Lot Essay
This drawing had been attributed to Claude until Blunt proposed an attribution to Poussin, and suggested a date in the 1640s. He compared the technique and handling with the Uffizi View of the Aventine and studies in the Louvre for The Finding of Moses and The Baptism of Christ, H. Brigstocke, A Loan Exhibition of Drawings by Nicolas Poussin from British Collections, 1990, figs. 40 and 37. Brigstocke suggests that a drawing in the Winslow Ames collection attributed to Claude is also by Poussin, M. Roethlisberger, op. cit., no. 421. If the Ames drawing is not by Poussin, it suggests Claude must have seen landscape studies drawn from life such as this one.
The fullest account of the drawing is in the Edinburgh catalogue: 'few studies from nature by Poussin are more economical in means or harmonious in construction than the Holkham drawing. Three broad bands of wash, gradually lightening in tone, serve to define the extent of the view. Reducing the entire motif to horizontal and diagonal accents, Poussin imbues it with an order and rationality comparable to that of certain of Cézanne's mature watercolours of the Mont Saint-Victoire'
The fullest account of the drawing is in the Edinburgh catalogue: 'few studies from nature by Poussin are more economical in means or harmonious in construction than the Holkham drawing. Three broad bands of wash, gradually lightening in tone, serve to define the extent of the view. Reducing the entire motif to horizontal and diagonal accents, Poussin imbues it with an order and rationality comparable to that of certain of Cézanne's mature watercolours of the Mont Saint-Victoire'