拍品專文
Gilbert Stuart’s portrait of Joseph Priestley stands as the most important likeness of one of the pioneers of modern chemistry. It is entirely apposite that Priestley, a free-thinking English clergyman and one of the great scientific luminaries of the age, should have been painted by Stuart, whose iconic depictions of George Washington stand as symbols of civic virtue and dignity. Commissioned in 1797, towards the end of Priestley’s life, Stuart’s portrait has an almost uncompromising humanity, capturing his sitter with remarkable sensitivity and a deftness of touch that defined his most accomplished work and secured his position as America’s greatest portraitist of the era. The reverse of the panel shows an oil sketch (fig. 1) that clearly relates to one of Stuart’s most celebrated full-length portraits of Washington. As such it constitutes an exceptionally rare preparatory study by the artist, a famously instinctive painter who disliked the conventional practice of making drawings or studies before starting work on a commission, preferring a direct approach from nature with the brush.
Of the various portraits painted of Priestley during his lifetime, this is arguably the finest. In a letter dated 6 January 1806 to Thomas Jefferson, then President of the United States, Priestley’s son Joseph wrote: ‘All the likenesses which I have seen of my father fall so far short, in my opinion, of that taken by Mr Stewart [sic]…’. He expressed his wish to reproduce Stuart’s portrait in his father’s memoirs and appealed to Jefferson to help secure a copy or permission to have an engraving made from the original, fearing that Stuart’s financial difficulties might have led him to sell the picture. Jefferson replied on 11 January that he would gladly have assisted, observing that Stuart’s ‘portraits are so fine that I should be sorry that the engraving should be from any other’, but explained that the artist was then in Boston and expressed his conviction that the original had not been sold (Joseph Priestley Jr. to Thomas Jefferson, 6 January 1806, and Jefferson to Priestley Jr., 11 January 1806, The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, Founders Online, National Archives).
The portrait was commissioned in 1797 by the American Philosophical Society, founded in 1743 by Benjamin Franklin in Philadelphia, for which Stuart was paid in advance the sum of 50 guineas. Despite the entreaties of the Society, Stuart failed to deliver the portrait, and the work evidently remained in his studio, supposedly unfinished. For reasons that remain unclear, but possibly due to the unrelenting strain of debts, Stuart is thought to have sold the portrait to Thomas Brocklehurst Barclay (1783-1866), a Liverpool merchant then visiting the United States, together with a copy of his portrait of Washington. On his return to England, Barclay commissioned the painter William Artaud, around 1812, to complete the background. It is possible that Barclay misunderstood Stuart’s technique of employing a lightly scumbled background, a practice he sometimes used to ensure the focus was drawn entirely to the sitter’s face, and, for purely aesthetic reasons, instructed Artaud to have this final passage of the portrait ‘finished’.
While the portrait remained in Artaud’s studio, the artist made three copies of Stuart’s original. A ‘Dissenter’ (later known as a Nonconformist) himself, Artaud may have known Priestley personally, as suggested by his highly engaging portrait of the scientist, executed in 1794 and formerly in the collection of Dr Williams’s Library at Gordon Square (Dr Williams’s Trust, on deposit at the University of Manchester). All three copies were likely intended for Priestley’s family; one is recorded in the collection of his descendant Marie Belloc Lowndes, the novelist and sister of Hilaire Belloc. It was from one of these copies, subsequently in the possession of Priestley’s descendants in Pennsylvania, that the American artist Albert Rosenthal (1863-1939) made his own copy, now in the Smithsonian National Museum of American History, Washington. On Barclay’s death in 1866 he bequeathed both the present portrait and that of Washington to William Rathbone V.
William Rathbone V (1787-1868) was an English merchant, politician, Mayor of Liverpool and a Unitarian. The Rathbone family were nonconformist shipowners and merchants of Liverpool, known for their philanthropy, public service and campaigns for social reform. They were also known for their patronage of the arts. William’s brother, Richard (1788-1860), became a key patron and sponsor of John James Audubon’s The Birds of America, published between 1827 and 1838, while his grandson, William Rathbone VII (1849-1919), was a close friend of the American painter John Singer Sargent.
