Lot Essay
These magnificent panels are the only known large-scale fruit and flower pendants by the peerless still-life painter Jan van Huysum that remain together in private hands. Painted with dazzling skill at the height of the artist’s career in the early 1730s, they have remarkably remained together since their creation. Their exceptional quality is matched by a distinguished provenance spanning three of the foremost European art collecting dynasties in history: the Landgraves of Hesse-Kassel, the Barings and the Rothschilds. They have remained in the present family’s hands for the last eighty years.
As the genre of still life emerged in its own right, so too did collectors’ taste for pendant fruit and flower pieces, uniting two complementary expressions of nature’s bounty: the ephemeral splendour of flowers with the rich abundance of fruit. This tradition reached its zenith in such sumptuous pendants by van Huysum, whose meticulous technique, brilliant colouring and sophisticated compositions elevated the genre to new heights. Executed between 1731 and 1733, when the artist produced a number of his greatest paintings, these pictures exemplify the refinement and ambition of his mature style. The artist included an astonishing variety of forms, colours and textures: in A Vase of Flowers, a splendid bouquet rises above an elegant terracotta vase, bringing together roses, hyacinths, gentians, peonies, blossom and other flowers in an arrangement that transcends the blooms of a single season; in Fruit with Flowers, peaches, grapes, figs, plums, redcurrants and a pomegranate spill across a marble ledge, before hollyhocks and a terracotta vase of poppies. It was only around 1731 that van Huysum began to include a pineapple and figs in his work, reflecting the increasing range and ambition of his still lifes, as well as the remarkable variety of textures to which he turned his brush. Many of the fruits and flowers depicted originated far beyond the Dutch Republic, reflecting the global trade networks that supplied previously unfamiliar botanical specimens. Indeed, pineapples were very expensive luxury goods during this period given the difficulty of cultivating them in Northern Europe, and became a symbol of wealth and status.
Van Huysum’s mastery of light animates these pictures, which are both illuminated by an unseen source from the left. In A Vase of Flowers, bright light is thrown onto the pink and white roses, white peony and pink hyacinths, exquisitely expressed with several layers of meticulously painted highlights that create a sculptural effect. The artist’s skill of conveying the transmission of light through a bouquet is on full display, passing through to shed light on several of the delicate petals of the French rose behind, whilst others are thrown into shade, conveyed using grey shadows. In Fruit with Flowers, the varied forms of the pink and white hollyhocks come to life with the same meticulous attention to light and shade. The artist describes the exact fall of light on the green and blue skin of the grapes, rendering the fruit translucent and revealing the veins and seeds beneath. This virtuoso illusionism is enhanced by the inclusion of insects and water droplets that balance precariously on the petals and leaves.
In A Vase of Flowers, the bird’s nest, characteristic of Jan van Huysum’s most celebrated paintings, contains three cuckoo’s eggs cushioned in a mass of iridescent moss, held together with a bundle of twigs. The nest teeters on the edge of the marble parapet, presumably an extension of the broader reflection on the fragility of life so often found in still lifes of this date. Other flowers and fruit are included at several different stages of their life cycle, such as the buds and open flowers of the apple blossom; five raspberries hanging over the marble ledge, all at different stages of ripening; and a fig, melon and pomegranate, cut open to reveal the brief moment when the bursting flesh and seeds are at their most ripe. The brief flowering and inevitable decay of fruit and flowers is frequently read as a reflection on the transience of earthly life. Yet in these pendants, van Huysum appears equally intent on celebrating nature’s bounty in all its richness, variety and scale. This spirit is underlined by the animated reliefs that decorate the terracotta vases. In A Vase of Flowers, a putto suspends himself playfully from a garland of flowers, whilst in Fruit with Flowers, three dancing nymphs, perhaps an allusion to the Three Graces, evoke harmony and abundance. Such richness and variety provided the artist with an opportunity to display the range of his technical brilliance, from the smooth surfaces of plump grapes, to the velvety, soft skin of the peaches, and the challenging textures of seeds and pulp.
