The Sins of the Cities of the Plain: the sole surviving copy
The Sins of the Cities of the Plain: the sole surviving copy
The Sins of the Cities of the Plain: the sole surviving copy
The Sins of the Cities of the Plain: the sole surviving copy
3 More
From a Private English Collection
The Sins of the Cities of the Plain: the sole surviving copy

[Anonymous]

Details
The Sins of the Cities of the Plain: the sole surviving copy
[Anonymous]
The Sins of the Cities of the Plain; or, The Recollections of a Mary-Ann. With Short Essays on Sodomy and Tribadism. London: Leicester Square [William Lazenby], 1881.

The newly discovered sole surviving copy of the true first edition of a foundational work of homosexual literature. Apparently limited to a print run of just 50 copies, all of which were previously thought lost.

12mo (168 x 105mm). Cancel title as per Ashbee, limitation leaf, text pp.[3]-95 (some spotting). Early 20th-century green half morocco, marbled paper sides, spine lettered and stamped in gilt.

Brought to you by

Thais Hitchins
Thais Hitchins Associate Specialist

Lot Essay

Henry Spencer Ashbee listed the work in his privately printed 1885 bibliography of erotic literature, Catena Librorum Tacendorum, but until the emergence of the present copy from an English private collection, all copies were believed to be lost. Recent scholarship distinguishes this true first edition from a later reprint with the fictitious place and date of publication ‘London: Privately Printed, 1881’, which is actually believed to have been printed in Paris around 1891. The reprint itself is exceptionally rare, with only the British Library copy known to survive. In 2021 it was reported to be the most frequently requested erotic work in the British Library. The present title-page instead gives ‘London: Leicester Square, 1881’, the district in which the clandestine publisher William Lazenby operated, and states the exceptionally high price of four guineas. These details, according to Ashbee’s contemporary account, identify this as the true first edition.

The novel opens in Leicester Square, where an unnamed gentleman encounters a young male prostitute who calls himself Jack Saul. The gentleman takes Saul to his rooms near Baker Street and, fascinated by his appearance and manner of life, pays him to relate his history. Saul’s ensuing recollections move from early sexual encounters and schoolboy experiences into the streets, hotels and private rooms of late-Victorian London. Combining confession, pornography and social observation, the book constructs a detailed narrative of prostitution, cross-dressing and desire between men across divisions of age and class.

The character was based, at least in part, upon the historical John ‘Jack’ Saul, an Irish-born male prostitute later involved in the Dublin Castle investigation of 1884 and called as a witness during the Cleveland Street scandal of 1889. Published four years before the Labouchere Amendment of 1885 extended the criminal law against sexual relations between men, The Sins of the Cities of the Plain presents a queer London that is both precarious and highly organised. The work maps a distinct and recognisable homosexual subculture: its protagonists navigate a network of familiar streets, houses, signals and codes; prostitution forges connections across social boundaries; and individuals usually observed, judged, or criminalised from without are instead given voice through an extended first-person narrative. The Parisian bookseller Charles Hirsch claimed that The Sins of the Cities of the Plain was among the ‘Socratic’ books he supplied to Oscar Wilde in 1890.

Ashbee, H. S. Catena librorum tacendorum, pp.194-195; Colligan, C. Nineteenth-Century British Pornography: Sources and Materials: Volume III: Pornographic Literature and the Underground Book Trade, 1880s-1910s (2026); Ingleheart, J. ‘High Culture in Low Company? The Reception of Ancient 'Homosexuality' in the Pornographic “The Sins of the Cities of the Plain”’. In E. Richardson (Ed.), Classics in Extremis: The Edges of Classical Reception, pp. 88-100 (2019); Mendes, P. Clandestine Erotic Fiction in English, 1800–1930, cf. 60-A (Paris reprint).

More from Love and Lust: A Literary Guide

View All
View All