HIGH ENERGY PARTICLE PHYSICS – Werner Heisenberg (1901-1976)
HIGH ENERGY PARTICLE PHYSICS – Werner Heisenberg (1901-1976)

Series of 8 autograph letters and one autograph postcard signed ('W. Heisenberg') to Bruno Rossi, Institute of Theoretical Physics, Leipzig, 18 November 1931 - 9 May 1932, with three retained copies of letters by Rossi to Heisenberg, 13 September and 19 November 1930 and n.d.

Details
HIGH ENERGY PARTICLE PHYSICS – Werner Heisenberg (1901-1976)
Series of 8 autograph letters and one autograph postcard signed ('W. Heisenberg') to Bruno Rossi, Institute of Theoretical Physics, Leipzig, 18 November 1931 - 9 May 1932, with three retained copies of letters by Rossi to Heisenberg, 13 September and 19 November 1930 and n.d.
In German. Together approximately 12 pages, 285 x 224mm, and one page, 104 x 148mm, by Heisenberg and 7 pages, various sizes, by Rossi. Custom cloth box. Provenance: Christie's Paris, 11 May 2012; Transfinite collection (bookplate).

On cosmic rays: the birth of high-energy particle physics. The correspondence opens with a deferential request for Rossi (whose specialist field it was) to review some calculations Heisenberg has made on the subject of cosmic radiation. After reading Rossi's comments on his manuscript, Heisenberg comments (12 Dec 1931) that 'As for the accuracy of the formulas, I would not allow for an error greater than a factor of 1.5 in the case of braking at energies below E = 100 mc²; beyond that point, the result could be off by a factor of 2'. He looks forward to reading Rossi's forthcoming paper: 'For I am somewhat unlucky, in that the experiments which I know seem always to agree with the theory, whereas there are manifestly others from which one can draw definitive conclusions against the gamma-ray theory'. He adds a diagram with a suggestion for Rossi's work on measuring cosmic rays through three Geiger counters separated by blocks of lead. He continues on 20 December 'I now understand very well the difficulties that stand in the way of the gamma-ray hypothesis, and I intend to reflect further on the overall connections. It was already quite clear to me that your application of the Bothe-Kohlhörster experiment (a 4% difference) could still be very well explained by electrons alone (without gamma rays)'. Having discussed the question at length with Niels Bohr over the Christmas holidays he resumes on 9 January 1932: 'We are firmly convinced that either the radiation is "corpuscular" (i.e., electrons), and Störmer’s theory fails for some reason, or that the primary radiation is absorbed much more rapidly than would be expected according to any reasonable theory. The Klein-Nishina formula would have to be wrong by a factor of about 10'. On 10 February he looks forward excitedly to learning 'what you will determine about the angular distribution of the secondary particles ... I have now compiled a more extensive paper on everything that theory has to say regarding the problem of cosmic rays' [published as Theoretical reflections on cosmic rays]. On 4 March he observes 'I shall shortly have the opportunity to talk to Bohr again about ultra-radiation and hope then to understand it a bit better'; he is doubtful of the results achieved by Rossi's colleague on angular dependence. On 21 March Heisenberg writes with a question on Rossi's recent research on 'the triple coincidences with 1m of lead absorption', illustrated with a diagram of the experiment in question. In the last letter, he looks forward to reading the experimental results 'from which you have drawn your conclusions regarding frequency and reach', though he cautions him on the distinction between 'real' or 'effective' range: 'For transition effects, the focus is usually on the effective range ... which is strongly influenced by scattering'.

The chief architect of quantum mechanics, Heisenberg's interest in cosmic radiation was motivated by developments in relativistic quantum theory, in particular the apparent infinite self-energy of the electron, and the prediction of the electron’s antimatter correlate, the positron ('positive electron'). He anticipated that the study of high-energy cosmic radiation could materially aid the resolution of these anomalies, and further answer other open questions relating to quantum theory. Heisenberg's 1932 paper 'Theoretical reflections on cosmic rays', referred to here, was a critical assessment of the challenge to early quantum electrodynamics posed by the cosmic ray experiments, and foreshadowed shower theory and thus the birth of particle physics. Rossi’s cosmic ray experiments, which Heisenberg discusses in real time, were the first systematic detection of particle showers, and the ‘electronic coincident circuit’ which Rossi invented and first used in these experiments – and which Heisenberg discusses and illustrates in these letters – was instrumental in confirming the existence of the positron in August 1932.

As these letters show, Heisenberg had a particular interest in determining whether the experimental tracks of cosmic rays were caused by known particles – specifically gamma particles or electrons – obeying unknown high-energy laws. Though he was unable to determine the exact nature of the ‘hard component’ of cosmic rays from this series of experiments, the further study of ‘particle showers’ led to the discovery of the muon in 1936, the nature of which Heisenberg explained in 1938 (in his paper 'Theoretical viewpoints for the interpretation of cosmic radiation'). The discovery of the muon, and Heisenberg’s explanation of its nature, shattered the simple picture of the subatomic world and sparked the discovery of a veritable 'zoo' of previously unknown particles – ultimately forcing physicists in 1961 into a formal organisation of the structure of matter in a framework playfully called the 'Eightfold Way'. Heisenberg himself continued to work with cosmic radiation and particle theory through the 1940s, leading to his 1943 development of 'scattering matrix theory', which was instrumental in the development of both quark theory and string theory.

The Italian physicist Bruno Rossi (1905-1993) was one of the pioneers in the study of cosmic rays. and worked with Walther Bothe in Berlin on cosmic ray penetration in summer 1930, when he was the first to observe that cosmic ray intensity west to east differed from that in the opposite direction, and suggesting that the rays were charged particles. Rossi left Italy after being dismissed from his professorship under anti-Jewish laws in 1938: in the following year he moved to the United States, where he took part in the Manhattan Project before eventually settling at MIT.

A substantial correspondence relating to a major scientific breakthrough, catching Heisenberg at the height of his powers and in the year for which he was awarded the Nobel Prize, 'for the creation of quantum physics'. The most substantial Heisenberg correspondence to have appeared at auction.

Offerto da

Mark Wiltshire
Mark Wiltshire Specialist

Altri da Valuable Books and Manuscripts

View All
View All