By the early 1730s, van Huysum had moved away from the dark settings of his earlier works in favour of light backgrounds, often with trees or a park setting. The inclusion of a row of Italianate cypress trees, as in Fruit with Flowers, is rare in his work. The scale and vertical emphasis of the trees is underlined by their continuation beyond the painted surface. A golden light passes through some of them, and illuminates the yellow tones of the leaves on the trees at right, creating the atmosphere of a suffused, warm evening sky. In A Vase of Flowers, a tree trunk, classical columns and a sculpture of Flora create an elegant garden setting. Light bursts through openings in the branches, casting shadows on the hard surfaces of the columns and illuminating the statue of Flora below. The same statue appears in reverse in an earlier painting by van Huysum dated 1723 (fig. 1; Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum), suggesting that it was based on engravings, presumably after well-known antique sculpture like the Farnese Flora. Indeed, several books of engravings were included in van Huysum’s posthumous sale, but as Segal has pointed out the reliefs on the terracotta vases and the sculpture rarely correspond directly to anything found in these sources (op. cit., p. 58).
The dates inscribed by the artist reveal a key feature of his famously secretive working method. Both paintings are dated twice: A Vase of Flowers is dated 1731 and 1732, while Fruit with Flowers is dated 1732 and 1733. This is not uncommon in van Huysum’s work, and underlines his preference for painting specimens from life, even waiting months for the right flower to bloom so that he could paint it from nature. In a well-known 1742 letter to A.N. van Haften, agent of the Duke of Mecklenburg-Schwerin, the artist explains why one of his paintings was not yet finished, lamenting that the year before ‘I could not get my hands on a yellow rose; otherwise it would be done by now’ (quoted in Segal, op. cit., p. 62, note 43). In order to capture varieties from life, these pictures were probably begun in the summer months, when the right flowers were in bloom. Van Huysum likely continued work during the winter months before completing them in the spring or summer of the following year. This laborious, time-consuming process allowed the artist to observe each flower and fruit at its peak. In the case of pendants such as these, Segal logically suggests the artist spent more time on the flower pieces during the spring and summer months and the fruit pieces later in the year. Indeed, the paintings themselves tell the story of the changing seasons. In A Vase of Flowers, almonds, a pear and apple blossom – all of which ripen or bloom in early spring – appear alongside nasturtiums, white meadow Cranesbill and poppies, which come into bloom between late spring and the end of summer. The resulting compositions are therefore not exact records of a particular time, but carefully orchestrated inventions in which varieties from different seasons are observed from life and brought together in a harmonious composition.
Despite the profusion of fruit and flowers, van Huysum employs characteristic rigour in design and masterful colouring to bring order and harmony to his complex compositions. In A Vase of Flowers, the painting is structured by a diagonal of delicate white and pink tones, running from the orange blossom in the lower left corner, linked by the stems of the snake’s head fritillary to the roses and peony in the centre, in turn connected to the head of the tulip by its arched stem that weaves behind the roses and hyacinths, finishing in the plump buds of the apple blossom. Stronger red, blue, yellow and green tones frame this central axis. As is often the case in van Huysum’s fruit and flower pendants, the diagonal forces move in opposite directions. In Fruit with Flowers, the composition is structured by the grape vine, around which lighter tones twist, again framed by the darker green tones of the vine and pineapple leaves. The rhythm of both paintings is complementary, culminating in a prominent red flower at the upper centre of each composition, a majestic crown imperial in the Flowers and an opium poppy in the Fruit with Flowers.
A study in the Louvre (fig. 2), related to A Vase of Flowers, shows how the artist established the principal structure of the composition, built up loosely using oiled charcoal and touches of watercolour to indicate areas of colour. A second drawing in the Morgan Library, New York, was also associated with A Vase of Flowers, but is now thought to date from the 1720s and to have functioned as a model for several other paintings (Segal, op. cit., p. 244, no. F31). A signed but undated drawing in the Louvre is probably a study for Fruit with Flowers (fig. 3). The arrangement of the fruit, flowers, vase and cypresses in the landscape is largely the same, but the relief on the terracotta vase includes putti rather than the nymphs seen in the finished painting. The lively spontaneity of this drawing is key to understanding how van Huysum worked out the balance, light and colouring of the composition. Despite their high level of finish and minute attention to detail, the paintings bear subtle traces of van Huysum’s continuous artistic invention and refinement. Small pentiments and visible reserves reveal that he continued to refine his paintings as he worked.
