Lot Essay
Federico Zeri attributed this Saint Catherine to Bernardino's brother, Francesco da Cotignola (c. 1475-1532), also called Zaganelli, noting the strict adherence to Peruginesque models, such as the Saint Flavia in the Pinacoteca Vaticana. However, Raffaella Zama places it in Bernardino's œuvre, close to the Madonna and Child with Musical Angels in the Galleria Giorgio Franchetti alla Ca' d'Oro, Venice.
The small-scale devotional panel is first recorded in a letter of 19 May 1897, in which the Perugian scholar-cum-dealer, Alessandro Piceller extols its virtues to his friend and colleague, the Florentine art dealer Stefano Bardini. The panel originated from the villa of an unnamed 'Marchesa', home to a prestigious collection from which, according to Piceller, numerous paintings had entered museum collections, causing 'quite a stir' ('ogni pittura uscita da questa famiglia ha fatto rumore nei musei ove è entrata'; Ciancabilla, op. cit., p. 381). From the low-quality photograph Piceller enclosed with his letter, Bardini declined the picture; however, Piceller succeeded in selling the Saint Catherine himself, in Florence, for three thousand lire (ibid., p. 384).
The small-scale devotional panel is first recorded in a letter of 19 May 1897, in which the Perugian scholar-cum-dealer, Alessandro Piceller extols its virtues to his friend and colleague, the Florentine art dealer Stefano Bardini. The panel originated from the villa of an unnamed 'Marchesa', home to a prestigious collection from which, according to Piceller, numerous paintings had entered museum collections, causing 'quite a stir' ('ogni pittura uscita da questa famiglia ha fatto rumore nei musei ove è entrata'; Ciancabilla, op. cit., p. 381). From the low-quality photograph Piceller enclosed with his letter, Bardini declined the picture; however, Piceller succeeded in selling the Saint Catherine himself, in Florence, for three thousand lire (ibid., p. 384).
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
