Descriptif du lot
Antique Juggling Girl has not been seen at public exhibition in Britain since the end of the nineteenth century, and has therefore been inconspicuous in the recent literature on its artist, as well as the more general literature on Victorian art. Yet it was one of Leighton’s most highly regarded paintings, from the generally favourable reviews of its London début, at the Royal Academy exhibition of 1874, through to the magisterial biography of 1906 by Mrs Russell Barrington, who declared it ‘a very original work’, one which should ‘be placed very high in the rank of Leighton’s achievements’. Its reappearance in the present sale therefore provides a welcome opportunity to restore it to its rightful place in Leighton’s oeuvre.
What prompted Mrs Barrington to call the painting ‘very original’? It represents a female nude in an ancient setting – an unexceptionable subject for a European painting in the post-Renaissance tradition. Yet she is neither a goddess nor a nymph, nor even a celebrated ancient courtesan, but merely a young woman performing a juggling act. One cue for the subject-matter may have been the painting shown at the Royal Academy exhibition of 1870 under the French title Un jongleur (‘A Juggler’, fig. 1), one of the first exhibits by the young Dutch painter, Lawrence Alma-Tadema, who would soon make his home and career in London. The male juggler in Alma-Tadema’s picture is an Egyptian, probably a slave, who plies a humble trade for the amusement of the Roman patrician family, who enjoy their leisure in an opulently appointed interior, well-stocked with luxury objects meticulously reconstructed from artefacts found at Pompeii and other ancient archaeological sites.
Leighton’s ‘juggling girl’, by contrast, stands tall and confident, facing the viewer, thoroughly in command of her surroundings. The model for the figure has been identified as Antonia Caiva, an Italian professional model much admired for her classical beauty and frequently employed by artists in Leighton’s circle. For Edward Burne-Jones she was ‘like Eve and Semiramis, but if she had a mind at all, which I always doubted, it had no ideas.’ He added, however: ‘She has splendour and solemnity’ (S. Wildman and J. Christian, Edward Burne-Jones: Victorian Artist-Dreamer, New York, 1998, pp. 249-50) – qualities evident both in the exquisite drawing by Burne-Jones that identifies her by name (fig. 2), and, more surprisingly, in the lithe posture and the golden, smoothly modelled flesh-tones of Leighton’s ancient juggler.
Leighton’s juggler is surrounded by the tools of her trade: a sword and a set of juggling rings in the foreground; a metal rod, perhaps used for flame-throwing, standing in the burnished urn; and a set of ropes with handles looped over the background screen, as well as the glinting golden balls caught in mid-flight. At the base of the screen is a frieze of dancing figures, reminiscent in design of a Greek vase painting. The figure stands on a leopard skin and wears a wreath of ivy-leaves – both elements associated with the worship of the wine-god Dionysus. The decorative border of the screen, with its stylised wave pattern, the furniture-legs just visible under the discarded draperies, and the orange grove in the background are all consistent with a setting in the ancient Mediterranean. Yet there is no sign of a detailed social milieu like that of Alma-Tadema’s painting. Instead, the figure is relieved against the pale-coloured vertical screen, which resembles the ‘cloth of honour’ often found behind the Madonna in Renaissance paintings. This confers a certain monumentality on the figure; the delicate tints of the flesh are keyed with utmost subtlety to the ivory and golden tints of the screen. The elegant poise of the figure seems somehow to outweigh the triviality of her activity.
For unknown reasons, Leighton chose to introduce the painting at the Liverpool Autumn Exhibition of 1873, before its London début at the Royal Academy in 1874. He must also have encouraged his friends among influential art critics, Emilia F.S. Pattison (later Lady Dilke) of the Academy and F.G. Stephens of the Athenaeum, to publish previews of the painting. If he was worried that the stark nudity of his figure, scarcely justified by its slight narrative pretext, might raise eyebrows in London, such fears proved unnecessary. Critics across the political spectrum were prepared to accept the painting as an essay in purely visual beauty. As the critic for the Spectator put it: ‘It does not matter in the least … whether any “Antique Juggling-Girl”, with the smallest conceivable amount of drapery, ever tossed a circle of golden balls in front of an ivory-tinted screen. It is enough for us that we see … a graceful composition of beauteous forms and tender harmonies of colour, with a subtle play of light, and everywhere what is grateful and delicious to the eye.’
