Lot Essay
This unpublished painting of The Flight into Egypt is a significant addition to the oeuvre of Andrea Vaccaro. Among the most significant Neapolitan artists of his generation, Vaccaro developed a style that combined Caravaggesque naturalism and chiaroscuro with the grace and sensitivity of Bernardo Cavallino. Around 1620, he copied Caravaggio’s Flagellation (Museo e Real Bosco di Capodimonte, Naples), and his copy still remains in situ in the church of San Domenico Maggiore. Vaccaro drew on the classicism of Guido Reni, Anthony van Dyck and Pietro Novelli, while also reflecting the influence of Massimo Stanzione and Artemisia Gentileschi, two of the most successful painters in seventeenth-century Naples. The figure types in this painting, which likely dates to the middle of the century, are characteristic of Vaccaro, especially the Madonna, with her long straight nose and finely arched eyebrows.
Unusually conceived in a vertical format, the Flight into Egypt is a subject more often treated in landscape orientation. Vaccaro has deftly accommodated the figures and donkey within a compact, upright composition. The existence of a variant of inferior quality, formerly in the Dusmet de Smours collection (152 x 125.7 cm.; recorded on the RKD website), suggests that the present format is largely original, though the painting may have been marginally reduced along the lower edge, where there is evidence of historic damage. In addition to the greater fluency in handling evident in the present painting, a key difference between the two variants is the figure of Joseph, who here turns to look out at the viewer rather than towards the Madonna and Child, and is rendered with remarkable naturalism and vitality.
The exceptional tenderness of the Virgin’s expression, as she lowers her eyes to gaze upon the Christ Child while he pauses from nursing, is one of the most naturalistic aspects of the painting. The appeal of this motif is attested by the existence of the two figures as an independent composition, signed by Vaccaro with initials (101.5 x 75 cm.; sale, London, Sotheby’s, 9 December 1987, lot 128), as well as other copies that testify to the popularity of both the subject and design.
The early history of The Flight into Egypt is not known, though its format and scale suggest that it was a private commission. In his Life of Andrea Vaccaro, the eighteenth-century biographer Bernardo de Dominici records a painting of this subject belonging to the Principe di Avellino, though its description is too brief to make a firm identification: ‘In the Prince of Avellino’s Gallery there is a fine painting by Andrea, depicting the Flight into Egypt, which is very well executed’ (‘Vedesi nella Galleria del Principe d’Avellino un bel Quadro d’Andrea, che rappresenta la fuga in Egitto, assai ben dipinto’; B. de Dominici, Vite de’ pittori, scultori, ed architetti…, vol. 3, Naples, 1742, p. 148’). A branch of the powerful Caracciolo Rosso family, the Principi di Avellino assembled an impressive collection of paintings and objects in their palazzo on via di Pozzo Bianco (now via dell’Anticaglia). The family quadreria appears to have been formed from the mid-seventeenth century onwards, judging by the artists represented, which included Battistello Caracciolo, Micco Spadaro, Bartolomeo Passante, Mattia Preti, Giovanni Battista Beinaschi and Luca Giordano. An inventory of 1801 recording the paintings inherited by Marino Francesco following the death of his father, Giovanni Caracciolo Rosso, Principe di Avellino, notes among the works in the galleria, ‘Un quadro di p. 5 x 6: “la figura(?) di Egitto” di Andrea Vaccaro’ (D. Ferrante. ‘La quadreria dei principi di Avellino’, Napoli Nobilissima, XI, 1902, p. 159), which must surely be identifiable with the picture mentioned by De Dominici. It reappears in an inventory of 1844, compiled following Marino Francesco’s death in January of that year, where it is listed among the paintings in the family’s residence at Palazzo Maddaloni: ‘16. Un quadro su tela rappresentante la fuga in Egitto (p. 6 x 5) con tre figure di Andrea Vaccaro, duc. 60.’ (op. cit., p. 174). The recorded dimensions are sufficiently close to those of the present work and, in view of its unusual near-square format, render the identification with the painting owned by the Principi di Avellino highly plausible.