A DISTINGUISHED PROVENANCE
Whilst many of van Huysum’s fruit and flower paintings were not necessarily conceived as pendants, and were only paired up by later collectors, these remarkable works appear to have always remained together in a succession of exceptional collections.
The pictures are first firmly recorded in a 1783 inventory of the celebrated Hesse-Kassel collection during the reign of Landgrave Frederick II. Although Frederick is known to have been interested in the arts and was responsible for the public opening of the collection, he is believed to have made few acquisitions (see Herzog, op. cit., p. 40). It remains possible that the pictures were acquired by his predecessor and father, Landgrave Wilhelm VIII, who formed one of the finest picture collections in pre-revolutionary Europe. The Landgrave spent his youth in the Netherlands, which ignited a lifelong passion for Dutch and Flemish painting and initiated the start of a collection that would come to include such prized works as Rembrandt’s Christ and St Mary Magdalen at the Tomb (London, Royal Collection), Rubens’s Pan and Syrinx and Titian’s Portrait of a Man in Armour (fig. 4; both Kassel, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister). Wilhelm is also known to have been a key patron of van Huysum. Johan van Gool recounts the first time the Landgrave encountered van Huysum’s work, noting that the Prince ‘stont als opgetogen toen ik hem dit Tafereel vertoonde’ [‘stood there, as if enraptured, when I showed him’] (J. van Gool, De nieuwe Schouburg der Nederlantsche kunstschilders en schilderessen, The Hague, 1751, II, p. 16).
The pre-Kassel history of the pictures remains the subject of debate, on account both of the generic descriptions in eighteenth-century inventories and sale catalogues as well as the artist’s penchant for using standard-sized panels. They have traditionally been identified with the ones acquired from the Counts Zinzendorf und Pottendorf of Vienna in 1762 by the renowned Swiss artist and collector Jean-Étienne Liotard (1702-1789). Liotard certainly owned a pair of fruit and flower pictures by van Huysum, which he was said to have held in especially high esteem. However, their cost probably proved beyond his means and he sought a buyer almost as soon as he acquired them. By June 1763, he had offered them to his patron, William Ponsonby, 2nd Earl of Bessborough (1704-1793), and they were later unsold in exhibitions in Paris (1771) and London (1773) and at his Christie’s auction of 1774. Liotard still owned a pair of fruit and flower paintings by van Huysum in 1785, when he offered them to the Comte d'Angiviller for the French royal collection, and in 1788, when the artist’s son brought them from Amsterdam to Paris for sale.
If Liotard only ever owned one pair of paintings by van Huysum, it is unlikely that they were the present pictures, which are securely documented in Kassel by 1783. Acknowledging the difficulties of reconstructing this early provenance, Segal suggested that Liotard may have owned more than one pair of fruit and flower pictures, a plausible possibility given his activities as both an artist and a dealer (op. cit., p. 240). However, Marcel Roethlisberger and Renée Loche maintain that Liotard only ever owned two paintings by van Huysum and that they remain untraced (op. cit., p. 140). A further complication is Liotard’s 1785 claim that his pictures had been offered to Charles VI in Vienna in 1724, a decade before the present paintings were completed. Segal notes that this story may have been fabricated by Liotard as part of an elaborate sales pitch, or that the dating may have been an error, with ‘1724’ intended to be ‘1734’, a year after Fruit with Flowers was completed (op. cit., p. 237). However, a posthumous sale of the collection of Claude Tolozan held in February 1801 describes fruit and flower pieces by van Huysum that are identified as the ‘famous paintings owned by Liotard’. The description of the bird’s nest in Tolozan’s flower piece also notes that it contained five eggs, rather than the three that appear in the present Flowers. There is, therefore, ample evidence to doubt Segal’s assertion that these are the pair once owned by Liotard.