Such reactions would have been unlikely only a few years earlier, when the London critics were more apt to dwell on the moral implications of the works under review. By 1874, Leighton had consolidated his position as the leading advocate for new trends in art that favoured excellence of design over worthy content; the phrase ‘art for art’s sake’, introduced as recently as 1868 and initially controversial, was increasingly accepted as an appropriate aim for artmaking. At this date, too, the campaign among younger artists to promote the ambitious painting of the nude figure, both male and female, at the London exhibitions was gathering force. Leighton himself had taken the lead with his large-scale female nude of 1867, Venus Disrobing for the Bath (fig. 3), soon followed by the male nude in his Daedalus and Icarus of 1869 (fig. 4). From that date onward, the artistic and cultural prestige of the nude grew inexorably, despite the occasional moral backlash – most famously in 1885 when a correspondent to The Times, who signed as ‘the British Matron’, objected to paintings of the nude on exhibition that year.
Leighton himself remained a lifelong advocate for the study of the nude figure in art education as well as in public exhibition. Antique Juggling Girl made its public début at an auspicious moment in Leighton’s career, six years after he reached the important milestone of becoming a full Royal Academician, but with four years still to go before his election to the Presidency of the Royal Academy, with its attendant public and administrative responsibilities. He was already at work on his next, magnificent processional painting with a subject from ancient Greek history, The Daphnephoria, finally exhibited in 1876 (Port Sunlight, Lady Lever Art Gallery). But in his early forties, with his reputation assured, he was also able to find time to paint for sheer delight. With its playful theme, its golden sunshine and its expertly articulated nude figure, Antique Juggling Girl stands as the perfect representative of that moment. Perhaps that helps to explain why sympathetic critics, from Emilia F.S. Pattison to Mrs Russell Barrington, were prepared, rightly, to place it among Leighton’s highest achievements.
We are grateful to Elizabeth Prettejohn, Professor of History of Art, University of York, for her assistance in preparing this catalogue entry.
What prompted Mrs Barrington to call the painting ‘very original’? It represents a female nude in an ancient setting – an unexceptionable subject for a European painting in the post-Renaissance tradition. Yet she is neither a goddess nor a nymph, nor even a celebrated ancient courtesan, but merely a young woman performing a juggling act. One cue for the subject-matter may have been the painting shown at the Royal Academy exhibition of 1870 under the French title Un jongleur (‘A Juggler’, fig. 1), one of the first exhibits by the young Dutch painter, Lawrence Alma-Tadema, who would soon make his home and career in London. The male juggler in Alma-Tadema’s picture is an Egyptian, probably a slave, who plies a humble trade for the amusement of the Roman patrician family, who enjoy their leisure in an opulently appointed interior, well-stocked with luxury objects meticulously reconstructed from artefacts found at Pompeii and other ancient archaeological sites.
Leighton’s ‘juggling girl’, by contrast, stands tall and confident, facing the viewer, thoroughly in command of her surroundings. The model for the figure has been identified as Antonia Caiva, an Italian professional model much admired for her classical beauty and frequently employed by artists in Leighton’s circle. For Edward Burne-Jones she was ‘like Eve and Semiramis, but if she had a mind at all, which I always doubted, it had no ideas.’ He added, however: ‘She has splendour and solemnity’ (S. Wildman and J. Christian, Edward Burne-Jones: Victorian Artist-Dreamer, New York, 1998, pp. 249-50) – qualities evident both in the exquisite drawing by Burne-Jones that identifies her by name (fig. 2), and, more surprisingly, in the lithe posture and the golden, smoothly modelled flesh-tones of Leighton’s ancient juggler.
