A FRENCH AND ITALIAN SILVER-GILT TABLE SERVICE FROM THE BORGHESE SERVICE
A FRENCH AND ITALIAN SILVER-GILT TABLE SERVICE FROM THE BORGHESE SERVICE

MOST PIECES MARKS OF MARTIN-GUILLAUME BIENNAIS, PIERRE-BENÔIT LORILLON, PARIS, 1789-1819 AND PIETRO PAOLA SPAGNA, ROME, CIRCA 1820

Details
A FRENCH AND ITALIAN SILVER-GILT TABLE SERVICE FROM THE BORGHESE SERVICE
MOST PIECES MARKS OF MARTIN-GUILLAUME BIENNAIS, PIERRE-BENÔIT LORILLON, PARIS, 1789-1819 AND PIETRO PAOLA SPAGNA, ROME, CIRCA 1820
Each stem chased with anthemion and baskets of flowers, engraved with a coat of arms, comprising:
Thirty-six table spoons, twenty-one mark of Pietro Paola Spagna, Rome; fifteen mark of Pierre-Benôit Lorillon, Paris, 1789-1819
Seven dessert spoons with peacock handles, Pierre-Benôit Lorillon, Paris, 1789-1809, one lacking arms
Six dessert spoons with basket of flower-basket handles, François-Dominique Naudin, Paris, 1819-1838
Thirty-four table forks, twenty-three mark of Pietro Paola Spagna, Rome; eleven mark of Pierre-Benôit Lorillon, Paris, 1789-1819
Twelve dessert forks with basket of flower-basket handles, François-Dominique Naudin, Paris, 1891-1838
Thirty-six table knives with steel blades stamped AU SINGE VIOLET, twenty-four mark of Martin-Guillaume Biennais, Paris, 1809-1819; twelve mark of Pietro Paola Spagna, Rome
Twelve dessert knives with steel blades stamped AU SINGE VIOLET, mark of Martin-Guillaume Biennais, 1789-1809
268 oz. 10 dwt. (8368 gr.) weighable silver
The arms are those of Borghese, as borne by Prince Camillo Borghese (136)
Provenance
Prince Camillo Borghese, who married Pauline Bonaparte, the sister of the Emperor Napoleon on 6 November 1803
The Borghese Palace Sale, Giacomini and Capobianchi, Rome, 28 March - 9 April 1892, part of lot 847
Don Antonio Licata
Prince Baucina
Ercole Canessa
Mrs. Edith Rockefeller McCormick, American Art Association/Anderson Galleries Inc., New York, 5 January 1934
Exhibited
Chicago, The Art Institute of Chicago, June 1924 - November 1932

Lot Essay

The Borghese Service, comprising 500 silver-gilt objects primarily by the French Imperial silversmith Martin-Guillaume Biennais and over 1,000 pieces of table silver, was traditionally thought to have been a gift from Napoleon to his second sister Pauline Bonaparte (1780-1825) on the occasion of her 1803 marriage to Prince Camillo Borghese (1775-1832). However, Biennais inscribed a number of pieces "Orfe de Lrs. .tis. Imperiales et Royales" indicating that most of the service post-dates 1805, when Napoleon was styled King of Italy. In addition, many of the French pieces have Paris hallmarks for 1809-1819.

Pauline Borghese's marriage was an unhappy union. She spent most of her time in Paris, until the fall of Napoleon, when she returned to Rome and took up residence in the Borghese Palace. She joined her husband in Florence shortly before her early death in 1825. In the 1820s, Florentine and Roman silversmiths contributed to the service by following the original Biennais models. The later additions may have been ordered by both spouses, as the service was split between Rome and Florence.

In 1892 the entire service was offered as one lot at the sale of contents of the Borghese Palace. After changing hands three times, the service became part of the collection of Edith Rockefeller McCormick and was exhibited in its entirety at the Art Institute of Chicago from 1924-1932. Upon Mrs. McCormick's death, American Art Association/Anderson Galleries sold the service in 150 lots. Widely scattered today, the Borghese service is found in numerous public collections including the Louvre and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

More from The C. Ruxton and Audrey B. Love Collection: Magnificent

View All
View All