At Kassel, the pictures passed by descent from Frederick II to his eldest son, Wilhelm IX, and remained in the collection until they were seized by French forces in 1806. In October of that year, in the midst of the Napoleonic wars, French troops, victorious at nearby Jena, entered Kassel, and on 1 November 1806 General Joseph Lagrange was appointed governor by imperial decree. Anticipating the advance of the French army, Wilhelm had selected forty-eight masterpieces, including the present pair, to be packed up with silver and other treasures and concealed from the French at residences including Sababurg hunting lodge, Löwenburg Castle and Wilhelmshöhe Palace. General Lagrange and his troops soon discovered the hidden pictures and transported the crates to Mainz, gifting them to Empress Joséphine Bonaparte, who was residing there temporarily. The Empress took the pictures to the Château de Malmaison, a seventeenth-century manor house located around 20 kilometres west of Paris, which Napoleon had acquired in 1799 as a private retreat. The present paintings were two of four by van Huysum on the list sent to Mainz by Lagrange, which also included a flower piece now in the Wallace Collection, London. However, none of them are listed in either the 1811 or 1814 inventories of Malmaison. As Alain Pougetoux notes, given the Empress’s great passion for flowers and botany, and the absence of other paintings by the artist at Malmaison, it is surprising that these pictures were not hung there (op. cit., p. 24). Presumably they were selected as gifts, or sold in untraced sales before 1811.
By the time John Smith published his famous Catalogue of van Huysum’s work in 1835 (op. cit.), the paintings were recorded in yet another distinguished collection, that formed at Bath House by the banker, politician and connoisseur, Alexander Baring, later 1st Baron Ashburton. Bath House, on Piccadilly, was renovated in 1821 by Henry Harrison and housed such notable works as Andrea Mantegna’s Adoration of the Magi (Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum), and Jan Steen’s The Skittle Players (London, National Gallery). It was visited by connoisseurs including Gustav Waagen, who remarked that Fruit was ‘in the high finish of every object, and the sunny brightness of the light, one of the most beautiful pictures of the master’ (op. cit., 1838, p. 286). Although it remains uncertain as to how and when Ashburton acquired the van Huysums, he is known to have had several close links to France, where the paintings had last appeared on the market. He was one of the bankers appointed to seek reparations from the French following the Napoleonic Wars. Moreover, several pictures in his collection were acquired from his friend, Charles-Maurice de Talleyrand, prince de Bénévent (1754-1838), who had in turn bought many pictures on the French art market that were originally at Kassel.
The van Huysums passed through several generations of the Baring family, before the collection was acquired en bloc in 1907 by Thomas Agnew & Co. and a consortium of other dealers. These pictures were bought by Alfred de Rothschild (fig. 5), scion of another eponymous banking family. Although they appear in the Agnew’s stock book of 1907, noting Alfred as the buyer, no price is listed, and a bill in the Rothschild Archive suggests that the purchase was made directly from Lord Ashburton (Rothschild Archive, London, 000/174B/30).
Alfred was a formidable connoisseur and collector. The second of Lionel de Rothschild’s three sons, Alfred joined the family bank soon after university and remained a partner there throughout his life, alongside his brothers. The scale of the family’s financial success was reflected in an expanding array of houses in both London and the country. The estate and original house at Halton had been acquired by Alfred's father Lionel from the Dashwood family in 1853. Between 1880 and 1883, Alfred transformed the property. He demolished the existing house and built a palatial new home in the French style, which he filled with his expanding collection of English and French art of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, Dutch cabinet pictures and British portraits, including Thomas Gainsborough’s portrait of Mrs William Villebois, which remains the world auction record for the artist following its sale in these Rooms in 2011. Whilst much of Alfred’s estate was inherited by his daughter, Almina Wombwell, Countess of Carnarvon (1876-1969), he bequeathed Halton House to his nephew, Lionel Nathan de Rothschild (1882-1942), who later sold the property and moved much of the contents to his own home, Exbury House. Lionel Nathan’s passion for botany is well-known from the renowned rhododendron and azalea gardens at the world-famous horticultural estate at Exbury, where the paintings found an especially fitting new home. Pendant Fruit and Flower pieces by van Huysum, dated 1722, also hung at Halton (Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum, inv. nos. 82.PB.71 and 82.PB.70). Following Lionel Nathan’s death in 1942, the paintings passed to his son, Edmund Leopold (1916-2009), who sold several pictures to account for heavy death duties. According to Lionel’s probate valuation of April 1942 (Rothschild Archive, London, 0⁄920), the present paintings were sold to Partridge for £1,250 each, from whom Sir Edward Mountain, the founder of Eagle Star Insurance, purchased them in 1946. These superb pictures have passed by descent in the family ever since, and this marks the first time they have appeared at auction in over 200 years.
