Lot Essay
Dated 1610, this beautifully preserved work is the earliest version of one of the rarest and most dynamic of Pieter Brueghel the Younger’s subjects: The Country Brawl, known in French as La Rixe. Dr Klaus Ertz describes it as ‘une merveilleuse version de 1610’ (exhibition catalogue, Antwerp, 1998, p. 396) and places it in his catalogue raisonné at the head of eight autograph versions of the composition, two of which are in museums: Musée Fabre, Montpellier (inv. no. 876-3-4; Ertz, no. E1056); and Philadelphia Museum of Art, John G. Johnson Collection (acc. no. J 422; Ertz, no. E1063). A third is on loan to the Národní galerie, Prague, from a private collection (inv. no. VO 1371; Ertz, no. E1058). The seven versions besides the present panel can be subdivided by size: three measuring roughly 40 x 55 cm., three roughly 75 x 105 cm., and one fragment measuring 27.4 x 32.8 cm. (Ertz, no. E1059). The present work belongs with the smaller formats, a classification on which Ertz expressly corrects Marlier. Only five of the eight are both signed and dated. With the exception of the present work, all the dated versions were painted within the same four-year period, 1619-22. The form of the signature, using the spelling ‘BRVEGHEL’, is unique amongst the various versions; the other signed examples use ‘BREVGHEL’, a spelling the artist seems to have adopted only after circa 1616.
The date of 1610 gives the present work a special status within the context of the known versions of this subject. Executed during this earlier phase of Brueghel’s activity, the ex-Coppée picture is distinguished by its highly elaborate under-drawing, its exceptional attention to detail and the high quality of its execution. These factors combine to make it not only the earliest but also the finest of all the known versions of this extraordinarily powerful composition.
There is some debate as to the origins of the subject. It is one of the few compositions by Pieter Brueghel the Younger that cannot be matched to a surviving prototype by his celebrated father, Pieter Bruegel the Elder. This could suggest that the composition is entirely of Pieter the Younger’s invention, as would seem to be the case for some other subjects, for example the Payment of the Tithes (also known as The Country Lawyer; see Ertz, nos. E489-E511a). It is generally assumed, however, that the composition is the only record of a lost painting by Pieter Bruegel the Elder, which could have been known to Pieter the Younger in the original, or through a studio cartoon or preparatory drawings. As early as 1907, Hulin de Loo argued that a composition of such accomplishment must go back to the Elder: ‘c’est un des groupes les plus complexes, les plus vivants, les plus violents et les plus réalistes et en même temps les plus plastiques dont l’histoire de l’art nous fournisse l’exemple...Bruegel a atteint ici l’apogée de son art’ (‘this is one of the most complex, the most lifelike, the most violent, the most realistic and at the same time the most sculptural figural groups of which the history of art provides example...here Bruegel [the Elder] attains the apogee of his art’; cited by Marlier, op. cit., p. 265).
In his discussion of the present picture in the 1998 exhibition catalogue (ibid.), Ertz notes the strong resemblance of the facial types to those in works by the Elder, such as The Peasant and the Nest Robber (Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum) or the drawing Summer (Hamburg, Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett). There is, moreover, an engraving of the composition by Pieter the Younger’s younger contemporary Lucas Vorsterman (1595-1675), which shows the event in reverse and bears the inscription ‘Peter Bruegel invent’ (fig. 1). Assuming that this refers to the elder artist and not his son, it would indicate an awareness, among the generation of artists that included Pieter the Younger, his brother Jan Brueghel the Elder and the latter’s friend Sir Peter Paul Rubens, of Pieter the Elder’s invention of the composition. To complicate matters, however, the print – which must date to circa 1620 – also bears in its legend a long dedication in Latin to Jan Brueghel the Elder, ‘Clariss. Praestantissimoq. Viro Dño Ioanni Bruegelio, Petri Bruegelii sui temporis Apellis Filio, Paternae Artis haeredi ex asse, hoc paternae manus monumentum artificiosissimum…’. This effectively dedicates ‘this monument to the art of the father’ to the son of ‘Pieter Bruegel, the Apelles of his time’, Jan Brueghel, ‘the heir of his art’.
