ARTHUR WILLIAM DEVIS (LONDON 1762-1822)
ARTHUR WILLIAM DEVIS (LONDON 1762-1822)
ARTHUR WILLIAM DEVIS (LONDON 1762-1822)
ARTHUR WILLIAM DEVIS (LONDON 1762-1822)
3 More
PROPERTY FROM A DISTINGUISHED PRIVATE COLLECTION
GHERARDO STARNINA (FLORENCE C.1360-BEFORE 1413)

Saint Maximin giving communion to Mary Magdalene

Details
GHERARDO STARNINA (FLORENCE C.1360-BEFORE 1413)
Saint Maximin giving communion to Mary Magdalene
oil and tempera on gold ground panel
16 3⁄8 x 25 5⁄8 in. (41.5 x 65.2 cm.)
Provenance
(Probably) commissioned for the Cappella di San Filippo in the Basilica di San Frediano, Lucca.
with Frederick Mont (1894-1994), New York (according to Fondazione Federico Zeri Photo Archive).
Anonymous sale [Appartenant au Comte de P.]; Palais Galliera, Paris, 15 March 1973, as 'école siennoise, fin du XIVe siècle'.
Private collection, Paris.
Literature
C. Volpe, 'Per il completamento dell'altare di San Lorenzo del Maestro del Bambino Vispo', Mitteilungen des Kunsthistorischen Institutes in Florenz, XVII, nos. 2⁄3, 1973, pp. 179, note 10, and p.182, fig. 6.
C. Lloyd, 'Gherardo di Jacopo called Starnina', Italian Paintings before 1600 in the Art Institute of Chicago: A Catalogue of the Collection, Chicago, 1993, pp. 229-30, note 13.
A. González-Palacios, 'Trattato di Lucca', in, Sumptuosa tabula picta. Pittori a Lucca tra gotico e Rinascimento, M. T. Filieri, ed., Livorno, 1998, pp. 24-5, and p. 268, under no. 30a.
D. Gordon, The Fifteenth Century: Italian Paintings, London, 2003, pp. 368 and 373-4, fig. 16.
L. Sbaraglio and A. Tartuferi, eds., Giovanni dal Ponte: Protagonista dell'Umanesimo tardogotico fiorentino, exhibition catalogue, Florence, 2016, pp. 71-5, pp. 168-9, pl. I, entry by Emanuele Zappasodi.
M. Palumbo, Il soggiorno di Gherardo Starnina in Spagna, PhD Thesis, Universidad de Barcelona, 2016, pp. 54, 89 and 394.
E. Zappasodi, 'Ristudiando Gherardo Starnina. Materiali e comparazioni per i polittici con i pilieri', Nuovi studi. Rivista di arte antica e moderna, XXIII, 2017, pp. 61, 68 and 77, note 5, figs. 68 and 94.

Brought to you by

Maja Markovic
Maja Markovic Director, Head of Evening Sale

Lot Essay

Originally part of the predella for an altarpiece, this panel is a rare testimony to Starnina's artistic vision and to the profound influence this artist exerted on fifteenth-century Florentine art. The painting last appeared on the market in 1973 in Paris and was shortly thereafter recognised as part of the same predella as The Beheading of Saint Margaret, in the National Gallery in London, and The Death of the Virgin, in the Art Institute of Chicago (figs. 1 and 2, respectively).

Starnina is first recorded in Florence in 1387, when his name appears in the register of the Guild of San Luca as "Gherardo di Jacopo Starna, dipintore" (R. Van Marle, The development of the Italian schools of painting, III, New York, 1970, p. 565). After receiving his training in Florence, Starnina moved to Spain, where he is documented in Valencia and Toledo during the last decade of the fourteenth century. By 1404, he had returned to Florence, where he completed the frescoes in the Chapel of Saint Jerome in Santa Maria del Carmine, a pivotal commission for reconstructing the artist’s oeuvre.

Painted after the artist’s return from Spain, the present work exemplifies the synthesis of Florentine training and Spanish experience characteristic of Starnina’s mature style. Here, the convincing spatial construction and volumetric modelling rooted in his Florentine origins are combined with a bold use of colour and a richness of detail that reflect his engagement with the International Gothic style encountered in Valencia and Toledo. The scene depicts Saint Mary Magdalene receiving the Last Communion from Saint Maximin. The episode, absent in the canonical Gospels, is recounted in the Golden Legend, a medieval compendium of saints’ lives written by Jacopo de Voragine. According to the text, Mary Magdalene spent the last thirty years of her life as a hermit in the desert, devoted to contemplation. Shortly before her death, she asked to be taken to Saint Maximin, from whom she received the Last Communion.

