Lot Essay
A striking and highly unusual feature of this thangka is its presentation of two wrathful manifestations of Vajrapani side by side within a single composition. Wrathful deities commonly appear with attendants or within tantric mandalas, but the pairing of two distinct forms of Vajrapani as co-equal focal images is rare, emphasizing both their shared identity and their differing manifestations of enlightened power. At right, Krodha Vajrapani appears in a relatively conventional wrathful aspect. His black body is offset by a brilliant red aureole of flames and enlivened with bone ornaments, red coral jewelry, serpents draped across his chest, and a finely rendered tiger skin trimmed with green pleated hems lined in red. He lunges in alidhasana posture, raising a vajra in his right hand while holding a bell in his left. In posture, attributes and serpent adornments, he conforms closely to the standard iconography of Krodha Vajrapani.
The figure at left presents a more enigmatic image. Identifiable as a yab-yum form related to Mahachakra Vajrapani, he retains characteristic features including the vajra, serpents issuing from the mouth, and an animal skin draped across the shoulders. Yet there are significant deviations from the established iconography. Most strikingly, the deity has wings and four legs, features rarely associated with Mahachakra Vajrapani. These characteristics suggest a distinct interpretation, perhaps linked to a Nyingma context.
The broader iconographic program supports this attribution. The upper register includes Samantabhadra, Vajradhara, Vajrasattva, and a figure likely representing Padmasambhava in his pandita form. A further assembly of winged yab-yum deities recalls the Nyingma cycle of the Eight Great Herukas (bka' chen brgyad), whose male forms characteristically bear wings. In the lower register, the protective deities Mahakala, Palden Lhamo and Black Jambhala accompany a whiskered lama performing a consecration ritual before the donors. The donors are noteworthy: the man wears the robes of an aristocratic layman and sits on a bolster, while the woman, dressed in a white robe with red decoration, offers a gilded ritual object. Similar costumes of western Tibet and northwestern Nepal appear in fourteenth-century manuscript illuminations from Dolpo (A. Heller, "Terma of Dolpo: The Secret Library of Pijor," Orientations, December 2001, pp. 64-71).
The painting shows a visual language shared between the Western Himalayas and Central Tibet. Beyond the Dolpo costumes of the donors, the chocolate-brown border framing the edges points to a West Tibetan origin. The same border appears on a fourteenth-century Chakrasamvara painting sold at Bonhams, Hong Kong, 1 December 2023, lot 1843, and on a painting of a Kagyu lama sold at Bonhams, Paris, 10 December 2024, lot 84. The figures and ornament, however, correspond closely to Central Tibetan models. The pointed, scrolling ends of the fiery mandorla and the multicolored, curlicue-tipped lotus petals are popular features of fourteenth- and fifteenth-century painting in Central Tibet, as seen in the murals of the Gyantse Kumbum (HAR 42944) and Shalu Monastery (HAR 51510). Later fifteenth-century Panjarnata Mahakala thangkas provide further points of comparison, including one in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (M.82.6.4; HAR 85733), three in the Rubin Museum of Art (HAR 82, 135 and 65030), and another in the Robert L. Poster Collection (P. Pal, Himalayas: An Aesthetic Adventure, Chicago, 2003, p. 244, no. 160). Compare also a fifteenth-century Panjarnata Mahakala thangka sold at Bonhams, Hong Kong, 5 October 2020, lot 113.
(We are grateful to Amy Heller for sharing her research on this thangka.)
The figure at left presents a more enigmatic image. Identifiable as a yab-yum form related to Mahachakra Vajrapani, he retains characteristic features including the vajra, serpents issuing from the mouth, and an animal skin draped across the shoulders. Yet there are significant deviations from the established iconography. Most strikingly, the deity has wings and four legs, features rarely associated with Mahachakra Vajrapani. These characteristics suggest a distinct interpretation, perhaps linked to a Nyingma context.
The broader iconographic program supports this attribution. The upper register includes Samantabhadra, Vajradhara, Vajrasattva, and a figure likely representing Padmasambhava in his pandita form. A further assembly of winged yab-yum deities recalls the Nyingma cycle of the Eight Great Herukas (bka' chen brgyad), whose male forms characteristically bear wings. In the lower register, the protective deities Mahakala, Palden Lhamo and Black Jambhala accompany a whiskered lama performing a consecration ritual before the donors. The donors are noteworthy: the man wears the robes of an aristocratic layman and sits on a bolster, while the woman, dressed in a white robe with red decoration, offers a gilded ritual object. Similar costumes of western Tibet and northwestern Nepal appear in fourteenth-century manuscript illuminations from Dolpo (A. Heller, "Terma of Dolpo: The Secret Library of Pijor," Orientations, December 2001, pp. 64-71).
The painting shows a visual language shared between the Western Himalayas and Central Tibet. Beyond the Dolpo costumes of the donors, the chocolate-brown border framing the edges points to a West Tibetan origin. The same border appears on a fourteenth-century Chakrasamvara painting sold at Bonhams, Hong Kong, 1 December 2023, lot 1843, and on a painting of a Kagyu lama sold at Bonhams, Paris, 10 December 2024, lot 84. The figures and ornament, however, correspond closely to Central Tibetan models. The pointed, scrolling ends of the fiery mandorla and the multicolored, curlicue-tipped lotus petals are popular features of fourteenth- and fifteenth-century painting in Central Tibet, as seen in the murals of the Gyantse Kumbum (HAR 42944) and Shalu Monastery (HAR 51510). Later fifteenth-century Panjarnata Mahakala thangkas provide further points of comparison, including one in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (M.82.6.4; HAR 85733), three in the Rubin Museum of Art (HAR 82, 135 and 65030), and another in the Robert L. Poster Collection (P. Pal, Himalayas: An Aesthetic Adventure, Chicago, 2003, p. 244, no. 160). Compare also a fifteenth-century Panjarnata Mahakala thangka sold at Bonhams, Hong Kong, 5 October 2020, lot 113.
(We are grateful to Amy Heller for sharing her research on this thangka.)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