On the other hand, like most of his contemporaries, Hulin de Loo was inclined to diminish Pieter the Younger’s creative abilities by comparison with his father’s, and it is not implausible that there was never a prototype by Pieter the Elder, in which case this would be one of Pieter the Younger’s most successful original inventions. In this respect it can be related to The Bad Shepherd (Christie’s, London, 8 July 2008, lot 38, £2,505,250), a unique composition with no prototype by the father, for many years attributed to him because of its high quality but in fact a masterpiece by the son.
Setting aside the question of the uncertain existence of a prototype by Pieter the Elder, the production and dedication of the engraving show how highly regarded the composition was in the time of Pieter the Younger, Jan the Elder and Rubens. It probably inspired Rubens, as a drawing of circa 1620-25 attributed to that artist, in black chalk and wash, repeats several of the figures involved in the tussle (Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen; inv. no. V 8 (PK)), replacing several of the faces with more typically ‘Rubensian’ types – the figure wielding the flail at left, for example, is given a beard and a wild shock of hair, as well as muscled calves suitable for a Hercules. Interestingly, the Vorsterman engraving records just such a figure in this role. Vorsterman worked in Rubens’s studio as his ‘in-house’ engraver, and it is likely that he was given the task of reproducing Brueghel’s composition with Rubens’s approval. Perhaps Rubens himself commissioned the engraving from Vorsterman – the dedication to Jan Brueghel, who was one of Rubens’s close friends (Rubens painted the touching family portrait of Jan Brueghel with his wife and children now in the Courtauld Gallery, London), lends credence to this hypothesis.
A version exhibited in 1992 as a collaboration between Rubens and Jan Brueghel the Elder – a panel in a private collection (94 x 124 cm.), presented as an original by Jan retouched by Rubens – is not accepted as such by Ertz, who recognises neither Rubens’s hand in the figures nor Jan’s in the landscape (see the catalogue of the exhibition De Bruegel à Rubens: l’école de peinture anversoise, 1550-1650, Antwerp, 1992, pp. 170-71, no. 73, illustrated). Marlier follows Hulin de Loo and van Bastelaer in citing another, smaller (36.5 x 46 cm.) putative copy from Rubens’s hand (see Marlier, op. cit., p. 267 and notes). Rubens was a great admirer of Pieter the Elder and owned no fewer than twelve paintings by him, as recorded in the inventory of his estate (1640). The same inventory lists, under no. 142 and among Rubens’s own works, a painting of ‘Des paysans qui se battent, fait d’après un dessin du Vieux Bruegel’ – evidence that Rubens himself painted the composition after a lost drawing by Pieter the Elder. It cannot be excluded, however, that Rubens may have owned the prototype by the Elder. Alternatively, it may have remained in family hands, in the possession of Jan Brueghel the Elder – further justification for the dedication of Vorsterman’s engraving of one of Rubens’s favourite Bruegels, which he might have seen in the collection of his friend Jan. Marlier suggests (op. cit., p. 266) that a work belonging to Jan Brueghel the Elder may be the one which the great British patron and collector Thomas Howard, 2nd Earl of Arundel, ordered his Antwerp agent Lionel Wake to purchase around 1625, ‘a painting begun by Bruegel and finished by Mostaert, showing a peasant brawl over a game of cards, which has been engraved by Vorsterman’. Gillis Mostaert (1534-1598) was a contemporary of Pieter the Elder who outlived him, and who could well have been asked to complete a painting left unfinished. The specificity of the attribution in Arundel’s instructions is striking; the picture reappears in the inventory drawn up in Amsterdam around 1655 after the death of Lady Arundel, as ‘Bruegel. Contadini che si batteno’, which may well be the last trace of the prototype. The present work was for many years given to Pieter the Elder – for example, when in the Lanz collection – an attribution which, given its quality and early date, is not surprising.