As the genre of still life emerged in its own right, so too did collectors’ taste for pendant fruit and flower pieces, uniting two complementary expressions of nature’s bounty: the ephemeral splendour of flowers with the rich abundance of fruit. This tradition reached its zenith in such sumptuous pendants by van Huysum, whose meticulous technique, brilliant colouring and sophisticated compositions elevated the genre to new heights. Executed between 1731 and 1733, when the artist produced a number of his greatest paintings, these pictures exemplify the refinement and ambition of his mature style. The artist included an astonishing variety of forms, colours and textures: in A Vase of Flowers, a splendid bouquet rises above an elegant terracotta vase, bringing together roses, hyacinths, gentians, peonies, blossom and other flowers in an arrangement that transcends the blooms of a single season; in Fruit with Flowers, peaches, grapes, figs, plums, redcurrants and a pomegranate spill across a marble ledge, before hollyhocks and a terracotta vase of poppies. It was only around 1731 that van Huysum began to include a pineapple and figs in his work, reflecting the increasing range and ambition of his still lifes, as well as the remarkable variety of textures to which he turned his brush. Many of the fruits and flowers depicted originated far beyond the Dutch Republic, reflecting the global trade networks that supplied previously unfamiliar botanical specimens. Indeed, pineapples were very expensive luxury goods during this period given the difficulty of cultivating them in Northern Europe, and became a symbol of wealth and status.
Van Huysum’s mastery of light animates these pictures, which are both illuminated by an unseen source from the left. In A Vase of Flowers, bright light is thrown onto the pink and white roses, white peony and pink hyacinths, exquisitely expressed with several layers of meticulously painted highlights that create a sculptural effect. The artist’s skill of conveying the transmission of light through a bouquet is on full display, passing through to shed light on several of the delicate petals of the French rose behind, whilst others are thrown into shade, conveyed using grey shadows. In Fruit with Flowers, the varied forms of the pink and white hollyhocks come to life with the same meticulous attention to light and shade. The artist describes the exact fall of light on the green and blue skin of the grapes, rendering the fruit translucent and revealing the veins and seeds beneath. This virtuoso illusionism is enhanced by the inclusion of insects and water droplets that balance precariously on the petals and leaves.
In A Vase of Flowers, the bird’s nest, characteristic of Jan van Huysum’s most celebrated paintings, contains three cuckoo’s eggs cushioned in a mass of iridescent moss, held together with a bundle of twigs. The nest teeters on the edge of the marble parapet, presumably an extension of the broader reflection on the fragility of life so often found in still lifes of this date. Other flowers and fruit are included at several different stages of their life cycle, such as the buds and open flowers of the apple blossom; five raspberries hanging over the marble ledge, all at different stages of ripening; and a fig, melon and pomegranate, cut open to reveal the brief moment when the bursting flesh and seeds are at their most ripe. The brief flowering and inevitable decay of fruit and flowers is frequently read as a reflection on the transience of earthly life. Yet in these pendants, van Huysum appears equally intent on celebrating nature’s bounty in all its richness, variety and scale. This spirit is underlined by the animated reliefs that decorate the terracotta vases. In A Vase of Flowers, a putto suspends himself playfully from a garland of flowers, whilst in Fruit with Flowers, three dancing nymphs, perhaps an allusion to the Three Graces, evoke harmony and abundance. Such richness and variety provided the artist with an opportunity to display the range of his technical brilliance, from the smooth surfaces of plump grapes, to the velvety, soft skin of the peaches, and the challenging textures of seeds and pulp.