The figures are painted with a delicacy and expressiveness reminiscent of the frescoes in the Church of Santa Maria del Carmine. The artist deftly contrasts different textures, from the bold, shimmering folds of Saint Maximin’s tunic, gathered against the tension of his left arm, to the softer yet rhythmic pattern formed by the hair that envelops Mary Magdalene. The vivid colour palette, the wild creature, perhaps a bear, emerging from behind the cave, and the expressiveness of the figures all lend a distinctive character to a subject and composition that remains firmly rooted in the Tuscan tradition. Its design is carefully balanced between two distinct parts. To the left lies the wilderness, dominated by the cave in which Mary Magdalene was believed to have spent her final years. To the right, Saint Maximin, accompanied by a young deacon, stands before an architectural setting evocative of Quattrocento Florence.

A closely comparable arrangement appears in the corresponding panel of the now-dispersed predella depicting The Beheading of Saint Margaret in the National Gallery, London. Here too, the setting is divided between a rocky landscape, where the martyrdom takes place, and the walls of a city. In both panels, scenes from the saints’ lives are set against a gold-leaf sky, lending the compositions a striking luminosity. In the central panel, depicting the Death of the Virgin (Art Institute of Chicago), the landscape is omitted and the gold background, a characteristic feature of Starnina's oeuvre, extends across the entire composition.

Following its appearance on the art market in 1973 as a work of the late fourteenth-century Sienese school, the panel was published by Carlo Volpe as by the Maestro del Bambino Vispo ('Master of the Lively Child'), an anonymous Florentine painter first identified by Osvald Sirén in 1904 and named after the unusually animated and cheerful Christ Child that recurs in his paintings (O. Sirén, ‘Alcuni pittori fiorentini che subirono l'influsso di Lorenzo Monaco’, L'Arte, 1904, pp. 337-355). Volpe tentatively associated it with the other surviving panels of the predella, already known to him and, at the time, still forming part of the corpus attributed to the Maestro del Bambino Vispo.

The artistic ambivalence, or rather bilingualism, of this anonymous master's work long obscured his identity. While the iconography and compositions of the works pointed to a Tuscan origin, their audacious palette, lavish use of gold, and lively expressiveness recalled the International Gothic style flourishing elsewhere in Europe. These qualities led some scholars to propose a Spanish origin for the artist. It was only in 1974 that Jeanne van Waadenoijen convincingly identified the Maestro del Bambino Vispo with Gherardo Starnina (J. van Waadenoijen, ‘A proposal for Starnina: exit the Maestro del Bambino Vispo?’, The Burlington Magazine, CXVI, February 1974, pp. 82-91). As a result, a substantial body of works previously attributed to the anonymous master, including the present panel, was reunited under Starnina's name. The predella to which this panel belongs originally formed part of an ambitious altarpiece, whose principal tier is now in the Martin von Wagner Museum, Würzburg. The triptych depicts the Madonna and Child Enthroned with Music-Making Angels flanked by Saints Peter and Margaret and Saints Philip and Mary Magdalene. The Würzburg altarpiece is considered one of the most important surviving works for understanding Starnina’s style after his return from Spain. A reconstruction of this complex ensemble was proposed by Emanuele Zappasodi in 2016 (in Sbaraglio, op. cit.). In addition to the tripartite predella, the altarpiece likely included three pinnacles above the main register and further panels in the lateral pilasters. Such a configuration recalls the large multi-tiered Spanish retablos with which Starnina became familiar during his time in Spain.

The original destination of the altarpiece has long been debated, with scholars divided between Florence and Lucca. More recent documentary discoveries and scholarship, however, have strengthened the case for a Lucchese provenance. It has been suggested that the altarpiece was intended for the chapel of Saint Philip in the church of San Frediano, commissioned by the merchant Pietro di Filippo Gentili. Pietro died in 1400, four years before the chapel was completed, and a document dated 7 January 1404 records that responsibility for the project passed to his widow, Maddalena (L. Pisani, ‘Giovanni dal Ponte, Florence’, The Burlington Magazine, CLIX, February 2017, pp. 160-162). The Würzburg Triptych may therefore have been commissioned by Maddalena herself. The iconographic programme of the altarpiece lends further support to this interpretation: Saints Peter and Mary Magdalene may refer to the patrons’ names, Saint Philip to the dedication of the chapel, and Saint Margaret to the relics of the saint preserved in the church.

The present panel, together with the other two predella scenes, plays an important role in supporting a Lucchese origin for the altarpiece. The three panels were likely originally surmounted by trilobed blind arches supported on corbels, traces of which are visible in the X-radiographs of the London and Chicago panels (Gordon, 2003, op. cit.; Zappasodi, 2018, op. cit.). Such an arrangement is virtually unknown in contemporary Florentine painting, whereas it is documented in a number of fifteenth-century Lucchese predellas.

More from Old Masters Evening Sale

View All
View All