The collection of the industrialist Baron Evence III Coppée (1882-1945) was formed in Brussels between 1920 and 1939. The focus was on sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century Flemish painting, with a special emphasis on the work of Pieter the Younger, whom Coppée much admired for his treatment of humanist themes. In all, he owned nine works by the artist, a group that set the example for many later collectors of Brueghel in Belgium. Much of the collection, including the present lot, was proudly displayed in the stately Coppée mansion, built in 1928 on the Avenue des Nations (now Avenue Franklin D. Roosevelt), Brussels (fig. 2).
The date of 1610 gives the present work a special status within the context of the known versions of this subject. Executed during this earlier phase of Brueghel’s activity, the ex-Coppée picture is distinguished by its highly elaborate under-drawing, its exceptional attention to detail and the high quality of its execution. These factors combine to make it not only the earliest but also the finest of all the known versions of this extraordinarily powerful composition.
There is some debate as to the origins of the subject. It is one of the few compositions by Pieter Brueghel the Younger that cannot be matched to a surviving prototype by his celebrated father, Pieter Bruegel the Elder. This could suggest that the composition is entirely of Pieter the Younger’s invention, as would seem to be the case for some other subjects, for example the Payment of the Tithes (also known as The Country Lawyer; see Ertz, nos. E489-E511a). It is generally assumed, however, that the composition is the only record of a lost painting by Pieter Bruegel the Elder, which could have been known to Pieter the Younger in the original, or through a studio cartoon or preparatory drawings. As early as 1907, Hulin de Loo argued that a composition of such accomplishment must go back to the Elder: ‘c’est un des groupes les plus complexes, les plus vivants, les plus violents et les plus réalistes et en même temps les plus plastiques dont l’histoire de l’art nous fournisse l’exemple...Bruegel a atteint ici l’apogée de son art’ (‘this is one of the most complex, the most lifelike, the most violent, the most realistic and at the same time the most sculptural figural groups of which the history of art provides example...here Bruegel [the Elder] attains the apogee of his art’; cited by Marlier, op. cit., p. 265).
In his discussion of the present picture in the 1998 exhibition catalogue (ibid.), Ertz notes the strong resemblance of the facial types to those in works by the Elder, such as The Peasant and the Nest Robber (Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum) or the drawing Summer (Hamburg, Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett). There is, moreover, an engraving of the composition by Pieter the Younger’s younger contemporary Lucas Vorsterman (1595-1675), which shows the event in reverse and bears the inscription ‘Peter Bruegel invent’ (fig. 1). Assuming that this refers to the elder artist and not his son, it would indicate an awareness, among the generation of artists that included Pieter the Younger, his brother Jan Brueghel the Elder and the latter’s friend Sir Peter Paul Rubens, of Pieter the Elder’s invention of the composition. To complicate matters, however, the print – which must date to circa 1620 – also bears in its legend a long dedication in Latin to Jan Brueghel the Elder, ‘Clariss. Praestantissimoq. Viro Dño Ioanni Bruegelio, Petri Bruegelii sui temporis Apellis Filio, Paternae Artis haeredi ex asse, hoc paternae manus monumentum artificiosissimum…’. This effectively dedicates ‘this monument to the art of the father’ to the son of ‘Pieter Bruegel, the Apelles of his time’, Jan Brueghel, ‘the heir of his art’.
On the other hand, like most of his contemporaries, Hulin de Loo was inclined to diminish Pieter the Younger’s creative abilities by comparison with his father’s, and it is not implausible that there was never a prototype by Pieter the Elder, in which case this would be one of Pieter the Younger’s most successful original inventions. In this respect it can be related to The Bad Shepherd (Christie’s, London, 8 July 2008, lot 38, £2,505,250), a unique composition with no prototype by the father, for many years attributed to him because of its high quality but in fact a masterpiece by the son.
