Lot Essay
Gluck (1925) dated this splendid early work by Van Dyck to 1625, believing that it came from the artist's second sojourn in Rome; he was the first scholar to recognize that it dates from the artist's youthful Italian period. Susan Barnes (1997) located the picture even earlier, to Van Dyck's first stay in Genoa, thus dating it circa 1621-1622; she compares the curvacious forms and languid manner of Saint John to figures that appear in several works that can be securely documented to the early 1620s, including Suffer Little Children Come unto Me (National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa); and two versions of the Martyrdom of Saint Sebastian (National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh; Alte Pinakothek, Munich). Larsen dates the painting to 1623-1625, and suggests that it might be identical with a 'San Gio: Battista nel deserto' mentioned by Bellori as in the collection of the English amateur Sir Kenelm Digby.
Although the gentle saints of Guido Reni have been proposed as inspiration for the present painting (see Princeton, 1979), Larsen is certainly correct when he observed the closer connection to the dramatic handling of light and shade found in the works of Caravaggio; certainly Van Dyck's sensual and contemplative young saint suggests a familiarity with Caravaggio's psychologically complex version of the same subject, today in the Nelson-Atkins Museum, Kansas City.
Although the gentle saints of Guido Reni have been proposed as inspiration for the present painting (see Princeton, 1979), Larsen is certainly correct when he observed the closer connection to the dramatic handling of light and shade found in the works of Caravaggio; certainly Van Dyck's sensual and contemplative young saint suggests a familiarity with Caravaggio's psychologically complex version of the same subject, today in the Nelson-Atkins Museum, Kansas City.