Leighton’s juggler is surrounded by the tools of her trade: a sword and a set of juggling rings in the foreground; a metal rod, perhaps used for flame-throwing, standing in the burnished urn; and a set of ropes with handles looped over the background screen, as well as the glinting golden balls caught in mid-flight. At the base of the screen is a frieze of dancing figures, reminiscent in design of a Greek vase painting. The figure stands on a leopard skin and wears a wreath of ivy-leaves – both elements associated with the worship of the wine-god Dionysus. The decorative border of the screen, with its stylised wave pattern, the furniture-legs just visible under the discarded draperies, and the orange grove in the background are all consistent with a setting in the ancient Mediterranean. Yet there is no sign of a detailed social milieu like that of Alma-Tadema’s painting. Instead, the figure is relieved against the pale-coloured vertical screen, which resembles the ‘cloth of honour’ often found behind the Madonna in Renaissance paintings. This confers a certain monumentality on the figure; the delicate tints of the flesh are keyed with utmost subtlety to the ivory and golden tints of the screen. The elegant poise of the figure seems somehow to outweigh the triviality of her activity.
For unknown reasons, Leighton chose to introduce the painting at the Liverpool Autumn Exhibition of 1873, before its London début at the Royal Academy in 1874. He must also have encouraged his friends among influential art critics, Emilia F.S. Pattison (later Lady Dilke) of the Academy and F.G. Stephens of the Athenaeum, to publish previews of the painting. If he was worried that the stark nudity of his figure, scarcely justified by its slight narrative pretext, might raise eyebrows in London, such fears proved unnecessary. Critics across the political spectrum were prepared to accept the painting as an essay in purely visual beauty. As the critic for the Spectator put it: ‘It does not matter in the least … whether any “Antique Juggling-Girl”, with the smallest conceivable amount of drapery, ever tossed a circle of golden balls in front of an ivory-tinted screen. It is enough for us that we see … a graceful composition of beauteous forms and tender harmonies of colour, with a subtle play of light, and everywhere what is grateful and delicious to the eye.’
Such reactions would have been unlikely only a few years earlier, when the London critics were more apt to dwell on the moral implications of the works under review. By 1874, Leighton had consolidated his position as the leading advocate for new trends in art that favoured excellence of design over worthy content; the phrase ‘art for art’s sake’, introduced as recently as 1868 and initially controversial, was increasingly accepted as an appropriate aim for artmaking. At this date, too, the campaign among younger artists to promote the ambitious painting of the nude figure, both male and female, at the London exhibitions was gathering force. Leighton himself had taken the lead with his large-scale female nude of 1867, Venus Disrobing for the Bath (fig. 3), soon followed by the male nude in his Daedalus and Icarus of 1869 (fig. 4). From that date onward, the artistic and cultural prestige of the nude grew inexorably, despite the occasional moral backlash – most famously in 1885 when a correspondent to The Times, who signed as ‘the British Matron’, objected to paintings of the nude on exhibition that year.
Leighton himself remained a lifelong advocate for the study of the nude figure in art education as well as in public exhibition. Antique Juggling Girl made its public début at an auspicious moment in Leighton’s career, six years after he reached the important milestone of becoming a full Royal Academician, but with four years still to go before his election to the Presidency of the Royal Academy, with its attendant public and administrative responsibilities. He was already at work on his next, magnificent processional painting with a subject from ancient Greek history, The Daphnephoria, finally exhibited in 1876 (Port Sunlight, Lady Lever Art Gallery). But in his early forties, with his reputation assured, he was also able to find time to paint for sheer delight. With its playful theme, its golden sunshine and its expertly articulated nude figure, Antique Juggling Girl stands as the perfect representative of that moment. Perhaps that helps to explain why sympathetic critics, from Emilia F.S. Pattison to Mrs Russell Barrington, were prepared, rightly, to place it among Leighton’s highest achievements.
We are grateful to Elizabeth Prettejohn, Professor of History of Art, University of York, for her assistance in preparing this catalogue entry.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
