Lot Essay
As its format indicates, this panel is one face of a double-sided portable standard: the counterpart of the Madonna adoring the Child was recorded with it in the Grassi collection in 1917 and in the Dabissi sale in 1924 but cannot now be traced. As Matteo Mazzalupi has observed, the principal figures, including the dove, were clearly inspired by Gentile da Fabriano’s Coronation of the Virgin (circa 1420; J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles), which likewise formed part of a double-sided standard, probably made for a confraternity associated with San Francesco in Fabriano. Banners of the type were favoured in certain towns of the Marche from the early fifteenth century. An early example, datable to the early 1430s, with Saint Francis and the trigram of Saint Bernardino of Siena on the reverse, in the Museo Piersanti at Matelica is attributable to the Master of San Verecondo who worked both in the Marche and at Gualdo and elsewhere to the west. A celebrated example is Signorelli’s standard for the Confraternity of the Raccomandati at Santa Maria del Mercato in Fabriano, depicting the Nursing Madonna and the Flagellation, now in the Pinacoteca di Brera, Milan. Other examples of the type - two double-sided banners in the Pinacoteca Nazionale dell’Umbria, Perugia (nos. 2⁄879 and 110⁄1047 and 111⁄1048), the second of which has been divided, formerly owned respectively by Bernard Berenson and F. Mason Perkins, and a third, the sides of which have been separated, in the Pinacoteca di Brera, Milan (nos. 742 and 750) - were formerly attributed to Francesco di Gentile da Fabriano but have recently been recognised as by Luca di Paolo da Matelica, to whom the majority of the pictures given to Francesco by Berenson in 1913 and subsequently have now been correctly attributed by Andrea De Marchi. Luca di Paolo, as for instance the altarpiece of 1462 formerly at Derby demonstrates, was an adherent of local tradition who responded to the influence of Folignate contemporaries, most notably Niccolò da Foligno who secured numerous commissions on the eastern flank of the Apennines.
Francesco di Gentile, evidently about a generation Luca’s junior, was in some respects the more adventurous artist. This is seen in two of his signed works, the Madonna of the Butterfly in the Pinacoteca Vaticana and a Portrait of a Youth formerly in the Pesenti collection at Bergamo. The former reflects mature works by Giovanni Bellini, while the suspended fruit in the latter imply a knowledge of Crivelli. What is striking is that both the Virgin and the youth look directly at the spectator with the same fixed gaze. Matteo Mazzalupi dates the banner from which this panel comes to the 1490s (private communication, 2 November 2026). He relates the heads of some of the cherubs to Niccolò da Foligno, known as Alunno, and Luca di Paolo. The Madonna from the other side of the banner by contrast suggests that Francesco must have looked at works by Signorelli in Fabriano and perhaps at Loreto.
Banners of the type continued to be painted for towns in the region of Fabriano and Arcevia well into the cinquecento. Mazzalupi points out that one made in 1514–15 by a Hungarian called Albertus for Piticchio, a village near Arcevia, is in a frame similar to that of this panel and its erstwhile companion. The Arcevia-born Ercole Ramazzani painted a small, arched, double-sided banner, dated to 1566, depicting the Madonna and Child in Glory and Saints (51.3 × 27.3 cm.; Christie’s, London, 13 July 1979, lot 191).
We are grateful to Matteo Mazzalupi for endorsing the attribution on the basis of photographs and for kindly providing additional literature.
Francesco di Gentile, evidently about a generation Luca’s junior, was in some respects the more adventurous artist. This is seen in two of his signed works, the Madonna of the Butterfly in the Pinacoteca Vaticana and a Portrait of a Youth formerly in the Pesenti collection at Bergamo. The former reflects mature works by Giovanni Bellini, while the suspended fruit in the latter imply a knowledge of Crivelli. What is striking is that both the Virgin and the youth look directly at the spectator with the same fixed gaze. Matteo Mazzalupi dates the banner from which this panel comes to the 1490s (private communication, 2 November 2026). He relates the heads of some of the cherubs to Niccolò da Foligno, known as Alunno, and Luca di Paolo. The Madonna from the other side of the banner by contrast suggests that Francesco must have looked at works by Signorelli in Fabriano and perhaps at Loreto.
Banners of the type continued to be painted for towns in the region of Fabriano and Arcevia well into the cinquecento. Mazzalupi points out that one made in 1514–15 by a Hungarian called Albertus for Piticchio, a village near Arcevia, is in a frame similar to that of this panel and its erstwhile companion. The Arcevia-born Ercole Ramazzani painted a small, arched, double-sided banner, dated to 1566, depicting the Madonna and Child in Glory and Saints (51.3 × 27.3 cm.; Christie’s, London, 13 July 1979, lot 191).
We are grateful to Matteo Mazzalupi for endorsing the attribution on the basis of photographs and for kindly providing additional literature.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