Intriguingly, the reverse of the present panel (which has also been prepared with a ground layer) shows a rapidly brushed oil sketch of a figure beside a horse (fig. 1). Although there is a very slight difference in the arrangement of the subjects, the oil sketch corresponds almost precisely with Stuart’s portrait of George Washington at Dorchester Heights (1806; Boston, Museum of Fine Arts; fig. 2), the monumental full-length in which the sitter is shown holding the reins of his horse with Boston Harbour in the distance. This sketch, therefore, would appear to be an early exercise in Stuart’s preparation for the Dorchester Heights composition, executed on the reverse of Priestley’s undelivered portrait while it was stored in the artist’s Boston studio. Given the dearth of surviving drawings and preparatory studies from the artist’s oeuvre, this sketch represents a remarkable discovery. Stuart was famously dismissive of the practice of drawing in chalk, stating that it was ‘a loss of time’, and adding that ‘… all studies should be made with the brush in hand. It is nonsense to think of perfecting oneself in drawing before one begins to paint … Drawing outlines without the brush is like a man learning the notes without a fiddle, or learning the notes on a violin without a bow.’
It is notable that the inscription on the reverse of the Priestley portrait compares very closely with that on the reverse of the Dorchester Heights picture (as visible from an x-ray), a work commissioned by Samuel Parkman (1751-1824) and given to the city of Boston. It seems possible that Stuart decided either to give or to sell the Priestley portrait to Parkman, the preparatory oil sketch on the reverse serving as a memento of the Dorchester Heights commission. After having both works inscribed, Parkman would then subsequently have sold the portrait of Priestley to Barclay, a fellow merchant.
Stuart, the pre-eminent American portrait painter of his age, was born in Rhode Island in 1755, and left America for England aged twenty, spending many years studying there, at first under his compatriot Benjamin West. Working alongside Gainsborough and Reynolds, he enjoyed considerable success as a portrait painter before his chaotic finances and the prospect of debtors’ prison forced him to flee to Ireland, where he worked for some six years. After eighteen years away, in 1793 he returned to the land of his birth and quickly established himself as the most fashionable portraitist in New York before moving his studio to Philadelphia. There he began work on his celebrated series of portraits of Washington, including the full-length known as the Lansdowne Portrait (1796; Washington, Smithsonian National Portrait Gallery), presented to Priestley’s former employer, William Petty, then Earl of Shelburne and later 1st Marquess of Lansdowne, who served as British Prime Minister from 1782 to 1783. In 1803 Stuart followed the Federal government to the new capital of Washington, D.C., before moving to Boston in 1805 where he worked for the remainder of his life.
Like Stuart, Priestley left a legacy rooted both in Britain and America. Born in West Yorkshire in 1733 to a nonconformist family, he grew up an independent-minded and hard-working free-thinker, before becoming a dissenting minister. At the same time, he was developing an interest in science, a passion that intensified after meeting the American polymath Benjamin Franklin in 1765. Franklin, a physicist, statesman and inventor, encouraged Priestley in the research that led, two years later, to the publication of The History and Present State of Electricity (1767), Priestley having been elected a Fellow of the Royal Society the preceding year. He was a prominent member of the celebrated Birmingham Lunar Society, which counted Erasmus Darwin, James Watt, Matthew Boulton and Josiah Wedgwood among its members.
