ROBERT RYMAN (1930-2019)
ROBERT RYMAN (1930-2019)
ROBERT RYMAN (1930-2019)
3 More
ROBERT RYMAN (1930-2019)

Untitled

Details
ROBERT RYMAN (1930-2019)
Untitled
signed and dated 'RRyman 60' (center left)
oil and gesso on canvas
59 ½ x 59 ½ in. (151.1 x 151.1 cm.)
Painted in 1960
Provenance
John Weber Gallery, New York (on consignment from the artist, 1973).
Reinhard Onnasch Galerie, Cologne (acquired from the above).
Ausstellungen bei Konrad Fischer, Düsseldorf (on consignment from the above).
Geertjan Visser, Belgium (acquired from the above, 1975).
Anon. sale, Christie's, New York, 7 May 1997, lot 20.
Acquired at the above sale by the present owner.
Literature
J. Harten, ed., Prospect/Retrospect: Europa, 1946-1976, exh. cat., Cologne, Buchhandlung Walther Köenig, 1976, p. 162 (installation view illustrated).
Op het tweede gezicht: Robert Ryman, Amsterdam, 1982, p. 94 (installation view illustrated).
R. Storr, Robert Ryman, exh. cat., London, Tate Gallery, p. 218 (installation views illustrated).
R. Storr, Robert Ryman, exh. cat., Madrid, Museo Nacional Centro de Arte Reina Sofía, 1993, p. 238 (installation view illustrated).
R. Polsky, Art Market Guide: Contemporary American Art, San Francisco, 1998, p. 126.
A. van der Bruggen, De receptie van Robert Ryman in Nederland, Master's thesis, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, 2004, p. 49.
R. Schenk, US in NL: Amerikaanse kunst in Nederlandse musea, Utretcht, 2004, p. 72 (installation view illustrated).
S.P. Hudson, Robert Ryman: Used Paint, Cambridge, 2009, p. 16 (installation view illustrated).
E. Gordon, Robert Ryman: Early and Late, New York, 2024, p. 12 (installation view illustrated).
Exhibited
New York, John Weber Gallery, Robert Ryman: Early Paintings, April 1972.
Amsterdam, Stedelijk Museum, Robert Ryman, February-March 1974, p. 43, no. 9.
Otterlo, Kröller-Müller Museum, 1975-1997 (on extended loan).
Otterlo, Rijksmuseum Kröller-Müller, "Una giornata al mare"/ Een dagje aan zee: een keuze uit de verzameling van Geertjan Visser, June-November 1992, n.p., no. 67 (illustrated upside down).
Further Details
This work will be listed as catalogue number 1960.018 in the forthcoming catalogue raisonné project being organized by David Gray.

Brought to you by

Paige Kestenman
Paige Kestenman Vice President, Senior Specialist, Co-Head of 20th Century Evening Sale