Setting aside the question of the uncertain existence of a prototype by Pieter the Elder, the production and dedication of the engraving show how highly regarded the composition was in the time of Pieter the Younger, Jan the Elder and Rubens. It probably inspired Rubens, as a drawing of circa 1620-25 attributed to that artist, in black chalk and wash, repeats several of the figures involved in the tussle (Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen; inv. no. V 8 (PK)), replacing several of the faces with more typically ‘Rubensian’ types – the figure wielding the flail at left, for example, is given a beard and a wild shock of hair, as well as muscled calves suitable for a Hercules. Interestingly, the Vorsterman engraving records just such a figure in this role. Vorsterman worked in Rubens’s studio as his ‘in-house’ engraver, and it is likely that he was given the task of reproducing Brueghel’s composition with Rubens’s approval. Perhaps Rubens himself commissioned the engraving from Vorsterman – the dedication to Jan Brueghel, who was one of Rubens’s close friends (Rubens painted the touching family portrait of Jan Brueghel with his wife and children now in the Courtauld Gallery, London), lends credence to this hypothesis.
A version exhibited in 1992 as a collaboration between Rubens and Jan Brueghel the Elder – a panel in a private collection (94 x 124 cm.), presented as an original by Jan retouched by Rubens – is not accepted as such by Ertz, who recognises neither Rubens’s hand in the figures nor Jan’s in the landscape (see the catalogue of the exhibition De Bruegel à Rubens: l’école de peinture anversoise, 1550-1650, Antwerp, 1992, pp. 170-71, no. 73, illustrated). Marlier follows Hulin de Loo and van Bastelaer in citing another, smaller (36.5 x 46 cm.) putative copy from Rubens’s hand (see Marlier, op. cit., p. 267 and notes). Rubens was a great admirer of Pieter the Elder and owned no fewer than twelve paintings by him, as recorded in the inventory of his estate (1640). The same inventory lists, under no. 142 and among Rubens’s own works, a painting of ‘Des paysans qui se battent, fait d’après un dessin du Vieux Bruegel’ – evidence that Rubens himself painted the composition after a lost drawing by Pieter the Elder. It cannot be excluded, however, that Rubens may have owned the prototype by the Elder. Alternatively, it may have remained in family hands, in the possession of Jan Brueghel the Elder – further justification for the dedication of Vorsterman’s engraving of one of Rubens’s favourite Bruegels, which he might have seen in the collection of his friend Jan. Marlier suggests (op. cit., p. 266) that a work belonging to Jan Brueghel the Elder may be the one which the great British patron and collector Thomas Howard, 2nd Earl of Arundel, ordered his Antwerp agent Lionel Wake to purchase around 1625, ‘a painting begun by Bruegel and finished by Mostaert, showing a peasant brawl over a game of cards, which has been engraved by Vorsterman’. Gillis Mostaert (1534-1598) was a contemporary of Pieter the Elder who outlived him, and who could well have been asked to complete a painting left unfinished. The specificity of the attribution in Arundel’s instructions is striking; the picture reappears in the inventory drawn up in Amsterdam around 1655 after the death of Lady Arundel, as ‘Bruegel. Contadini che si batteno’, which may well be the last trace of the prototype. The present work was for many years given to Pieter the Elder – for example, when in the Lanz collection – an attribution which, given its quality and early date, is not surprising.
The collection of the industrialist Baron Evence III Coppée (1882-1945) was formed in Brussels between 1920 and 1939. The focus was on sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century Flemish painting, with a special emphasis on the work of Pieter the Younger, whom Coppée much admired for his treatment of humanist themes. In all, he owned nine works by the artist, a group that set the example for many later collectors of Brueghel in Belgium. Much of the collection, including the present lot, was proudly displayed in the stately Coppée mansion, built in 1928 on the Avenue des Nations (now Avenue Franklin D. Roosevelt), Brussels (fig. 2).
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
