Lot Essay
This gilt-copper figure depicts Shakyamuni crowned and bejewelled, seated in vajraparyankasana with his right hand extended in bhumisparsha mudra, the gesture that records his triumph over the assaults of Mara. Crowned images present the Buddha not simply as a historical teacher but in an exalted, celestial form, his regalia proclaiming the transcendent authority of Buddhahood. Early Vajrayana traditions associated the imagery with Shakyamuni following his enlightenment and his celestial consecration by other Buddhas. It has also been understood as a dual manifestation of Vairocana, the cosmic Buddha, and Shakyamuni, his earthly emanation (K. Behrendt, "Tibet and India: Buddhist Traditions and Transformations," The Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin, vol. 71, no. 3, Winter 2014, p. 18).
The Buddha wears a monastic habit made from scraps of cloth sewn together, among the few possessions a mendicant may own. Here the patchwork is rendered as a grid of rectangular fields outlined in beaded seams across the chest, shoulder and back. The sumptuous crown, though seemingly anomalous beside such simplicity, represents his regal supremacy over the phenomenal world (J. Van Alphen et al., Cast for Eternity: Bronze Masterworks from India and the Himalayas in Belgian and Dutch Collections, 2003, p. 191, no. 62). The tradition of depicting the Buddha in patchwork robes originated in India and appears in eastern Indian medieval manuscripts (J. Casey, N. P. Ahuja and D. Weldon, Divine Presence, 2003, no. 44, p. 141).
The closest comparison is the silver Buddha formerly in the Ellsworth collection (ibid.). Both figures wear the patchwork robe with an incised hem, here with a rhizome pattern, and with seams articulated in beading. The robe folds over the body in an identical manner, the patchwork pattern is oriented along the same cross-sections, and the fishtail pleats and fanned end of the robes are similarly articulated. The crowns correspond closely: five gem-set leaves of nearly equal size rise from a beaded headband, with rosettes above the ears and long ribbons falling to the shoulders, each ending in a jeweled pendant. The jewelry is similarly conceived, with turquoise and colored glass set in settings, a technique characteristic of Nepalese craftsmen. A turquoise marks the urna on the present figure.
Previous scholarship has firmly linked the iconography of this figure to the Jowo Rinpoche, the principal icon of the Jokhang temple in Lhasa and the most venerated image in Tibet. The association was first proposed by T. T. Thingo in 1989 (Essen and Thingo, 1989, I-1, p. 24). It is repeated for the silver Buddha, which is dated to the 13th century (Casey, 2003, no. 44, p. 141), and for the present figure, which is dated to the 13th/14th century (Cast for Eternity, no. 62). The consistency of the crown across these images suggests that they record the distinctive appearance of the Jowo, said to be the statue brought to Tibet in the seventh century. Photographs of the current Jowo, however, show it to be a much later statue, and the whereabouts of the original are unknown (U. von Schroeder, 2001, pls. 215A-C, pp. 926-29). Any direct claim of derivation is therefore difficult to sustain, yet the iconographic relationship between the two is clear.
Alternatively, Jean-Luc Estournel associates the silver Buddha (fig. 365) with a group of crowned Buddhas related to Densatil Monastery (Jean-Luc Estournel, "About the 18 stupas and other treasures once at the Densatil monastery," AsianArt.com, 2020, figs. 361-365). He dates all of them to the second half of the 14th century, aside from fig. 364, to which he gives a 15th-century date. All show an intense degree of Nepalese influence, especially figs. 362 and 363, the latter of which sold at Christie's, New York, 13 September 2017, lot 620. The present figure shows less pronounced Nepalese features. The body is narrower, the robe lacks a double hem, and the pleating of the fishtail is less tightly arranged, with fewer pleats. It nevertheless follows the same pattern of crown type, jewelry and sashes, although the ushnisha is taller in the present example. As scholarship on this group varies, it is difficult to say with certainty where exactly the sculpture was made. Yet whether it is linked to the Jokhang or to Densatil, both strands of scholarship point to Central Tibet and to a date within or around the 14th century.
The Buddha wears a monastic habit made from scraps of cloth sewn together, among the few possessions a mendicant may own. Here the patchwork is rendered as a grid of rectangular fields outlined in beaded seams across the chest, shoulder and back. The sumptuous crown, though seemingly anomalous beside such simplicity, represents his regal supremacy over the phenomenal world (J. Van Alphen et al., Cast for Eternity: Bronze Masterworks from India and the Himalayas in Belgian and Dutch Collections, 2003, p. 191, no. 62). The tradition of depicting the Buddha in patchwork robes originated in India and appears in eastern Indian medieval manuscripts (J. Casey, N. P. Ahuja and D. Weldon, Divine Presence, 2003, no. 44, p. 141).
The closest comparison is the silver Buddha formerly in the Ellsworth collection (ibid.). Both figures wear the patchwork robe with an incised hem, here with a rhizome pattern, and with seams articulated in beading. The robe folds over the body in an identical manner, the patchwork pattern is oriented along the same cross-sections, and the fishtail pleats and fanned end of the robes are similarly articulated. The crowns correspond closely: five gem-set leaves of nearly equal size rise from a beaded headband, with rosettes above the ears and long ribbons falling to the shoulders, each ending in a jeweled pendant. The jewelry is similarly conceived, with turquoise and colored glass set in settings, a technique characteristic of Nepalese craftsmen. A turquoise marks the urna on the present figure.
Previous scholarship has firmly linked the iconography of this figure to the Jowo Rinpoche, the principal icon of the Jokhang temple in Lhasa and the most venerated image in Tibet. The association was first proposed by T. T. Thingo in 1989 (Essen and Thingo, 1989, I-1, p. 24). It is repeated for the silver Buddha, which is dated to the 13th century (Casey, 2003, no. 44, p. 141), and for the present figure, which is dated to the 13th/14th century (Cast for Eternity, no. 62). The consistency of the crown across these images suggests that they record the distinctive appearance of the Jowo, said to be the statue brought to Tibet in the seventh century. Photographs of the current Jowo, however, show it to be a much later statue, and the whereabouts of the original are unknown (U. von Schroeder, 2001, pls. 215A-C, pp. 926-29). Any direct claim of derivation is therefore difficult to sustain, yet the iconographic relationship between the two is clear.
Alternatively, Jean-Luc Estournel associates the silver Buddha (fig. 365) with a group of crowned Buddhas related to Densatil Monastery (Jean-Luc Estournel, "About the 18 stupas and other treasures once at the Densatil monastery," AsianArt.com, 2020, figs. 361-365). He dates all of them to the second half of the 14th century, aside from fig. 364, to which he gives a 15th-century date. All show an intense degree of Nepalese influence, especially figs. 362 and 363, the latter of which sold at Christie's, New York, 13 September 2017, lot 620. The present figure shows less pronounced Nepalese features. The body is narrower, the robe lacks a double hem, and the pleating of the fishtail is less tightly arranged, with fewer pleats. It nevertheless follows the same pattern of crown type, jewelry and sashes, although the ushnisha is taller in the present example. As scholarship on this group varies, it is difficult to say with certainty where exactly the sculpture was made. Yet whether it is linked to the Jokhang or to Densatil, both strands of scholarship point to Central Tibet and to a date within or around the 14th century.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