From 1773 to 1780 Priestley served as librarian and tutor to the children of Lord Lansdowne, who provided him with a laboratory at Bowood House, Calne, in Wiltshire, where he could conduct his scientific experiments. It was here, in August 1774, that Priestley isolated the gas he called ‘dephlogisticated air’, later identified as oxygen, having already demonstrated in 1771 that plants could restore air rendered unfit for respiration, discoveries that marked key turning points in the development of modern science. His fame had already spread abroad. He was elected an associate of the French Academy of Sciences in 1772 and later, in 1780, a member of the Imperial Academy of Sciences in St Petersburg. In the autumn of 1774, Priestley travelled to Paris in Shelburne’s suite and there described his experiment to Antoine-Laurent de Lavoisier, the French chemist whose oxygen theory of combustion would eventually supersede the phlogiston theory to which Priestley held for the rest of his life. Priestley’s outspoken support for the American and French Revolutions and his firm belief in Unitarianism earned him widespread unpopularity. On 14 July 1791, his house and laboratory at Fairhill, Birmingham, were burned down by a mob in what became known as the Priestley Riots (fig. 3), the subject of a painting by John Eckstein, an artist then resident in the city (1791; present whereabouts unknown, formerly in the collection of Susan Lowndes Marques, daughter of Marie Belloc Lowndes).
In 1794, Priestley and his family sailed for New York before settling in Pennsylvania. He stayed briefly in Philadelphia – known as the Athens of America, then the largest city in the new United States and its capital between 1790 and 1800 – before moving to Northumberland County, where he spent the remainder of his life and continued his scientific experiments. In America, Priestley formed a close intellectual friendship with Thomas Jefferson, whom he met in Philadelphia in 1797 and with whom he maintained a correspondence on religion, politics and education. Jefferson was a profound admirer of Priestley’s scientific and theological writings, and their shared commitment to religious liberty and the advancement of knowledge established a bond that endured until the scientist’s death. Writing to Priestley on 21 March 1801, shortly after assuming the presidency, Jefferson declared that ‘Yours is one of the few lives precious to mankind’, a tribute that eloquently attests to the extraordinary esteem in which the English polymath was held in his adopted country (Thomas Jefferson to Joseph Priestley, 21 March 1801, The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, Founders Online, National Archives). When he died in 1804, he was universally acknowledged as one of the outstanding scientific figures of the age. Priestley was a complex figure, whose theological and metaphysical works, particularly his interest in Unitarianism, need to be set alongside his scientific achievements.
In character, Priestley was known for his simplicity and kindness of heart, qualities eloquently captured by Stuart and lauded by Mary Anne Schimmelpenninck, née Galton, who knew him through her father’s Lunar Society circle and described the ‘serene expression of his countenance’. She further observed that ‘He seemed present with God by recollection and with man by cheerfulness’. Priestley stands as a leading figure of the ‘Atlantic Enlightenment’ whose work bridged natural philosophy, radical politics and dissenting theology. Stuart’s portrait of Priestley strikes a disarmingly restrained note, capturing, with psychological intensity, the spirituality and questing curiosity of this singular polymath.
Of the various portraits painted of Priestley during his lifetime, this is arguably the finest. In a letter dated 6 January 1806 to Thomas Jefferson, then President of the United States, Priestley’s son Joseph wrote: ‘All the likenesses which I have seen of my father fall so far short, in my opinion, of that taken by Mr Stewart [sic]…’. He expressed his wish to reproduce Stuart’s portrait in his father’s memoirs and appealed to Jefferson to help secure a copy or permission to have an engraving made from the original, fearing that Stuart’s financial difficulties might have led him to sell the picture. Jefferson replied on 11 January that he would gladly have assisted, observing that Stuart’s ‘portraits are so fine that I should be sorry that the engraving should be from any other’, but explained that the artist was then in Boston and expressed his conviction that the original had not been sold (Joseph Priestley Jr. to Thomas Jefferson, 6 January 1806, and Jefferson to Priestley Jr., 11 January 1806, The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, Founders Online, National Archives).
The portrait was commissioned in 1797 by the American Philosophical Society, founded in 1743 by Benjamin Franklin in Philadelphia, for which Stuart was paid in advance the sum of 50 guineas. Despite the entreaties of the Society, Stuart failed to deliver the portrait, and the work evidently remained in his studio, supposedly unfinished. For reasons that remain unclear, but possibly due to the unrelenting strain of debts, Stuart is thought to have sold the portrait to Thomas Brocklehurst Barclay (1783-1866), a Liverpool merchant then visiting the United States, together with a copy of his portrait of Washington. On his return to England, Barclay commissioned the painter William Artaud, around 1812, to complete the background. It is possible that Barclay misunderstood Stuart’s technique of employing a lightly scumbled background, a practice he sometimes used to ensure the focus was drawn entirely to the sitter’s face, and, for purely aesthetic reasons, instructed Artaud to have this final passage of the portrait ‘finished’.
