Descriptif du lot
Having famously declared, “With an apple, I want to astonish Paris!” Paul Cezanne has become synonymous with the still life and, perhaps even more so, the motif of the apple (quoted in Cezanne, exh. cat., Philadelphia Museum of Art, 1996, p. 383). Over the course of the 1870s, this humble fruit proliferated in Cezanne’s compositions, a perfect vehicle for his revelatory explorations into form, composition, and color, as he probed the nature of perception and representation itself. Cezanne’s “still lifes departed from the ‘silent life’ of things, rendering instead an object-filled world that exploded the conceptual limits conventionally assigned to a still life” (B. Leca, ed., The World is an Apple: The Still Lifes of Paul Cezanne, exh. cat., The Barnes Foundation, Philadelphia, 2014, p. 21).
Tasse, verre et fruits immerses the viewer in the artist’s carefully constructed world of objects. Six apples, ranging from green and soft yellow-hued orbs to fiery balls of orange and red, are positioned across the tabletop, flanked by a wine glass and a wide-brimmed cup. The backdrop for this scene is a delicate blue floral wallpaper, a pattern which is not seen in any of his other still lifes. Dating from the late 1870s, a pivotal moment in the artist’s life as he moved away from his Impressionist associations to pursue his own, distinct vision, this painting is one of an important group of still lifes from this time, each one sharing a similar cast of quotidian characters to achieve a varied and evermore daring array of compositional variations. Many of these works are now in museums including The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, The Art Institute of Chicago, and the Musée d’Orsay, Paris.
While seemingly an unplanned arrangement of everyday objects scattered across a tabletop, in fact, each element of this absorbing still-life scene would have been intensely scrutinized and meticulously planned by the artist. With this genre, Cezanne was able to construct worlds just as he wanted them for his painting, staging objects and their settings so that he could investigate relationships of space, color, and form. As Meyer Schapiro described, “his still-life is a model world that he has carefully set up…like the table of the strategist who meditates imaginary battles between the toy forces he has arranged on his variable terrain” (“The Apples of Cezanne: An Essay on the Meaning of Still Life” in Modern Art, 19th and 20th Centuries: Selected Papers, New York, 1978, p. 27).
The artist Louis Le Bail once witnessed Cezanne’s artful preparation of his still lifes, describing: “Cezanne arranged the fruits, contrasting the tones one against the other, making the complementaries vibrate, the greens against the reds, the yellows against the blues, tipping, turning, balancing the fruits as he wanted them to be using coins of one or two sous for the purpose. He brought to this task the greatest care and many precautions; one guessed that it was a feast for the eye to him” (quoted in Cezanne Paintings, exh. cat., Kunsthalle Tübingen, 1993, p. 172).
Tasse, verre et fruits is one such “feast for the eye,” a visual encapsulation of the artist’s compositional attention to detail. Each apple holds a plethora of both delicate and bold tonal contrasts, capturing the glossiness and gleam of their skin, as well as evoking their wholesome roundness. Pictorial complementaries abound—the teal-colored shadow that pools on the table between the left-hand trio of fruit works in perfect accord with its orange and peach neighbors in the forms of the apples.
For the love that he put into painting them,” the critic, Thadée Natanson, wrote of Cezanne’s apples, “he is and remains the painter of apples, smooth, round, fresh, weighty, bursting apples from which color flows, not those one would like to eat or that trompe l’oeil makes appealing to the gourmand, but with ravishing forms. It is he who has given them shining dresses of red and yellow, who has made tiles of reflecting light on their skins, who has encompassed in a loving stroke their rotundity, and has created from them a delicious, definitive image” (quoted in J. Rewald, The Paintings of Paul Cezanne: A Catalogue Raisonné, New York, 1996, vol. I, p. 232).
Yet, when regarded close up, these apples turn into abstract conglomerations of color, each carefully considered patch, stroke, and accretion of paint as compelling as the represented object that they denote. “I cannot convey my sensation immediately,” Cezanne described, “so I put color on again, and I keep putting it on as best I can” (quoted in J. Rewald, Paul Cezanne, trans. M.H. Liebman, London, 1959, p. 85). This dichotomy is what made Cezanne’s art so revolutionary: he worked in the boundary between representation and abstraction, creating at once recognizable “images,” which at the same time insistently declare themselves to be nothing more than strokes of pigment upon a canvas. “An apple must remain an apple to communicate to us that when it is transformed into a ‘painted apple’ it is something itself,” the art historian Denis Coutagne once wrote (quoted in exh. cat., op. cit., 2014, p. 25).