By the early 1730s, van Huysum had moved away from the dark settings of his earlier works in favour of light backgrounds, often with trees or a park setting. The inclusion of a row of Italianate cypress trees, as in Fruit with Flowers, is rare in his work. The scale and vertical emphasis of the trees is underlined by their continuation beyond the painted surface. A golden light passes through some of them, and illuminates the yellow tones of the leaves on the trees at right, creating the atmosphere of a suffused, warm evening sky. In A Vase of Flowers, a tree trunk, classical columns and a sculpture of Flora create an elegant garden setting. Light bursts through openings in the branches, casting shadows on the hard surfaces of the columns and illuminating the statue of Flora below. The same statue appears in reverse in an earlier painting by van Huysum dated 1723 (fig. 1; Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum), suggesting that it was based on engravings, presumably after well-known antique sculpture like the Farnese Flora. Indeed, several books of engravings were included in van Huysum’s posthumous sale, but as Segal has pointed out the reliefs on the terracotta vases and the sculpture rarely correspond directly to anything found in these sources (op. cit., p. 58).
The dates inscribed by the artist reveal a key feature of his famously secretive working method. Both paintings are dated twice: A Vase of Flowers is dated 1731 and 1732, while Fruit with Flowers is dated 1732 and 1733. This is not uncommon in van Huysum’s work, and underlines his preference for painting specimens from life, even waiting months for the right flower to bloom so that he could paint it from nature. In a well-known 1742 letter to A.N. van Haften, agent of the Duke of Mecklenburg-Schwerin, the artist explains why one of his paintings was not yet finished, lamenting that the year before ‘I could not get my hands on a yellow rose; otherwise it would be done by now’ (quoted in Segal, op. cit., p. 62, note 43). In order to capture varieties from life, these pictures were probably begun in the summer months, when the right flowers were in bloom. Van Huysum likely continued work during the winter months before completing them in the spring or summer of the following year. This laborious, time-consuming process allowed the artist to observe each flower and fruit at its peak. In the case of pendants such as these, Segal logically suggests the artist spent more time on the flower pieces during the spring and summer months and the fruit pieces later in the year. Indeed, the paintings themselves tell the story of the changing seasons. In A Vase of Flowers, almonds, a pear and apple blossom – all of which ripen or bloom in early spring – appear alongside nasturtiums, white meadow Cranesbill and poppies, which come into bloom between late spring and the end of summer. The resulting compositions are therefore not exact records of a particular time, but carefully orchestrated inventions in which varieties from different seasons are observed from life and brought together in a harmonious composition.
Despite the profusion of fruit and flowers, van Huysum employs characteristic rigour in design and masterful colouring to bring order and harmony to his complex compositions. In A Vase of Flowers, the painting is structured by a diagonal of delicate white and pink tones, running from the orange blossom in the lower left corner, linked by the stems of the snake’s head fritillary to the roses and peony in the centre, in turn connected to the head of the tulip by its arched stem that weaves behind the roses and hyacinths, finishing in the plump buds of the apple blossom. Stronger red, blue, yellow and green tones frame this central axis. As is often the case in van Huysum’s fruit and flower pendants, the diagonal forces move in opposite directions. In Fruit with Flowers, the composition is structured by the grape vine, around which lighter tones twist, again framed by the darker green tones of the vine and pineapple leaves. The rhythm of both paintings is complementary, culminating in a prominent red flower at the upper centre of each composition, a majestic crown imperial in the Flowers and an opium poppy in the Fruit with Flowers.
A study in the Louvre (fig. 2), related to A Vase of Flowers, shows how the artist established the principal structure of the composition, built up loosely using oiled charcoal and touches of watercolour to indicate areas of colour. A second drawing in the Morgan Library, New York, was also associated with A Vase of Flowers, but is now thought to date from the 1720s and to have functioned as a model for several other paintings (Segal, op. cit., p. 244, no. F31). A signed but undated drawing in the Louvre is probably a study for Fruit with Flowers (fig. 3). The arrangement of the fruit, flowers, vase and cypresses in the landscape is largely the same, but the relief on the terracotta vase includes putti rather than the nymphs seen in the finished painting. The lively spontaneity of this drawing is key to understanding how van Huysum worked out the balance, light and colouring of the composition. Despite their high level of finish and minute attention to detail, the paintings bear subtle traces of van Huysum’s continuous artistic invention and refinement. Small pentiments and visible reserves reveal that he continued to refine his paintings as he worked.
A DISTINGUISHED PROVENANCE
Whilst many of van Huysum’s fruit and flower paintings were not necessarily conceived as pendants, and were only paired up by later collectors, these remarkable works appear to have always remained together in a succession of exceptional collections.
