BARTHOLOMEUS SPRANGER (ANTWERP 1546-1611 PRAGUE)
BARTHOLOMEUS SPRANGER (ANTWERP 1546-1611 PRAGUE)
1 More
BARTHOLOMEUS SPRANGER (ANTWERP 1546-1611 PRAGUE)

Witches’ Sabbath

Details
BARTHOLOMEUS SPRANGER (ANTWERP 1546-1611 PRAGUE)
Witches’ Sabbath
signed with initials and dated ‘B·S / 1576’ (lower right)
oil on panel, unframed
13 7⁄8 x 9 1⁄8 in. (35.7 x 23.1 cm.)
Provenance
(Possibly) with Galerie L. T. Neumann, Vienna (according to a photo in the Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, Vienna; see Metzler, op. cit.).
Mrs. Eugenie Pollach (c. 1902⁄3-1995), Salzburg, part of the family’s long-standing private collection, by whom gifted to the present owner in the 1990s.
Literature
S. Metzler, Bartholomeus Spranger: Splendour and Eroticism in Imperial Prague: The Complete Works, New Haven and London, 2014, pp. 18, 25 and 68-9, no. 1.

Brought to you by

Lucy Speelman
Lucy Speelman Associate Specialist, Head of Day Sale

Lot Essay

Among the most intriguing inventions of Bartholomeus Spranger’s early career, this remarkable Witches’ Sabbath, signed and dated 1576, represents a return to the subject that had first brought the young Flemish painter to prominence in Rome almost a decade earlier. Conceived at a pivotal moment in his artistic development, shortly after his arrival at the imperial court in Vienna following nearly ten years in Italy, the painting unites the fantastical traditions of his Netherlandish upbringing with the architectural and pictorial sophistication he had acquired south of the Alps.

Within a vast, ruined edifice, where the remnants of antiquity give way to shadowy grottoes and subterranean chambers, Spranger has assembled an extraordinary succession of supernatural rites, illuminated by flickering fires and an eerie light penetrating the darkened sky. The rare survival of a treatment of a subject otherwise known chiefly through the testimony of his contemporary biographer Karel van Mander offers a revealing insight into an aspect of Spranger’s imagination seldom encountered in his extant oeuvre, before the emergence of the celebrated mythological and allegorical compositions that would establish his reputation as one of the defining painters of European Mannerism.

The subject held a particular significance for Spranger. In his Schilder-Boeck of 1604, Karel van Mander, who knew the artist personally, recounted how, shortly after arriving in Rome in 1566, Spranger painted a small scene of sorcery set among ruins resembling the Colosseum, with women flying on broomsticks and other nocturnal apparitions (K. van Mander, Het Schilder-Boeck, Haarlem, 1604, fol. 270v). Originally intended for the banker Joan Spindolo, the painting was instead acquired by the celebrated miniaturist Giulio Clovio, who showed it to Cardinal Alessandro Farnese. So delighted was the cardinal that he sought the young painter’s acquaintance, subsequently welcoming him into his household. Spindolo, meanwhile, regretted having relinquished the painting, and Spranger executed another, which van Mander reports was even better than the first. Thus, an apparently modest exercise in fantastical invention transformed Spranger’s prospects in Rome (Metzler, op. cit., pp. 24-6 and 68-9).

Spranger’s familiarity with such subjects had its roots in Antwerp, where he first trained under Jan Mandyn, a painter whose work drew heavily upon the visionary world of Hieronymus Bosch, and subsequently Cornelis van Dalem, whose landscapes were distinguished by their sombre colouring and atmospheric depth (ibid., pp. 18-19). In 1565, Hieronymus Cock issued two engravings after Pieter Bruegel the Elder, Saint James at the Sorcerer’s Den and The Fall of the Magician Hermogenes, bringing together flying witches, cauldrons, magic books and necromancers, and establishing a visual vocabulary upon which generations of Netherlandish painters would draw (R. Vervoort, Bruegel’s Witches, Bruges, 2015, pp. 48-55 and 72-80).

Spranger’s conception is distinguished, however, by the extraordinary prominence given to the setting itself, transforming the ruins of antiquity into a mysterious realm inhabited by witches and supernatural apparitions. Rising through almost the entire height of the panel, the broken arches, massive vaults and crumbling masonry merge imperceptibly with the rock formations beneath them, their architectural forms gradually dissolving into the natural world. At upper left, the remains of an ancient structure descend into a succession of darkened grottoes, while the great central vault opens onto a distant landscape beneath a sky momentarily illuminated through the clouds. At upper right, a witch flies through the darkness, her supernatural passage linking the celestial expanse with the sinister activities concealed below. Rather than bringing his protagonists together in a single crowded gathering, Spranger has distributed them throughout the ruin, drawing the eye from one illuminated recess to another, each revealing a different aspect of the witches’ nocturnal assembly.

