• Russian Art auction at Christies

    Sale 1528

    Russian Art

    London

    |

    2 June 2014

    Browse Sale
Previous Lot
Search
Next Lot
    • Erik Bulatov (b. 1933)
    Lot 106 | PROPERTY FROM THE AHLERS COLLECTION /WebsiteLevel/More

    Erik Bulatov (b. 1933)

    Freedom is Freedom II from the Here series

    Price realised

    GBP 242,500

    Estimate

    GBP 100,000 - GBP 150,000

    Follow lot
    Add to Interests

    Erik Bulatov (b. 1933)
    Freedom is Freedom II from the Here series
    signed in Cyrillic, inscribed in Russian with title, further inscribed in Russian, further inscribed in French with title, dated and numbered ‘EBulatov/2001/(2)/Vsevolod Nekrasov’ (on the reverse)
    oil on canvas
    78¾ x 78¾ in. (200 x 200 cm.)
    Painted 2000-2001

    Provenance

    Acquired from the artist by the present owner in 2006.

    Contact us

    • Contact Client Service

      info@christies.com

      New York +1 212 636 2000

      London +44 (0)20 7839 9060

      infoasia@christies.com

      Asia +852 2760 1766

    • Sarah Mansfield

      smansfield@christies.com

      +44 (0)20 7389 2210

    Literature and exhibited

    Literature

    Exhibition catalogue, Erik Bulatov: works 1995-2001, Oslo, 2002, illustrated p. 7.
    E. Bulatov, ‘Slovo o kartine [A note on the painting]’, WAM [World Art Museum], Moscow, no. 11, 2004, illustrated p. 65.
    J. Backstein and B. De Baere, Exhibition catalogue, Moscow conceptualism and its influence. Angels of History, Antwerp, 2005, illustrated p. 37.
    V. Görner, C. Käding and A. Prenzle, exhibition catalogue, Freedom is Freedom, Hannover, 2006, illustrated on the cover and p. 10, pp. 11 and 30.
    N. Godzina and A. Kharitonova, exhibition catalogue, Erik Bulatov. Vot [Here you are], Moscow, 2006, illustrated p. 159, listed pp. 156, 207 and 221.
    D. Sausset, ‘Boulatov, superstar’, Connaissance des arts, illustrated p. 59, 2007.
    K. Miskarian, Art Khronika, 8, 2006, illustrated p. 76.
    L. Adashevskaia, ‘’Vot’-kartiny moei zhizhni. Beseda s Erikom Bulatovym [‘Here you are’, or My Oeuvre. An interview with Erik Bulatov]’, Dialog iskusstv [Arts Dialogue], Moscow, 2007, illustrated p. 125.
    L. Milkova, Painting Photography: Erik Bulatov, Boris Mikhailov, and Soviet underground art, 1970-1985, Philadelphia, 2008, p. 99f.
    G. Matt and C. Hug, exhibition catalogue, Ende der Geschichte oder Beginn der Zukunft? Anmerkungen zum Epochenbruch, Vienna, 2009, illustrated p. 99, listed p. [302], pp. [24, 98].
    K. Rieber, Erik Bulatov. Catalogue raisonné in two volumes. Volume I: Paintings 1952-2011, Cologne, 2012, illustrated p. 207, listed p. 284, no. 194.


    Exhibited

    Oslo, Blomqvist Kunsthandel AS, Erik Bulatov: works 1995-2001, 24 January-2 March 2002.
    Antwerp, Museum van Hedendaagse Kunst Antwerpen, Moscow conceptualism and its influence. Angels of History, 17 September-27 November 2005.
    Hannover, Kestnergesellschaft, Erik Bulatov: Freiheit ist Freiheit/Freedom is Freedom, 24 February-28 May, 2006.
    Moscow, The State Tretyakov Gallery, Erik Bulatov. Vot [Here you are], 19 September-19 November 2006.
    Vienna, 1989. Ende der Geschichte oder Beginn der Zukunft? Anmerkungen zum Epochenbruch, 9 October-7 February 2010.


