Edgar Degas (1834-1917)
Fifty Years of Passion for Art Inspired by an unbridled passion for art, the late Ellen and Paul Hirschland spent their half century together building an exquisite collection of paintings, drawings, and sculpture that filled their home from floor to ceiling and suffused their lives and those of their children with beautiful objects, valued artist friends, and endless adventures and stories. Many of the artists whose works the couple collected frequently enjoyed stimulating discussions and lively meals in the Hirschland home, surrounded by their own works in the Tudor house on Long Island. By chance, both collectors came to their passion naturally. Paul Hirschland grew up in Germany in a home amid not only classic works by Tintoretto and his contemporaries, but also by van Gogh, Sisley, Monet, and other Impressionists. Ellen Berney Hirschland was raised in Baltimore, the great-niece of Claribel and Etta Cone, who left their internationally admired large collection of Matisses, Picassos, and other treasures to the Baltimore Museum of Art. As a teenager, Ellen enjoyed a close friendship with her great-aunt Etta Cone, and joined her in European travels. In 1936, they toured galleries throughout France and Switzerland and especially enjoyed visiting Henri Matisse, who invited the 17-year-old aspiring art historian to choose a favorite drawing, which he signed and presented to her. Ellen and M. Matisse stayed in touch until his death in 1954. As New Yorkers, the Hirschlands visited galleries and museums every weekend in the metro area, and traveled widely to see public art and visit private collections around the United States and in Europe. They always included their children in these jaunts, even procuring special permission for their young family to be admitted to the Frick Gallery, which at the time excluded children under 10 years of age. Their bent toward helping others understand and appreciate art was deeply instilled. Ellen Hirschland, who majored in art history at Wheaton College in Massachusetts, eventually curated shows for the Great Neck Public School system and the Heckscher Museum on Long Island, and led waiting-list-only adult education art tours for almost 35 years, first for the Adult Program of the Great Neck schools, then with two of her three children, to American and European destinations. She served as trustee of the Baltimore Museum of Art and of the Heckscher Museum. Ellen and Paul Hirschland's taste in art grew and changed over time-from Impressionism to hard edge. But their collection always reflected a dedication and love for each and every piece they owned, for they always honored an early agreement that they would buy only works that appealed to them both. The collectors had a profound knowledge of the art on their walls. Whereas Paul Hirschland mostly educated and entertained at soirées in their home, Ellen Hirschland not only taught, but also wrote about art. She contributed several entries to the Dictionary of American Biography, notably about Maud and Chester Dale, whose collection belongs to the National Gallery in Washington, D.C., and wrote a chapter in the Museum of Modern Art's book Four Americans in Paris, about her great-aunts and Gertrude Stein. A book on the Cone sisters, co-authored with her daughter, is forthcoming. Selected Works from the Hirschland Collection
Edgar Degas (1834-1917)

Grande arabesque, troisième temps

Details
Edgar Degas (1834-1917)
Grande arabesque, troisième temps
stamped with signature, numbered and stamped with foundry mark 'Degas (Lugt 658) 16/L AA HEBRARD CIRE PERDUE' (on the base)
bronze with dark brown patina
Height: 15½ inches (39.4 cm.)
Original wax model executed 1882-1895 and cast between 1919 and 1921 in an edition of twenty-two, numbered A to T plus two casts reserved for the Degas heirs and the founder Hébrard; marked 'HER' and 'HER.D' respectively.
Provenance
Alfred Flechtheim, Berlin (15 July 1926).
Fine Arts Associates (Otto Gerson), New York.
Paul M. Hirschland, New York (acquired in 1947).
By descent from the above to the present owner.
Literature
J. Rewald, ed., Degas, Works in Sculpture, A Complete Catalogue, New York, 1944, p. 24, no. XL (another cast illustrated, p. 95).
L. Browse, Degas Dancers, London, 1949, p. 388, no. 155 (another cast illustrated).
F. Russoli and F. Minervino, L'opera completa di Degas, Milan, 1970, p. 140, no. S8 (another cast illustrated).
C.W. Millard, The Sculpture of Edgar Degas, Princeton, 1976, no. 91 (another cast illustrated).
J. Rewald, Degas's Complete Sculpture, San Francisco, 1990, pp. 118-119, no. XL (another cast illustrated).
S. Campbell, "A Catalogue of Degas Bronzes", in Apollo, August 1995, p. 18, no. 16 (another cast illustrated).
J.S. Czestochowski and A. Pingeot, Degas Sculptures: Catalogue Raisonné of the Bronzes, Memphis, 2002, p. 153, no. 16 (another cast illustrated in color, p. 152).
Exhibited
New York, The Museum of Modern Art, Summer Exhibition: Retrospective, June-September 1930.
New York, Fine Arts Associates (Otto Gerson), French Art Around 1900--From van Gogh to Matisse, October-November, 1953, no. 10.
Great Neck Education Association, Living With Art, March 1952, no. 58.

Lot Essay

Of the seventy-four wax sculptures by Degas that were cast in bronze, forty are dancers, and seven of these show dancers executing various forms of the arabesque, the most beautifully poised and classically balanced of all ballet poses. In it the dancer positions herself so that she creates the longest possible line from her fingertips to her toes; the pose is normally used to conclude a phrase of steps. The present sculpture is more correctly titled Première arabesque penchée, referring to the point in the dancer's movement when she leans furthest forward, with her hand only inches from the ground. In actual practice she would have been supported by a male partner, as in a pas-de-deux, or held on to a barre in the dance classroom or studio; it would have otherwise been impossible for the dancer, pitched this far forward, to recover and again assume an upright stance.

It is perhaps the precariousness of this pose that attracted Degas, who must have relished the challenge of the idea of depicting the body at the extreme limit of balance. Among his arabesque poses, two other versions show the arabesque penchée, sculptures nos. 2 and 60 (Rewald nos. XLI and XXXIX, respectively). Sculpture no. 60 shows a very young and lithe dancer, and has been labeled première étude; the present work, le deuxième étude depicts a dancer with a more mature figure. While other sculptures showing arabesque poses have counterparts in Degas' paintings, pastels and drawings, no other works show the arabesque penchée, possibly because the pose in a stage composition would have required a male partner, a subject that Degas avoided. It seems likely that Degas' interest in the pose was exclusively sculptural, and that he did not intend to use it as a model for drawing the figure, a function that many other sculptures served while in progress or once they were completed.

This approach reflects a shift in Degas' sensibility, coming very late in his career, away from a naturalistic rendering of the figure to a more symbolical conception, in which the dancer embodies in her movement feelings of striving and risk. John Rewald wrote that the artist's hands now "modeled with more energy, less care, and their very feverishness seemed to be transmitted to the material. But this feverishness has nothing disordered about it, it corresponds to the almost youthful fire which so many great masters come to in their old age. The care for detail has disappeared; both hand and eye go after what is essential with the raw strength which comes from knowledge and experience. The movements to which he had devoted such research he now represents in a style which is itself teeming with agitation. In his hands wax is no longer an inert material; his fingers mould it almost frenzy, constructing masses which no longer borrow from nature the smooth surface of human bodies, but express, right down to their rough texture, the pulsations of life and the breath of the creator" (in op. cit., 1990, pp. 23 and 24 ).

More from Impressionist and Modern Art Evening Sale

View All
View All