ROBERT INDIANA (1928-2018)
ROBERT INDIANA (1928-2018)
ROBERT INDIANA (1928-2018)
1 More
ROBERT INDIANA (1928-2018)
4 More
Herbert Lust: Collector, Scholar, Friend
ROBERT INDIANA (1928-2018)

LOVE Wall

Details
ROBERT INDIANA (1928-2018)
LOVE Wall
stenciled with the artist's initials 'RI' (on the reverse of the upper right canvas); stenciled with the date '68' (on the reverse of the upper left canvas)
oil on canvas, in four parts
each: 12 x 12 in. (30.5 x 30.5 cm.)
overall: 24 x 24 in. (61 x 61 cm.)
Painted in 1968
Provenance
Acquired from the artist by the late owner, circa 1989.
Literature
M. Murphy, ed., Robert Indiana: An American Icon, New York, 2026, p. 202 (illustrated).
S. Salama-Caro, The Robert Indiana Catalogue Raisonné (www.ricatalogueraisonne.org), no. P-1968-13 (illustrated; accessed September 2026).
Exhibited
Rockland, Farnsworth Art Museum; Waterville, Colby College Museum of Art; Pennsylvania, Reading Public Museum; Framingham, Danforth Museum; Manchester, Currier Gallery of Art; Pittsfield, Berkshire Museum and Flint Institute of Arts, Indiana's Indianas: A Twenty-Year Retrospective of Painting and Sculpture from the Collection of Robert Indiana, September 1982-March 1984, p. 22 (titled The Gray LOVE).
Maine, Portland Museum of Art and Marietta/Cobb Museum of Art, Love and the American Dream: The Art of Robert Indiana, June 1999-January 2000, p. 104, no. 38 (titled Grey Love Wall).
New York, Sotheby's, S 2 Gallery, Robert Indiana: Works from the Collection of Herbert Lust, September-October 2017, pp. 124-125 (illustrated).
New York, Pace, Robert Indiana: The American Dream, May-August 2025.

Brought to you by

Paige Kestenman
Paige Kestenman Vice President, Senior Specialist, Co-Head of 20th Century Evening Sale

Lot Essay

An exceptional, early example of the artist’s instantly iconic LOVE paintings, LOVE Wall reveals Robert Indiana in full command of his innovative artistic motif which has pervaded popular culture. Painted in 1968, the work is one of the first from the eponymous series which repeats Indiana’s famous phrase across four connected panels. Multiplied and reimagined across the painting in four different orientations, Indiana constructs here a palindrome which doubles LOVE then doubles it again. The present work demonstrates Indiana working at the precipice of abstraction as his merged and mingled letters collate into abstract signs deprived of legibility.

His four centered Vs, stacked over each other, expand to create two large X shapes, which create “the two unknowns whose meeting presides over the existence of love, as in mathematical equations,” as the art historian Hélène Depotte describes (“Towards an Immobile Voyage: Robert Indiana, the Reality-Dreamer,” in Robert Indiana: Rétrospective 1958-1998, exh. cat., Musée d’Art Modern et d’Art Contemporain de Nice, 1998, p. 67). LOVE Wall propels Indiana’s most important motif into a new dimension, emphasizing the optical shock of his value-laden text through multiplicity. The critic Lucy Lippard describes the series as “exuberant, exquisitely rendered works, decorative in a good sense and products of a sophisticated innocence” (quoted in M. Krause and J. Wilmerding, eds., The Essential Robert Indiana, exh. cat., Indianapolis Museum of Art, 2013, p. 58).

The Cubists and Surrealists were among the first to include text in paintings, using words incidentally in the case of Cubist collage and didactically in the case of Joan Miró or René Magritte’s Surrealist imagery. Indiana’s innovation was to deconstruct his text, employing each letter structurally to explore syllabic and visual potentials simultaneously.

The art historian Susan Elizabeth Ryan, identifying LOVE as “a watershed in Indiana’s career,” explains how here, “word and image are equal; figure and ground coextensive” (“Eternal Love,” in Love and the American Dream: The Art of Robert Indiana, exh. cat., Portland Museum of Art, 1999, p. 76). The artist’s word-based art originated in love poems which Indiana composed in the 1950s, while his decision to focus on love stemmed from his upbringing in a religious family in rural Indiana. “All Christian Science churches are very prim and proper,” Indiana explained. “Only one thing appears in a Christian Science church, and that’s a small, very tasteful inscription, in gold usually, over the platform where the readers conduct the service. And that inscription is God is Love” (ibid., p. 79).

Gertude Stein’s line “Rose is a rose is a rose” from her 1913 poem “Sacred Emily” served as partial inspiration for Indiana’s decision to repeat his love motif across his oeuvre. Indiana’s art, a vital precursor to Pop, emerged out of the young artist’s deep immersion and deployment of the vernacular of American popular culture—engaging with American history and Beat poetry through the lens of his midwestern roots, Indiana achieved a uniquely American sensibility. Working amid the Coenties Slip artists, including Ellsworth Kelly, Agnes Martin, and James Rosenquist, Indiana wielded symbols such as love in order to comment on the newfound pervasiveness of text and images in twentieth century America. “Indiana’s art corroborates this new reliance on street and highway signage, and on its chance poetry, on the endless flux of urban messages that ceaselessly buzz in front of our eyes and brain, and on its powerful visual fascination,” describes the art historian Joachim Pissaro (“Signed into Art,” in Robert Indiana, New York, 2006, p. 59).