While the portrait remained in Artaud’s studio, the artist made three copies of Stuart’s original. A ‘Dissenter’ (later known as a Nonconformist) himself, Artaud may have known Priestley personally, as suggested by his highly engaging portrait of the scientist, executed in 1794 and formerly in the collection of Dr Williams’s Library at Gordon Square (Dr Williams’s Trust, on deposit at the University of Manchester). All three copies were likely intended for Priestley’s family; one is recorded in the collection of his descendant Marie Belloc Lowndes, the novelist and sister of Hilaire Belloc. It was from one of these copies, subsequently in the possession of Priestley’s descendants in Pennsylvania, that the American artist Albert Rosenthal (1863-1939) made his own copy, now in the Smithsonian National Museum of American History, Washington. On Barclay’s death in 1866 he bequeathed both the present portrait and that of Washington to William Rathbone V.
William Rathbone V (1787-1868) was an English merchant, politician, Mayor of Liverpool and a Unitarian. The Rathbone family were nonconformist shipowners and merchants of Liverpool, known for their philanthropy, public service and campaigns for social reform. They were also known for their patronage of the arts. William’s brother, Richard (1788-1860), became a key patron and sponsor of John James Audubon’s The Birds of America, published between 1827 and 1838, while his grandson, William Rathbone VII (1849-1919), was a close friend of the American painter John Singer Sargent.
Intriguingly, the reverse of the present panel (which has also been prepared with a ground layer) shows a rapidly brushed oil sketch of a figure beside a horse (fig. 1). Although there is a very slight difference in the arrangement of the subjects, the oil sketch corresponds almost precisely with Stuart’s portrait of George Washington at Dorchester Heights (1806; Boston, Museum of Fine Arts; fig. 2), the monumental full-length in which the sitter is shown holding the reins of his horse with Boston Harbour in the distance. This sketch, therefore, would appear to be an early exercise in Stuart’s preparation for the Dorchester Heights composition, executed on the reverse of Priestley’s undelivered portrait while it was stored in the artist’s Boston studio. Given the dearth of surviving drawings and preparatory studies from the artist’s oeuvre, this sketch represents a remarkable discovery. Stuart was famously dismissive of the practice of drawing in chalk, stating that it was ‘a loss of time’, and adding that ‘… all studies should be made with the brush in hand. It is nonsense to think of perfecting oneself in drawing before one begins to paint … Drawing outlines without the brush is like a man learning the notes without a fiddle, or learning the notes on a violin without a bow.’
It is notable that the inscription on the reverse of the Priestley portrait compares very closely with that on the reverse of the Dorchester Heights picture (as visible from an x-ray), a work commissioned by Samuel Parkman (1751-1824) and given to the city of Boston. It seems possible that Stuart decided either to give or to sell the Priestley portrait to Parkman, the preparatory oil sketch on the reverse serving as a memento of the Dorchester Heights commission. After having both works inscribed, Parkman would then subsequently have sold the portrait of Priestley to Barclay, a fellow merchant.
Stuart, the pre-eminent American portrait painter of his age, was born in Rhode Island in 1755, and left America for England aged twenty, spending many years studying there, at first under his compatriot Benjamin West. Working alongside Gainsborough and Reynolds, he enjoyed considerable success as a portrait painter before his chaotic finances and the prospect of debtors’ prison forced him to flee to Ireland, where he worked for some six years. After eighteen years away, in 1793 he returned to the land of his birth and quickly established himself as the most fashionable portraitist in New York before moving his studio to Philadelphia. There he began work on his celebrated series of portraits of Washington, including the full-length known as the Lansdowne Portrait (1796; Washington, Smithsonian National Portrait Gallery), presented to Priestley’s former employer, William Petty, then Earl of Shelburne and later 1st Marquess of Lansdowne, who served as British Prime Minister from 1782 to 1783. In 1803 Stuart followed the Federal government to the new capital of Washington, D.C., before moving to Boston in 1805 where he worked for the remainder of his life.
