Lot Essay
Few works of medieval sculpture coming to auction can claim the combination of rarity and significance embodied by the present Saint Catherine. An autograph work by Tilman Riemenschneider, the most recognizable and celebrated sculptor of the Golden Age of late medieval German wood sculpture, the present figure is one of only a handful of the master’s works to remain in private hands. When the figure last appeared on the market in 2008, it achieved $6,313,000, setting a world auction record for a work of European medieval sculpture (Sotheby’s, New York, 24 January, lot 31). The delicacy of the carving and the understated emotional intensity conveyed through the facial features are hallmarks of Riemenschneider’s mature style.
Riemenschneider’s very earliest years of training remain relatively obscure, but he is known to have traveled to Ulm, where he was apprenticed to the sculptor Michel Erhart (c. 1440⁄1445-after 1522). Equally adept at carving in stone, alabaster and wood, Riemenschneider would eventually settle in Würzburg in 1483, where he was admitted to the Guild of Saint Luke as a master in 1485. He was extensively patronized by town councils and members of the church and, at the peak of his career, is thought to have had as many as 40 assistants in his workshop. Among his most important extant commissions in stone one might cite the monument to the Prince-Bishop Rudolf von Scherenberg (1496-1499, Würzburg Cathedral) and the tomb of Heinrich II and Kunigunde (dedicated in 1513, Bamberg Cathedral). He is also documented to have executed numerous works, principally altarpieces, in wood, both painted and unpainted, but many of these were destroyed or dispersed during the religious and political upheavals of the first half of the 16th century. Perhaps the most important of the surviving works in wood is the Holy Blood Altarpiece (1501-1505, Jakobskirche, Rothenburg; for images see Chapuis,1999, pp. 30-31), the central scene of which depicts the Last Supper, at which Christ refers to the wine as the ‘new covenant in my blood’. Despite being a wealthy and respected burgher, Riemenschneider found himself on the losing side of the Peasants’ Revolt of 1525. As a result, he was imprisoned and possibly tortured. He did not produce any significant works thereafter and died in 1531 in Würzburg where he was buried in the cathedral cemetery.
The original location of the present figure of Saint Catherine is unknown, but it was almost certainly a flanking figure to a central group in a carved wood altarpiece. Unknown to scholars until its sale from the collection of Georg Schuster, Munich, in 1927, it had only once been exhibited, in Hanover in 1931, before its appearance in the exhibition devoted to the artist in 1999 in Washington, Tilman Riemenschneider: Master Sculptor of the Late Middle Ages. When it was sold from the Schuster collection, it was paired with another female saint by Riemenschneider whose identity remains uncertain because she has lost her attributes. The two saints were purchased together and descended within the same family. The other saint was sold at auction (Sotheby’s, New York, 22 May 2001, lot 32) and was acquired by the Peter Moores Foundation at Compton Verney for $2,970,000. Due to their size, technical similarities and a distinctive slot in the reverse of each which is thought to have facilitated attachment to the original altarpiece, the two figures are generally agreed to have come from the same, unidentified, commission. A third figure of Saint Elizabeth of Hungary, in the Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Nuremberg, although polychromed, has also been linked to the same altarpiece. Julien Chapuis has suggested that the three figures were originally a group of four, and were part of an altarpiece similar in arrangement to Michel Erhart’s Blaubeuren Altarpiece. Based on various compositional features, he proposes that Saint Catherine stood to the right of the central figure or group, and on the left stood Saint Elizabeth flanked by the female saint from Compton Verney (Chapuis, 1999, p. 331).
A detailed analysis of the surface carving of the present figure and the unidentified female saint by Michele Marincola suggests that the figures were originally intended to be unpainted, although enhanced with subtle glazes. This was confirmed by a second analysis by Wibke Ottweiler in 2025. Marincola identifies nine different tool types and argues convincingly that the delicacy of the carving and punching would have been obscured by the application of a ground and different paint layers, as is the case in the Saint Elizabeth. It is thought that all three figures were given a polychrome surface, possibly as early as the late 16th century, but that the Saint Catherine and unidentified saint were then returned to their original surface, probably in the 19th century. Riemenschneider was among the earliest German wood sculptors to have produced "unpolychromed" figures and groups.
The three saints discussed above are thought to have been executed over a number of years, with the present lot considered to be the earliest. Riemenschneider is known to have often taken a considerable amount of time to execute some of his commissions, and on stylistic grounds it is thought that this altarpiece may have taken 10 to 15 years to complete. In his entry on the three figures, Chapuis argues that the "volumetric treatment of form and angular drapery patterns" of the Saint Catherine are typical of the artist’s work from around 1505, comparing it to the Virgin from a Virgin and Child group dated to circa 1503-1505 in the Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, Hamburg (see Chapuis, 1999, no. 28, pp. 271-274).
Saint Catherine of Alexandria has long been venerated as a model of courage, strength and wisdom. In the Christian tradition, the fourth-century saint was martyred for her condemnation of pagan idolatry and refusal to break her vow of chastity. By the tenth century, she had begun to be venerated in the Eastern Orthodox Church, and the spread of her cult led to her increasing popularity and fame during the Middle Ages. In visual culture, she is typically identified by a number of attributes, including a crown, a wheel, the proposed means of her torture, a sword, a book and a martyr’s palm. The missing hand of the present sculpture may originally have held a sword, while a wheel may have been positioned at the saint’s feet, as in Martin Schongauer’s engraving of Saint Catherine of circa 1480-1490 (National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC, inv. no. 1943.3.69). Riemenschneider was intimately familiar with Schongauer’s work, which greatly informed his own artistic practice; while some of his compositions directly adopted Schongauer’s graphic models, others reinterpreted and developed them more freely (Chapuis, 1999, pp. 62–63).
