A. Auld, Exhibition catalogue, Fact and Fancy: Drawings and Paintings by Sir Joseph Noel Paton (1821-1901), The Scottish Art Council, April 1967, p. 13, no. 15., illus. p. 26.
Edinburgh, Royal Scottish Academy, 1871 no. 827.
Edinburgh, Scottish National Exhibition, 1908.
Edinburgh, The Scottish Art Council, Fact and Fancy: Drawings and Paintings by Sir Joseph Noel Paton, 1967, no. 15.
Munich, British Council, Haus der Kunst, Zwei Jahrhunderte Englische Malerei, November 1979 –January 1980, no. 326, catalogue not traced.