocking animals were also a common feature in later periods.

6. Look out for bronze mirrors

Mirrors made in bronze, highly polished on one side, were also popular in ancient times. Although the earliest bronze mirrors date to Neolithic times, they only began to be mass-produced from the Warring States period (475-221 BC) onwards, with the finest examples dating to the Han (206 BC-220 AD) and Song (960-1279) dynasties.

A bronze circular mirror with deities and animals. China, mid-late Eastern Han dynasty, late 2nd-3rd century A.D. 5½  in (14  cm) diameter, box. Sold for $37,500 on 20 March 2015  at Christie’s New York

A bronze circular mirror with deities and animals. China, mid-late Eastern Han dynasty, late 2nd-3rd century A.D. 5½ in (14 cm) diameter, box. Sold for $37,500 on 20 March 2015 at Christie’s New York

Bronze mirrors were produced right up until the Qing dynasty (1644-1912), so it is important to identify the age of a mirror. Pay attention to the quality of casting and the style of design on the non-polished side.

7. Ornaments and ritual weapons

Bronze was also used to make ritual weapons including blades and axe heads, and elaborate ornaments such as belt hooks, which were an indication of status when worn by the elite. 

A gilt-bronze taotie mask and loose-ring handle. China, Six dynasties period (222-589 A.D). 7¾  in (19.7  cm) high overall, metal stand. Sold for $11,875 on 21 March 2019 at Christie’s New York

A gilt-bronze taotie mask and loose-ring handle. China, Six dynasties period (222-589 A.D). 7¾ in (19.7 cm) high overall, metal stand. Sold for $11,875 on 21 March 2019 at Christie’s New York

These were used in ceremonies, or were buried in the tombs of the elites for use in the afterlife.

8. Be wary of ‘archaistic’ pieces from later periods

‘Archaism’ is perhaps the most prominent theme in Chinese art throughout its long history. It is very common to find ancient bronze forms and motifs imitated in later periods, both in bronze and other materials such as jade and ceramics.

Ming and Qing-dynasty bronzes can often appear very similar to their predecessors, and this must be considered when dating a piece. Later Chinese bronzes should be regarded as fine artworks in their own right, paying tribute to China’s ancient masterpieces.