In the centre distance, figures dance hand in hand around a fire, enacting the ritual gathering of the sabbath, while further to the right another seemingly tends a cauldron, traditionally associated with the preparation of magical potions and the ointments believed to enable witches to fly (Vervoort, op. cit., 2015, pp. 67 and 97-100). The contrast between the fires illuminating these clandestine rites and the light penetrating the heavens is particularly suggestive, yet the witch traversing the darkened sky suggests that even the natural world has become subject to supernatural forces. Spranger thus leaves the boundary between the two deliberately uncertain, creating an imaginary space in which the ruins of civilisation have become the domain of sorcery, and where the beholder is invited to discover, rather than simply observe, the mysteries concealed within.

In the foreground, the most disturbing rituals take place almost within reach of the beholder. At left, a figure seen from behind consults a book, while another brings a lighted candle to the mouth of a reclining, seemingly lifeless man, in what appears to be an act of necromantic conjuration. Nearby, an elderly woman reads from an open volume, directing a wand against a human skull, a striking evocation of necromantic divination, particularly cephalomancy, in which the dead were believed to answer the questions of the living. Such practices were described in contemporary accounts of sorcery, their instruments familiar from the elaborate rituals of ceremonial magic: as early as 1456, Johannes Hartlieb had described the conjuring of a severed head with candles and incense, through which the dead were believed to speak (G. Tal, Art and Witchcraft in Early Modern Italy, Amsterdam, 2024, pp. 262-3).

At lower right, an old woman, almost entirely naked, bends over a basket with another skull in her hand. Her bald head, emaciated body and pendulous breasts recall the grotesque physiognomies through which early modern artists associated witchcraft with bodily corruption and moral transgression, finding a particularly close parallel in the personification of Heresy, whose withered nakedness symbolised her spiritual depravity (Vervoort, op. cit., 2015, pp. 129-30). Yet Spranger's interest extends beyond these familiar conventions of the grotesque: the unsettling naturalism of the figure, like the mysterious rites unfolding beside her, lends his fantastical invention a disturbing suggestion of reality.

The choice of an antique ruin was particularly appropriate to an artist who had spent the greater part of the preceding decade in Rome. Van Mander’s description of Spranger’s first Witches’ Sabbath specifically evokes the Colosseum, where Benvenuto Cellini famously described participating in a nocturnal ceremony during which a necromancer summoned spirits amidst terrifying apparitions. Spranger himself had explored Nero’s Domus Aurea with van Mander and Hans Mont, leaving their names inscribed upon its walls (Vervoort, op. cit., pp. 99-100; Metzler, op. cit., p. 34). Such experiences offer a particularly suggestive context for the present composition, in which the architecture is neither a faithful record of an identifiable monument nor merely a picturesque backdrop, but an imaginative transformation of the ancient world into a place of concealment and supernatural activity.

The date of 1576 places the picture at another decisive moment in Spranger’s career. Recommended by Giambologna to Maximilian II, he had arrived in Vienna in November 1575, following almost ten years in Italy. His Gathering of the Gods of 1576, a design for the decoration of the Neugebäude, reveals an artist still assimilating his Italian experience while developing a new artistic language. Metzler has aptly characterised this moment as a stylistic crossroads, when Spranger had not yet abandoned the traditions of Italy but was beginning to transform them into a manner of his own (op. cit., pp. 34-40 and 183-85). The present picture, conceived amid these changes, suggests not merely a recollection of his youthful success but a fresh exploration of the imaginative possibilities through which his reputation had first been established.

In returning to the subject of his youthful success, Spranger created a work that is at once a reflection of his artistic inheritance and a testament to the originality of his developing imagination. The ancient ruins, once monuments to the achievements of civilisation, have become the setting for a world governed by uncertainty, where the familiar gives way to the extraordinary and light serves as much to conceal as to reveal. It is through this transformation of the visible world into a realm of supernatural possibility that the present Witches’ Sabbath finds its particular place in Spranger’s oeuvre, preserving an imaginative freedom that would continue to inform his art, even as the grotesque fantasies of his early career gave way to the refined allegories of his maturity.

We are grateful to Dr. Sally Metzler for confirming the attribution on the basis of photographs.

More from Old Masters to Modern Day Sale: Paintings, Drawings, Sculpture

View All
View All