The pictures are first firmly recorded in a 1783 inventory of the celebrated Hesse-Kassel collection during the reign of Landgrave Frederick II. Although Frederick is known to have been interested in the arts and was responsible for the public opening of the collection, he is believed to have made few acquisitions (see Herzog, op. cit., p. 40). It remains possible that the pictures were acquired by his predecessor and father, Landgrave Wilhelm VIII, who formed one of the finest picture collections in pre-revolutionary Europe. The Landgrave spent his youth in the Netherlands, which ignited a lifelong passion for Dutch and Flemish painting and initiated the start of a collection that would come to include such prized works as Rembrandt’s Christ and St Mary Magdalen at the Tomb (London, Royal Collection), Rubens’s Pan and Syrinx and Titian’s Portrait of a Man in Armour (fig. 4; both Kassel, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister). Wilhelm is also known to have been a key patron of van Huysum. Johan van Gool recounts the first time the Landgrave encountered van Huysum’s work, noting that the Prince ‘stont als opgetogen toen ik hem dit Tafereel vertoonde’ [‘stood there, as if enraptured, when I showed him’] (J. van Gool, De nieuwe Schouburg der Nederlantsche kunstschilders en schilderessen, The Hague, 1751, II, p. 16).
The pre-Kassel history of the pictures remains the subject of debate, on account both of the generic descriptions in eighteenth-century inventories and sale catalogues as well as the artist’s penchant for using standard-sized panels. They have traditionally been identified with the ones acquired from the Counts Zinzendorf und Pottendorf of Vienna in 1762 by the renowned Swiss artist and collector Jean-Étienne Liotard (1702-1789). Liotard certainly owned a pair of fruit and flower pictures by van Huysum, which he was said to have held in especially high esteem. However, their cost probably proved beyond his means and he sought a buyer almost as soon as he acquired them. By June 1763, he had offered them to his patron, William Ponsonby, 2nd Earl of Bessborough (1704-1793), and they were later unsold in exhibitions in Paris (1771) and London (1773) and at his Christie’s auction of 1774. Liotard still owned a pair of fruit and flower paintings by van Huysum in 1785, when he offered them to the Comte d'Angiviller for the French royal collection, and in 1788, when the artist’s son brought them from Amsterdam to Paris for sale.
If Liotard only ever owned one pair of paintings by van Huysum, it is unlikely that they were the present pictures, which are securely documented in Kassel by 1783. Acknowledging the difficulties of reconstructing this early provenance, Segal suggested that Liotard may have owned more than one pair of fruit and flower pictures, a plausible possibility given his activities as both an artist and a dealer (op. cit., p. 240). However, Marcel Roethlisberger and Renée Loche maintain that Liotard only ever owned two paintings by van Huysum and that they remain untraced (op. cit., p. 140). A further complication is Liotard’s 1785 claim that his pictures had been offered to Charles VI in Vienna in 1724, a decade before the present paintings were completed. Segal notes that this story may have been fabricated by Liotard as part of an elaborate sales pitch, or that the dating may have been an error, with ‘1724’ intended to be ‘1734’, a year after Fruit with Flowers was completed (op. cit., p. 237). However, a posthumous sale of the collection of Claude Tolozan held in February 1801 describes fruit and flower pieces by van Huysum that are identified as the ‘famous paintings owned by Liotard’. The description of the bird’s nest in Tolozan’s flower piece also notes that it contained five eggs, rather than the three that appear in the present Flowers. There is, therefore, ample evidence to doubt Segal’s assertion that these are the pair once owned by Liotard.