The painting has been in England for over a century, having belonged to Sir William Morton Eden, 7th Baronet of West Auckland, whose name is inscribed on the reverse of the stretcher. It then descended to his grandson, Sir John Eden, Baron Edon of Winton, who consigned it for sale at auction in 1978, marking its last appearance on the art market nearly fifty years ago. From 1965, Sir John lived at Knoyle Place in Wiltshire, a former rectory and childhood home of the architect Sir Christopher Wren, where the painting is believed to have hung for a period. Sir John was the nephew of Sir Anthony Eden (1897-1977), Prime Minister of the United Kingdom from 1955 to 1957.
Unusually conceived in a vertical format, the Flight into Egypt is a subject more often treated in landscape orientation. Vaccaro has deftly accommodated the figures and donkey within a compact, upright composition. The existence of a variant of inferior quality, formerly in the Dusmet de Smours collection (152 x 125.7 cm.; recorded on the RKD website), suggests that the present format is largely original, though the painting may have been marginally reduced along the lower edge, where there is evidence of historic damage. In addition to the greater fluency in handling evident in the present painting, a key difference between the two variants is the figure of Joseph, who here turns to look out at the viewer rather than towards the Madonna and Child, and is rendered with remarkable naturalism and vitality.
The exceptional tenderness of the Virgin’s expression, as she lowers her eyes to gaze upon the Christ Child while he pauses from nursing, is one of the most naturalistic aspects of the painting. The appeal of this motif is attested by the existence of the two figures as an independent composition, signed by Vaccaro with initials (101.5 x 75 cm.; sale, London, Sotheby’s, 9 December 1987, lot 128), as well as other copies that testify to the popularity of both the subject and design.
The early history of The Flight into Egypt is not known, though its format and scale suggest that it was a private commission. In his Life of Andrea Vaccaro, the eighteenth-century biographer Bernardo de Dominici records a painting of this subject belonging to the Principe di Avellino, though its description is too brief to make a firm identification: ‘In the Prince of Avellino’s Gallery there is a fine painting by Andrea, depicting the Flight into Egypt, which is very well executed’ (‘Vedesi nella Galleria del Principe d’Avellino un bel Quadro d’Andrea, che rappresenta la fuga in Egitto, assai ben dipinto’; B. de Dominici, Vite de’ pittori, scultori, ed architetti…, vol. 3, Naples, 1742, p. 148’). A branch of the powerful Caracciolo Rosso family, the Principi di Avellino assembled an impressive collection of paintings and objects in their palazzo on via di Pozzo Bianco (now via dell’Anticaglia). The family quadreria appears to have been formed from the mid-seventeenth century onwards, judging by the artists represented, which included Battistello Caracciolo, Micco Spadaro, Bartolomeo Passante, Mattia Preti, Giovanni Battista Beinaschi and Luca Giordano. An inventory of 1801 recording the paintings inherited by Marino Francesco following the death of his father, Giovanni Caracciolo Rosso, Principe di Avellino, notes among the works in the galleria, ‘Un quadro di p. 5 x 6: “la figura(?) di Egitto” di Andrea Vaccaro’ (D. Ferrante. ‘La quadreria dei principi di Avellino’, Napoli Nobilissima, XI, 1902, p. 159), which must surely be identifiable with the picture mentioned by De Dominici. It reappears in an inventory of 1844, compiled following Marino Francesco’s death in January of that year, where it is listed among the paintings in the family’s residence at Palazzo Maddaloni: ‘16. Un quadro su tela rappresentante la fuga in Egitto (p. 6 x 5) con tre figure di Andrea Vaccaro, duc. 60.’ (op. cit., p. 174). The recorded dimensions are sufficiently close to those of the present work and, in view of its unusual near-square format, render the identification with the painting owned by the Principi di Avellino highly plausible.
The painting has been in England for over a century, having belonged to Sir William Morton Eden, 7th Baronet of West Auckland, whose name is inscribed on the reverse of the stretcher. It then descended to his grandson, Sir John Eden, Baron Edon of Winton, who consigned it for sale at auction in 1978, marking its last appearance on the art market nearly fifty years ago. From 1965, Sir John lived at Knoyle Place in Wiltshire, a former rectory and childhood home of the architect Sir Christopher Wren, where the painting is believed to have hung for a period. Sir John was the nephew of Sir Anthony Eden (1897-1977), Prime Minister of the United Kingdom from 1955 to 1957.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