The reappearance of the present figure of Saint Catherine at auction represents a rare opportunity for collectors of sculpture from any era. Not only is it a recognized masterpiece by one of the most important sculptors of the late Middle Ages, but its contained emotional intensity and the almost modern abstraction evident in the folds of drapery mean that it transcends both place and period.
Riemenschneider’s very earliest years of training remain relatively obscure, but he is known to have traveled to Ulm, where he was apprenticed to the sculptor Michel Erhart (c. 1440⁄1445-after 1522). Equally adept at carving in stone, alabaster and wood, Riemenschneider would eventually settle in Würzburg in 1483, where he was admitted to the Guild of Saint Luke as a master in 1485. He was extensively patronized by town councils and members of the church and, at the peak of his career, is thought to have had as many as 40 assistants in his workshop. Among his most important extant commissions in stone one might cite the monument to the Prince-Bishop Rudolf von Scherenberg (1496-1499, Würzburg Cathedral) and the tomb of Heinrich II and Kunigunde (dedicated in 1513, Bamberg Cathedral). He is also documented to have executed numerous works, principally altarpieces, in wood, both painted and unpainted, but many of these were destroyed or dispersed during the religious and political upheavals of the first half of the 16th century. Perhaps the most important of the surviving works in wood is the Holy Blood Altarpiece (1501-1505, Jakobskirche, Rothenburg; for images see Chapuis,1999, pp. 30-31), the central scene of which depicts the Last Supper, at which Christ refers to the wine as the ‘new covenant in my blood’. Despite being a wealthy and respected burgher, Riemenschneider found himself on the losing side of the Peasants’ Revolt of 1525. As a result, he was imprisoned and possibly tortured. He did not produce any significant works thereafter and died in 1531 in Würzburg where he was buried in the cathedral cemetery.
The original location of the present figure of Saint Catherine is unknown, but it was almost certainly a flanking figure to a central group in a carved wood altarpiece. Unknown to scholars until its sale from the collection of Georg Schuster, Munich, in 1927, it had only once been exhibited, in Hanover in 1931, before its appearance in the exhibition devoted to the artist in 1999 in Washington, Tilman Riemenschneider: Master Sculptor of the Late Middle Ages. When it was sold from the Schuster collection, it was paired with another female saint by Riemenschneider whose identity remains uncertain because she has lost her attributes. The two saints were purchased together and descended within the same family. The other saint was sold at auction (Sotheby’s, New York, 22 May 2001, lot 32) and was acquired by the Peter Moores Foundation at Compton Verney for $2,970,000. Due to their size, technical similarities and a distinctive slot in the reverse of each which is thought to have facilitated attachment to the original altarpiece, the two figures are generally agreed to have come from the same, unidentified, commission. A third figure of Saint Elizabeth of Hungary, in the Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Nuremberg, although polychromed, has also been linked to the same altarpiece. Julien Chapuis has suggested that the three figures were originally a group of four, and were part of an altarpiece similar in arrangement to Michel Erhart’s Blaubeuren Altarpiece. Based on various compositional features, he proposes that Saint Catherine stood to the right of the central figure or group, and on the left stood Saint Elizabeth flanked by the female saint from Compton Verney (Chapuis, 1999, p. 331).
A detailed analysis of the surface carving of the present figure and the unidentified female saint by Michele Marincola suggests that the figures were originally intended to be unpainted, although enhanced with subtle glazes. This was confirmed by a second analysis by Wibke Ottweiler in 2025. Marincola identifies nine different tool types and argues convincingly that the delicacy of the carving and punching would have been obscured by the application of a ground and different paint layers, as is the case in the Saint Elizabeth. It is thought that all three figures were given a polychrome surface, possibly as early as the late 16th century, but that the Saint Catherine and unidentified saint were then returned to their original surface, probably in the 19th century. Riemenschneider was among the earliest German wood sculptors to have produced "unpolychromed" figures and groups.
The three saints discussed above are thought to have been executed over a number of years, with the present lot considered to be the earliest. Riemenschneider is known to have often taken a considerable amount of time to execute some of his commissions, and on stylistic grounds it is thought that this altarpiece may have taken 10 to 15 years to complete. In his entry on the three figures, Chapuis argues that the "volumetric treatment of form and angular drapery patterns" of the Saint Catherine are typical of the artist’s work from around 1505, comparing it to the Virgin from a Virgin and Child group dated to circa 1503-1505 in the Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, Hamburg (see Chapuis, 1999, no. 28, pp. 271-274).
Saint Catherine of Alexandria has long been venerated as a model of courage, strength and wisdom. In the Christian tradition, the fourth-century saint was martyred for her condemnation of pagan idolatry and refusal to break her vow of chastity. By the tenth century, she had begun to be venerated in the Eastern Orthodox Church, and the spread of her cult led to her increasing popularity and fame during the Middle Ages. In visual culture, she is typically identified by a number of attributes, including a crown, a wheel, the proposed means of her torture, a sword, a book and a martyr’s palm. The missing hand of the present sculpture may originally have held a sword, while a wheel may have been positioned at the saint’s feet, as in Martin Schongauer’s engraving of Saint Catherine of circa 1480-1490 (National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC, inv. no. 1943.3.69). Riemenschneider was intimately familiar with Schongauer’s work, which greatly informed his own artistic practice; while some of his compositions directly adopted Schongauer’s graphic models, others reinterpreted and developed them more freely (Chapuis, 1999, pp. 62–63).
The reappearance of the present figure of Saint Catherine at auction represents a rare opportunity for collectors of sculpture from any era. Not only is it a recognized masterpiece by one of the most important sculptors of the late Middle Ages, but its contained emotional intensity and the almost modern abstraction evident in the folds of drapery mean that it transcends both place and period.
.jpg?w=1)