At Kassel, the pictures passed by descent from Frederick II to his eldest son, Wilhelm IX, and remained in the collection until they were seized by French forces in 1806. In October of that year, in the midst of the Napoleonic wars, French troops, victorious at nearby Jena, entered Kassel, and on 1 November 1806 General Joseph Lagrange was appointed governor by imperial decree. Anticipating the advance of the French army, Wilhelm had selected forty-eight masterpieces, including the present pair, to be packed up with silver and other treasures and concealed from the French at residences including Sababurg hunting lodge, Löwenburg Castle and Wilhelmshöhe Palace. General Lagrange and his troops soon discovered the hidden pictures and transported the crates to Mainz, gifting them to Empress Joséphine Bonaparte, who was residing there temporarily. The Empress took the pictures to the Château de Malmaison, a seventeenth-century manor house located around 20 kilometres west of Paris, which Napoleon had acquired in 1799 as a private retreat. The present paintings were two of four by van Huysum on the list sent to Mainz by Lagrange, which also included a flower piece now in the Wallace Collection, London. However, none of them are listed in either the 1811 or 1814 inventories of Malmaison. As Alain Pougetoux notes, given the Empress’s great passion for flowers and botany, and the absence of other paintings by the artist at Malmaison, it is surprising that these pictures were not hung there (op. cit., p. 24). Presumably they were selected as gifts, or sold in untraced sales before 1811.
By the time John Smith published his famous Catalogue of van Huysum’s work in 1835 (op. cit.), the paintings were recorded in yet another distinguished collection, that formed at Bath House by the banker, politician and connoisseur, Alexander Baring, later 1st Baron Ashburton. Bath House, on Piccadilly, was renovated in 1821 by Henry Harrison and housed such notable works as Andrea Mantegna’s Adoration of the Magi (Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum), and Jan Steen’s The Skittle Players (London, National Gallery). It was visited by connoisseurs including Gustav Waagen, who remarked that Fruit was ‘in the high finish of every object, and the sunny brightness of the light, one of the most beautiful pictures of the master’ (op. cit., 1838, p. 286). Although it remains uncertain as to how and when Ashburton acquired the van Huysums, he is known to have had several close links to France, where the paintings had last appeared on the market. He was one of the bankers appointed to seek reparations from the French following the Napoleonic Wars. Moreover, several pictures in his collection were acquired from his friend, Charles-Maurice de Talleyrand, prince de Bénévent (1754-1838), who had in turn bought many pictures on the French art market that were originally at Kassel.
The van Huysums passed through several generations of the Baring family, before the collection was acquired en bloc in 1907 by Thomas Agnew & Co. and a consortium of other dealers. These pictures were bought by Alfred de Rothschild (fig. 5), scion of another eponymous banking family. Although they appear in the Agnew’s stock book of 1907, noting Alfred as the buyer, no price is listed, and a bill in the Rothschild Archive suggests that the purchase was made directly from Lord Ashburton (Rothschild Archive, London, 000/174B/30).
Alfred was a formidable connoisseur and collector. The second of Lionel de Rothschild’s three sons, Alfred joined the family bank soon after university and remained a partner there throughout his life, alongside his brothers. The scale of the family’s financial success was reflected in an expanding array of houses in both London and the country. The estate and original house at Halton had been acquired by Alfred's father Lionel from the Dashwood family in 1853. Between 1880 and 1883, Alfred transformed the property. He demolished the existing house and built a palatial new home in the French style, which he filled with his expanding collection of English and French art of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, Dutch cabinet pictures and British portraits, including Thomas Gainsborough’s portrait of Mrs William Villebois, which remains the world auction record for the artist following its sale in these Rooms in 2011. Whilst much of Alfred’s estate was inherited by his daughter, Almina Wombwell, Countess of Carnarvon (1876-1969), he bequeathed Halton House to his nephew, Lionel Nathan de Rothschild (1882-1942), who later sold the property and moved much of the contents to his own home, Exbury House. Lionel Nathan’s passion for botany is well-known from the renowned rhododendron and azalea gardens at the world-famous horticultural estate at Exbury, where the paintings found an especially fitting new home. Pendant Fruit and Flower pieces by van Huysum, dated 1722, also hung at Halton (Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum, inv. nos. 82.PB.71 and 82.PB.70). Following Lionel Nathan’s death in 1942, the paintings passed to his son, Edmund Leopold (1916-2009), who sold several pictures to account for heavy death duties. According to Lionel’s probate valuation of April 1942 (Rothschild Archive, London, 0⁄920), the present paintings were sold to Partridge for £1,250 each, from whom Sir Edward Mountain, the founder of Eagle Star Insurance, purchased them in 1946. These superb pictures have passed by descent in the family ever since, and this marks the first time they have appeared at auction in over 200 years.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
