Lot Essay
In his dissertation (loc. cit.), Spalding dates the present painting to around 1588. He notes that Santi di Tito appears to have derived elements for it from preliminary drawings now in the Uffizi, Florence (U773F & U771F) that had been executed as preparatory studies for the Crucifixion of circa 1588 in Santa Croce, but which were then abandoned by the artist in relation to that composition.
Like the artist's Lamentation in Pisa dated by Spalding to 1575-1585, the present painting displays the same treatment of the halo and very similar wounds to Christ's side. The nails in the foreground also appear in the Pisan Lamentation and in the paintings of the Pieta in Scrofiano and in the Accademia, Venice.
The motif of the swooning Madonna may derive from Barocci's Deposition in the Cathedral, Perugia of 1567-1569 (see fig. 1).
Like the artist's Lamentation in Pisa dated by Spalding to 1575-1585, the present painting displays the same treatment of the halo and very similar wounds to Christ's side. The nails in the foreground also appear in the Pisan Lamentation and in the paintings of the Pieta in Scrofiano and in the Accademia, Venice.
The motif of the swooning Madonna may derive from Barocci's Deposition in the Cathedral, Perugia of 1567-1569 (see fig. 1).