    Lot Essay

    Freedom is Freedom II belongs to a series of twelve paintings (1999-2003), eleven of which (including the present work) feature text from poems by Bulatov’s friend, the minimalist poet Vsevolod Nekrasov (1934-2009). An exhibition of this series entitled I live, I see was held at the State Tretyakov Gallery in 2006.
    Like many artists and writers in Eastern Europe, Bulatov’s work has evolved in accordance with the world around him. A staunch Komsomol member as a teenager, he gradually came to understand and despise the restriction of art in the USSR. Although classified as a non-conformist (the group of artists working outside of the Soviet-prescribed agenda in the 1960s-1980s), Bulatov rejects the Sots Art classification of his work. His interests have never been restricted to Soviet society or indeed any society; he is interested in issues that transcend the social order and exist beyond a simple dialectic of Soviet vs. Anti-Soviet.
    There are certain pervasive aspects visible throughout Bulatov’s oeuvre. He describes his mission as being ‘to show and prove, that social space, however meaningful and aggressive it may seem, is actually boundless. [Social space] has limits, a border, and human freedom and in general the meaning of human existence is on the other side of that border. The space of art is over there, on that side of the social border.’ In much of his work the placement of text over image defines that space. In Freedom is Freedom II the word ‘freedom’ stretches away from us enticingly into the sky, providing access to this space beyond.
    Bulatov’s 1988 solo exhibition in Zurich marked a turning point in both his career and indeed his life. In 1989 in the wake of the exhibition’s success, he moved to New York, prompting a rapid exploration of contemporary art, particularly American Pop Art. Bulatov developed a keen interest in artists such as Ed Ruscha (b. 1937) who incorporate text into their work and whose influence can be felt in the present work. Freedom is Freedom II also recalls Christopher Wool’s (b. 1955) seminal Apocalypse Now (1988, Private collection) in its easy conveyance of the Pop and Dada collagist aesthetic. Where Wool’s source material is a Hollywood blockbuster, its text appropriately referencing the value society invests in property and ownership, Bulatov’s work is arguably, by this point, less cynical. In Freedom is Freedom II Bulatov takes an unimpeachable truth, repeating it almost like a prayer. While the use of language in art encompasses a New York slant, the political charge to language is an idea intrinsic to those raised in the Soviet era. Nekrasov’s critique of the official Soviet language and hackneyed phrases utilised by the government made his poetry unpublishable in the USSR.
    Bulatov’s change in context and geopolitics precipitated the present work: an insistent meditation on universal truth and freedom without strictures. The sky serves as a multifaceted metaphor, as do the clouds: shape-shifting, divination, God, eternity, space, transience, as well as the lingering connotation of its etymology: the Latin ‘nebula’, cloud (and ‘Nebo’ meaning sky in Russian, from a common Proto-Indo-European root,) giving various Indo-European languages an equivalent of the world ‘nebulous’. Against this web of associations, the repetition of ‘Freedom is’ serves to reinforce the meaning of this image: a boundless, endless, exultant human freedom. In Nekrasov’s poem six lines repeating ‘Freedom is’ is followed by a seventh: ‘Freedom is freedom’, evoking Gertrude Stein’s ‘Rose is a rose is a rose is a rose’ from her 1913 poem Sacred Emily. In Bulatov’s image this closure is absent. Traditionally translated as ‘Freedom is freedom’, if the words are read sequentially, each line might be translated as ‘Freedom exists’, with the painting’s size conferring an additional authority to this statement. Is it a celebration, a reminder or something to be repeated until it comes true? Repetition becomes a way to truth and away from an oppressive language and aesthetic by clinging to very basic human ideas. As the Soviet-era Polish poet Zbigniew Herbert (1924-1998) wrote: ‘it didn’t require great character at all/our refusal disagreement and resistance/we had a shred of necessary courage/but fundamentally it was a matter of taste’.

    Other information

    Special Notice


    Artist's Resale Right ("Droit de Suite"). Artist's Resale Right Regulations 2006 apply to this lot, the buyer agrees to pay us an amount equal to the resale royalty provided for in those Regulations, and we undertake to the buyer to pay such amount to the artist's collection agent.


    Pre-Lot Text

    PROPERTY FROM THE AHLERS COLLECTION

    Recommended features

      • Collecting guide: Soviet porce
      • Collecting guide: Soviet porcelain

        ​​Russian Works of Art specialist Margo Oganesian offers an expert overview of a category that is very much on the up ​

      • Collecting Guide: 15 things yo
      • Collecting Guide: 15 things you need to know about Fabergé

        From the iconic imperial eggs to its jewellery, flowers, figurines and snuff-boxes, and the distinct styles of its various branches and workmasters

      • 5 minutes with... An important
      • 5 minutes with... An important drawing by Gustav Klimt

        This study for a gorgon in the Beethoven Frieze in Vienna may look familiar — a sister work has recently been promoting a Klimt exhibition in London

      • The must-see exhibitions of 20
      • The must-see exhibitions of 2019 — Europe

        Masters of the Renaissance in Berlin, a Post-Impressionist in Britain and Degas at the Opéra — our updated guide to the best shows in Europe this year

Share
Email
Copy link