Lot Essay
Lilla Perry relates a most interesting story about this very bottle. The tale begins with a meeting of collectors in Los Angeles, brought together by the dealer Gertrude Stuart, for a showing of bottles recently acquired in the Orient. Her method of selling was for the collectors to draw numbers in preferential order for choosing the bottle they wanted. Lilla Perry had spotted this Qianlong-marked bottle and immediately recognized its intrinsic beauty, though suspecting it to be 18th century rather than by Ye Bengqi. Sadly, she drew number nine and the bottle was gone. The collector who purchased it was Albert Pyke. The bottle passed from that source indirectly to the Reifs
Ye Bengqi was a member of a family of four, best known for their skills at painting inside snuff bottles. According to Robert W. L. Kleiner, Chinese Snuff Bottles from the Mary and George Bloch Collection, p. 23, Hugh Moss learned in an interview with Ye Bengqi in Beijing in 1974 that the brothers used to visit the Beijing Museum and memorize the patterns depicted on the authentic glass bottles and wares on display. They would then attempt to re-create them. The results were technically brilliant. However, a comparison of the glass and enameling style soon reveals differences. Ye family bottles are meticulous to a fault but lack the vigor and freedom associated with the 18th century originals. The enamels are more opaque in the copies and the glass itself lacks the pitting commonly found on the precursors
For other examples, see Chris Randall, Important Chinese Snuff Bottles, 1991,Catalogue, fig. 1; Robert Hall, Chinese Snuff Bottles III, 1990, Catalogue, fig. 10; Bob C. Stevens, The Collector's Book of Chinese Snuff Bottles, pls. 945-946
Ye Bengqi was a member of a family of four, best known for their skills at painting inside snuff bottles. According to Robert W. L. Kleiner, Chinese Snuff Bottles from the Mary and George Bloch Collection, p. 23, Hugh Moss learned in an interview with Ye Bengqi in Beijing in 1974 that the brothers used to visit the Beijing Museum and memorize the patterns depicted on the authentic glass bottles and wares on display. They would then attempt to re-create them. The results were technically brilliant. However, a comparison of the glass and enameling style soon reveals differences. Ye family bottles are meticulous to a fault but lack the vigor and freedom associated with the 18th century originals. The enamels are more opaque in the copies and the glass itself lacks the pitting commonly found on the precursors
For other examples, see Chris Randall, Important Chinese Snuff Bottles, 1991,Catalogue, fig. 1; Robert Hall, Chinese Snuff Bottles III, 1990, Catalogue, fig. 10; Bob C. Stevens, The Collector's Book of Chinese Snuff Bottles, pls. 945-946