“...exuberant, exquisitely rendered works, decorative in a good sense and products of a sophisticated innocence.” -- Lucy Lippard

The present work was acquired directly from the artist by Herbert Lust. The two first met in 1973 at a New York dinner party hosted by the du Pont family. The hostess ushered Lust into a drawing room, telling him that a “fellow Hoosier” was dying to meet him. This chance meeting, initiated by their shared Indianan origins, inaugurated a decades-long friendship between artist and collector. Lust, along with his wife Virginia, were some of Indiana’s most ardent champions. Virginia gave Indiana his first solo show in thirteen years at her gallery in 1989, reigniting attention in the artist. Herbert helped organize international museum and gallery exhibitions, while simultaneously building one of the most important collections of Indiana’s work in private hands. LOVE Wall has remained in the Lust collection for forty years and has been loaned to several of Indiana’s most important retrospectives, including his 1999 exhibition at the Portland Museum of Art. An exceptional, rare example of the artist’s most renowned motif, LOVE Wall is the most important early four-part LOVE painting to come to auction in almost twenty years.

Herbert Lust: Collector, Scholar, Friend
A farm boy from Indiana who through intellect and luck became an accomplished scholar, writer, and collector, Herbert Lust, reflecting on his many achievements, described himself as “a dazed soldier of fortune, drenched with experience.” An early encounter with Keats’ “Ode to a Nightingale” propelled him toward a literary career. At the age of twenty-one, he became the youngest person ever to receive a master’s degree in philosophy and mathematics from the University of Chicago, and in 1949 he became one of the first Fulbright scholars, using his grant to spend two years in Paris investigating the influence of the American novel on French literature.

Describing his first studio visit with Alberto Giacometti, which would catalyze his collecting, Herbert Lust writes, “The space was very small, and the scattered bronzes seemed quite ugly to me. Yet my studies of philosophy and literature also told me that my initial impressions must be wrong. If Sartre and the greatest writers claimed that Alberto was a great artist, then I was just a fool, and had much to learn about art.” Giacometti was Lust’s first thrilling confrontation with contemporary art, and his initial negative response was soon replaced by a compelling desire to study and collect.

Informed by the collecting practices of Gertrude Stein, another literary hero whose legacy he knew well through his friendship with Alice B. Toklas, and using his meager Fulbright grant funds, Lust’s first major acquisition was an Yves Tanguy painting, followed in quick succession by several Hans Bellmer drawings. Tanguy’s Qui répondra? (1948), now in Lust’s collection, exemplifies Lust’s early impulse toward Surrealism, which would also lead him to assemble one of the most significant collections of Bellmer in the world.

Lust, together with his wife Virginia, whom he married in 1963, began building one of the greatest collections of Giacometti works. In 1970, the crown jewel entered the collection when Lust purchased Giacometti’s seminal Figure, demie grandeur (no. 2) from Joseph R. Shapiro, a prominent Chicago collector and founding president of the city’s Museum of Contemporary Art. “It was the first and fullest recognizable portrait done in Giacometti’s greatest period,” writes Lust. “It was in homage to his great love, Isabel Delmer, whom he had sculpted off and on for a dozen years by 1949. He was fascinated by her chignon. In no bronze does Alberto depict better a man’s love for a woman. She is love, tenderness, courage and majesty incarnate, a weightless queen in an invisible kingdom.”

Lust’s collection expanded well beyond the European avant-garde. Three years after acquiring Figure, demie grandeur (no. 2), another stroke of luck found him at a society gathering in New York hosted by the du Pont family. There he met Robert Indiana, who immediately challenged Lust’s predilection for European art and his reluctance to collect contemporary American artists. What began as a spirited debate evolved into a decades-long engagement with Indiana’s work. Lust ultimately acquired more than thirty works by the artist, including important examples such as FOUR (1965) and LOVE (1975). The artist’s LUST FAMILY PORTRAIT (1995), inscribed “For Virginia and Herbert Lust,” remains a testament to their enduring relationship.

Virginia Lust Gallery, with which Herbert was closely involved, championed other important artists as well, including Frank Stella. Lust eventually acquired Stella’s early masterpiece Les Indes Galantes (1964), from the artist’s seminal Mitered Maze series. Titled after Jean- Philippe Rameau’s Baroque opera-ballet concerning Cupid’s search for love across the globe, and inspired by Stella’s time in Paris, the work chimes compellingly with Lust’s own personal journey.

Through careful scholarship, insightful writing, and deep friendships, Herbert Lust built one of the greatest collections of contemporary art of his generation. Armed with luck and a sharp intellect, Lust built an incredible collection of artists whom he knew both personally and academically. His success in both business and collecting allowed him to generously support numerous institutions—his gifts of hundreds of works from his collection to the Tel Aviv Museum and to the Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden proved transformative to both museums, expanding the scope and reach of their collections. Holding seminal works by artists ranging from Giacometti and Calder, Tanguy, Bellmer, and Bauermeister, to Frank Stella and Robert Indiana, Herbert Lust’s collection explores in depth the artists he befriended. At once perceptively scholarly and deeply personal, the collection tells the story of both an exceptional personality and the course of art history across the twentieth century.

More from 20th Century Evening Sale

View All
View All