Lot Essay

“Ryman’s work is the single best argument against the notion that painting can be wholly replaced by pictures in photomechanical media.” -- Robert Storr
Painted in 1960, a critical year in Robert Ryman’s career, Untitled is one of only a handful of early paintings executed at what was then the artist’s largest scale. Here, Ryman’s rhythmic, dynamic brushstrokes dance across a nearly monochromatic canvas, pushing and pulling paint across the surface as he intently investigated the possibilities of his medium. While predominantly in the artist’s signature whites, Ryman allows glimmers of his exuberant underpainting to insinuate out from the painting’s richly worked peaks, disclosing a rich tapestry of color. Untitled revels in Ryman’s newfound mastery of his materials and announces his decades-long painterly project, which would propel painting towards new frontiers. Emerging out from the shadow of the Abstract Expressionists in the late 1950s, Ryman faced down the predominant assumption of the time that abstraction and even painting as an art form had been exhausted. “I never thought that painting was dead,” Ryman remarked, “and I think that there are a great many possibilities for painting. I think that painting is in its beginning, particularly the realism” (“On Painting,” in Robert Ryman, exh. cat., Renn Espace d’art contemporain, Paris, 1991, p. 67). Finely attuned to the preceding generation as well as to the materiality of his paints and supports, Ryman devised a radical new approach to painting which regenerated contemporary art, establishing avenues which artists continue to explore and expand to this day. The present work inaugurates Ryman’s Realist mode, exemplifying his stylistic maturity and demonstrating one of his first investigations into the possibilities of scale and space. Robert Storr, the esteemed curator and art historian, writes that “Ryman’s work is the single best argument against the notion that painting can be wholly replaced by pictures in photomechanical media” (“In the American Grain,” in S. Goban and C.J. Martin, eds., Robert Ryman, Dia Art Foundation, New York, 2017, p. 23). Untitled represents one of Ryman’s first and most potent essays buttressing this profound defense of painting.
Spanning nearly sixty inches square, Untitled propels Ryman’s measured majesty into new dimensions. Ryman here examines the effects of asymmetry: he leaves the leftmost area of his cream prepared surface visible, establishing a poignant contrast with his cresting waves of white strokes which alight across the rest of the canvas. Always insistent that his paintings were not monochromes, Ryman here varies the whites he uses, juxtaposing warm and cool tones to emphasize depth and contrast. Keeping white as his predominant color allows the artist to heighten the visibility of the other elements of his work—the viscosity of his oils, the interactions between precisely placed strokes, the crenulated deposits of paint establishing a brilliant impasto, all made more visible via his austere palette.
The present work is an important example of Ryman’s early experiments with color. “Far from being a monochrome painter,” Storr reminds us, “Ryman in the early years almost always fleshed out his paintings over a polychrome bed of terracotta browns, blood reds, golden ochres, putty-like Naples yellows, deep leafy or acidic greens… Ryman’s palette encompassed a modified but full spectrum of primaries” (ibid., pp. 20-21). Here, submerged colors embedded within Ryman’s methodical underpainting flash out from below Ryman’s white field. Brilliant violets (exceedingly rare in Ryman’s oeuvre), rich ochres, verdant greens, and sumptuous lapis lazuli irradiate the painting like glimpses of gems, each color a revelation into a subterranean world alight with color. Describing his technique, Ryman elucidates how “as I worked and developed the painting, I found that I was eliminating a lot. I would put the color down, then paint over the color, trying to get down to a few crucial elements. It was like erasing something to put white over it” (quoted in ibid., p. 16). The overall effect is mesmeric: “Where these substrata are most pronounced,” Storr explains, “the welts of underpainting exert pressure on their white mantle such that one begins to feel the temperature of the buried color like a pulse or sinuous movement beneath the skin” (ibid., p. 21). In its subtle polychromy, Untitled reveals Ryman’s radical project to reinvigorate Realist painting.
“I looked at everything and got something from everything.” -- Robert Ryman
Rejecting the notion of abstraction, Ryman defined himself foremost as a Realist painter. “With realism there is no picture. The aesthetic is an outward aesthetic instead of an inward aesthetic, and since there is no picture, there is no story. And there is no myth. And, there is no illusion, above all. So lines are real, and the space is real, the surface is real and there is an interaction between the painting and the wall plane, unlike with abstraction and representation” (R. Ryman, “On Painting,” op. cit., p. 59). Ryman had first come to New York in 1952 to develop his natural skill as a jazz musician, and its rhythmic, improvisational beat made its way into Ryman’s painterly practice. He began painting in the wake of Abstract Expressionism, and Ryman developed his singular painterly aesthetic at the Museum of Modern Art, where he took a job as a security guard. Admiring the many masterpieces by Matisse, Cezanne, and Picasso, he embraced the gauntlet of modern art: “I looked at everything and got something from everything” (quoted in R. Storr, op. cit., p. 12). While working at the museum, Ryman developed friendships with Lucy Lippard, the curator whom he would later marry, as well as Dan Flavin and Sol LeWitt. Most influential was his chance meeting with Mark Rothko in the museum’s cafeteria in 1957—the older artist’s all-over and all-around canvases were seminal to Ryman’s development. “Bob [Ryman] was mad for Rothko’s work,” Lippard later recalled, and became intently focused on advancing his way of having a composition open out into the space of the onlooker (quoted in S. P. Hudson, Robert Ryman: Used Paint, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 2009, p. 87). Ryman quit his job at MoMA in May 1960, the year the present work was made, announcing the commencement of his fully fledged artistic career. After learning everything he could from the modern masters, Ryman set off to develop his own highly idiosyncratic practice.
Untitled was first acquired by Geertjan Visser, an important early collector of contemporary art in the Netherlands. Collaborating with his brother Martin Visser, an influential curator, designer, and collector, and his sister-in-law Mia, Geertjan Visser built one of the largest collections of postwar art in Europe. Close friendships with both American and European artists saw the trio collect seminal artworks from Piero Manzoni, Lucio Fontana, Joseph Beuys, Dan Flavin, Donald Judd, Carl Andre, Sol LeWitt, and Ellsworth Kelly. Over six hundred works from this combined collection are now in the collection of the Kröller-Müller Museum in the Netherlands.
Painted just as Ryman achieved artistic maturity, Untitled integrates the many concerns which would define his oeuvre. The work’s ambitious scale and luminous underpainting look forward toward Ryman’s later output while simultaneously demonstrating his careful consideration of Rothko’s emphasis on a direct visual experience. Ryman excised color from his palette after 1962 and gradually favored more symmetrical compositions, making Untitled one of the last to employ both conceits. Foundational to his artistic discovery while simultaneously attaining their own aesthetic brilliance, these two elements mark the present work as one of the most important of Ryman’s early years.

More from 20th Century Evening Sale

View All
View All