In contrast to the shimmering worlds of color that exist within the forms of the apples, when regarded as a whole, there is a definite weightiness and solidity to this still life. The apples’ shadows appear tangible, while the amber-colored liquid in the glass has an opacity that is at odds with its supposedly aqueous form. In many ways, this is a reflection of the major shift that had begun to occur in Cezanne’s art at this time. Beginning in the early 1870s, the artist had adopted the tenets of Impressionism, studying the effects of light and air and conveying these with his softer, brighter palette. Towards the end of this decade, however, he had begun to seek more from his art. As he famously said at this time, he wanted to create, “something more solid and enduring like the art in museums” (quoted in J. Rewald, op. cit., 1959, p. 122).
For Cezanne, Impressionism was ultimately too centered around the ephemeral effects of nature to enable him to achieve his desire at transcribing a direct perception of the world. He wanted to capture the structure, the essence, and the sensation of the subject in front of him, scrutinizing it and understanding it as a combination of forms, planes and colors. As a result, his art underwent a shift. Forms and objects became more stable and monumentalized as he focused increasingly on pictorial space and compositional structure.
This newly developing approach can be felt in the composition of the present work. The picture plane is formed around four horizontal planes that appear stacked on top of each other—the pale tabletop and then the three elements of what appears to be a wainscoted wall behind. The floral-patterned backdrop, with its green and white dado rail, is echoed in the decoration of the cup below. A similar protagonist can be found in the related Poterie, tasse et fruits sur une nappe blanche, also painted circa 1877 (FWN, no. 737; The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York), its broad, yawning mouth interrupting the otherwise insistently horizontal emphasis of the composition. This segmentation of the composition was radical for the time, as Cezanne increasingly reveled in revealing the artifice inherent in painting, and particularly the still-life genre.
The first owner of Tasse, verre et fruits was Paul Gallimard, the father of the founder of the eponymous French publishing house. Having studied painting at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts, Gallimard was an important and early patron of the Impressionists, particularly Pierre-Auguste Renoir, with whom he was friends. With his inherited fortune, Gallimard acquired a number of theaters in Paris, and lived in a spectacular hotel on the rue Saint-Lazare, where he hung his artistic treasures, including Vincent van Gogh’s Roses and Edouard Manet’s Huitres, both now housed in the National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C.
The present work remained in Gallimard’s family collection until 1929, when it was sold to the dealer, Paul Cassirer. In 1936, it entered the collection of Siegfried Kramarsky, a German-born banker, philanthropist, and art collector. During a period spent in Amsterdam, he acquired an important group of Van Goghs including his portrait of Doctor Gachet (1890; Private collection). Tasse, verre et fruits remained in his collection until 1986, when it was acquired by the present owner, with whom it has remained for the past forty years.
Tasse, verre et fruits immerses the viewer in the artist’s carefully constructed world of objects. Six apples, ranging from green and soft yellow-hued orbs to fiery balls of orange and red, are positioned across the tabletop, flanked by a wine glass and a wide-brimmed cup. The backdrop for this scene is a delicate blue floral wallpaper, a pattern which is not seen in any of his other still lifes. Dating from the late 1870s, a pivotal moment in the artist’s life as he moved away from his Impressionist associations to pursue his own, distinct vision, this painting is one of an important group of still lifes from this time, each one sharing a similar cast of quotidian characters to achieve a varied and evermore daring array of compositional variations. Many of these works are now in museums including The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, The Art Institute of Chicago, and the Musée d’Orsay, Paris.
While seemingly an unplanned arrangement of everyday objects scattered across a tabletop, in fact, each element of this absorbing still-life scene would have been intensely scrutinized and meticulously planned by the artist. With this genre, Cezanne was able to construct worlds just as he wanted them for his painting, staging objects and their settings so that he could investigate relationships of space, color, and form. As Meyer Schapiro described, “his still-life is a model world that he has carefully set up…like the table of the strategist who meditates imaginary battles between the toy forces he has arranged on his variable terrain” (“The Apples of Cezanne: An Essay on the Meaning of Still Life” in Modern Art, 19th and 20th Centuries: Selected Papers, New York, 1978, p. 27).
The artist Louis Le Bail once witnessed Cezanne’s artful preparation of his still lifes, describing: “Cezanne arranged the fruits, contrasting the tones one against the other, making the complementaries vibrate, the greens against the reds, the yellows against the blues, tipping, turning, balancing the fruits as he wanted them to be using coins of one or two sous for the purpose. He brought to this task the greatest care and many precautions; one guessed that it was a feast for the eye to him” (quoted in Cezanne Paintings, exh. cat., Kunsthalle Tübingen, 1993, p. 172).