Like Stuart, Priestley left a legacy rooted both in Britain and America. Born in West Yorkshire in 1733 to a nonconformist family, he grew up an independent-minded and hard-working free-thinker, before becoming a dissenting minister. At the same time, he was developing an interest in science, a passion that intensified after meeting the American polymath Benjamin Franklin in 1765. Franklin, a physicist, statesman and inventor, encouraged Priestley in the research that led, two years later, to the publication of The History and Present State of Electricity (1767), Priestley having been elected a Fellow of the Royal Society the preceding year. He was a prominent member of the celebrated Birmingham Lunar Society, which counted Erasmus Darwin, James Watt, Matthew Boulton and Josiah Wedgwood among its members.
From 1773 to 1780 Priestley served as librarian and tutor to the children of Lord Lansdowne, who provided him with a laboratory at Bowood House, Calne, in Wiltshire, where he could conduct his scientific experiments. It was here, in August 1774, that Priestley isolated the gas he called ‘dephlogisticated air’, later identified as oxygen, having already demonstrated in 1771 that plants could restore air rendered unfit for respiration, discoveries that marked key turning points in the development of modern science. His fame had already spread abroad. He was elected an associate of the French Academy of Sciences in 1772 and later, in 1780, a member of the Imperial Academy of Sciences in St Petersburg. In the autumn of 1774, Priestley travelled to Paris in Shelburne’s suite and there described his experiment to Antoine-Laurent de Lavoisier, the French chemist whose oxygen theory of combustion would eventually supersede the phlogiston theory to which Priestley held for the rest of his life. Priestley’s outspoken support for the American and French Revolutions and his firm belief in Unitarianism earned him widespread unpopularity. On 14 July 1791, his house and laboratory at Fairhill, Birmingham, were burned down by a mob in what became known as the Priestley Riots (fig. 3), the subject of a painting by John Eckstein, an artist then resident in the city (1791; present whereabouts unknown, formerly in the collection of Susan Lowndes Marques, daughter of Marie Belloc Lowndes).
In 1794, Priestley and his family sailed for New York before settling in Pennsylvania. He stayed briefly in Philadelphia – known as the Athens of America, then the largest city in the new United States and its capital between 1790 and 1800 – before moving to Northumberland County, where he spent the remainder of his life and continued his scientific experiments. In America, Priestley formed a close intellectual friendship with Thomas Jefferson, whom he met in Philadelphia in 1797 and with whom he maintained a correspondence on religion, politics and education. Jefferson was a profound admirer of Priestley’s scientific and theological writings, and their shared commitment to religious liberty and the advancement of knowledge established a bond that endured until the scientist’s death. Writing to Priestley on 21 March 1801, shortly after assuming the presidency, Jefferson declared that ‘Yours is one of the few lives precious to mankind’, a tribute that eloquently attests to the extraordinary esteem in which the English polymath was held in his adopted country (Thomas Jefferson to Joseph Priestley, 21 March 1801, The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, Founders Online, National Archives). When he died in 1804, he was universally acknowledged as one of the outstanding scientific figures of the age. Priestley was a complex figure, whose theological and metaphysical works, particularly his interest in Unitarianism, need to be set alongside his scientific achievements.
In character, Priestley was known for his simplicity and kindness of heart, qualities eloquently captured by Stuart and lauded by Mary Anne Schimmelpenninck, née Galton, who knew him through her father’s Lunar Society circle and described the ‘serene expression of his countenance’. She further observed that ‘He seemed present with God by recollection and with man by cheerfulness’. Priestley stands as a leading figure of the ‘Atlantic Enlightenment’ whose work bridged natural philosophy, radical politics and dissenting theology. Stuart’s portrait of Priestley strikes a disarmingly restrained note, capturing, with psychological intensity, the spirituality and questing curiosity of this singular polymath.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