Tasse, verre et fruits is one such “feast for the eye,” a visual encapsulation of the artist’s compositional attention to detail. Each apple holds a plethora of both delicate and bold tonal contrasts, capturing the glossiness and gleam of their skin, as well as evoking their wholesome roundness. Pictorial complementaries abound—the teal-colored shadow that pools on the table between the left-hand trio of fruit works in perfect accord with its orange and peach neighbors in the forms of the apples.
For the love that he put into painting them,” the critic, Thadée Natanson, wrote of Cezanne’s apples, “he is and remains the painter of apples, smooth, round, fresh, weighty, bursting apples from which color flows, not those one would like to eat or that trompe l’oeil makes appealing to the gourmand, but with ravishing forms. It is he who has given them shining dresses of red and yellow, who has made tiles of reflecting light on their skins, who has encompassed in a loving stroke their rotundity, and has created from them a delicious, definitive image” (quoted in J. Rewald, The Paintings of Paul Cezanne: A Catalogue Raisonné, New York, 1996, vol. I, p. 232).
Yet, when regarded close up, these apples turn into abstract conglomerations of color, each carefully considered patch, stroke, and accretion of paint as compelling as the represented object that they denote. “I cannot convey my sensation immediately,” Cezanne described, “so I put color on again, and I keep putting it on as best I can” (quoted in J. Rewald, Paul Cezanne, trans. M.H. Liebman, London, 1959, p. 85). This dichotomy is what made Cezanne’s art so revolutionary: he worked in the boundary between representation and abstraction, creating at once recognizable “images,” which at the same time insistently declare themselves to be nothing more than strokes of pigment upon a canvas. “An apple must remain an apple to communicate to us that when it is transformed into a ‘painted apple’ it is something itself,” the art historian Denis Coutagne once wrote (quoted in exh. cat., op. cit., 2014, p. 25).
In contrast to the shimmering worlds of color that exist within the forms of the apples, when regarded as a whole, there is a definite weightiness and solidity to this still life. The apples’ shadows appear tangible, while the amber-colored liquid in the glass has an opacity that is at odds with its supposedly aqueous form. In many ways, this is a reflection of the major shift that had begun to occur in Cezanne’s art at this time. Beginning in the early 1870s, the artist had adopted the tenets of Impressionism, studying the effects of light and air and conveying these with his softer, brighter palette. Towards the end of this decade, however, he had begun to seek more from his art. As he famously said at this time, he wanted to create, “something more solid and enduring like the art in museums” (quoted in J. Rewald, op. cit., 1959, p. 122).
For Cezanne, Impressionism was ultimately too centered around the ephemeral effects of nature to enable him to achieve his desire at transcribing a direct perception of the world. He wanted to capture the structure, the essence, and the sensation of the subject in front of him, scrutinizing it and understanding it as a combination of forms, planes and colors. As a result, his art underwent a shift. Forms and objects became more stable and monumentalized as he focused increasingly on pictorial space and compositional structure.
This newly developing approach can be felt in the composition of the present work. The picture plane is formed around four horizontal planes that appear stacked on top of each other—the pale tabletop and then the three elements of what appears to be a wainscoted wall behind. The floral-patterned backdrop, with its green and white dado rail, is echoed in the decoration of the cup below. A similar protagonist can be found in the related Poterie, tasse et fruits sur une nappe blanche, also painted circa 1877 (FWN, no. 737; The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York), its broad, yawning mouth interrupting the otherwise insistently horizontal emphasis of the composition. This segmentation of the composition was radical for the time, as Cezanne increasingly reveled in revealing the artifice inherent in painting, and particularly the still-life genre.
The first owner of Tasse, verre et fruits was Paul Gallimard, the father of the founder of the eponymous French publishing house. Having studied painting at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts, Gallimard was an important and early patron of the Impressionists, particularly Pierre-Auguste Renoir, with whom he was friends. With his inherited fortune, Gallimard acquired a number of theaters in Paris, and lived in a spectacular hotel on the rue Saint-Lazare, where he hung his artistic treasures, including Vincent van Gogh’s Roses and Edouard Manet’s Huitres, both now housed in the National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C.
The present work remained in Gallimard’s family collection until 1929, when it was sold to the dealer, Paul Cassirer. In 1936, it entered the collection of Siegfried Kramarsky, a German-born banker, philanthropist, and art collector. During a period spent in Amsterdam, he acquired an important group of Van Goghs including his portrait of Doctor Gachet (1890; Private collection). Tasse, verre et fruits remained in his collection until 1986, when it was acquired by the present owner, with whom it has remained for the past forty years.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
