A. Ottino della Chiesa, Bernardino Luini, Novara, 1956, pp. 33, 73, no. 40, fig. 89, as 'attributed to Luini'.
K. Paris, ed., The Frederick W. Schumacher Collection, Columbus, 1976, pp. 142-143, as 'Luini or follower'.
Columbus, Gallery of Fine Arts, The Renaissance Image of Man and the World, 27 October-27 November 1961, no. 12, as 'Luini'.
Columbus, Ohio State University Art Gallery, Six Centuries of Painting from The Columbus Gallery of Fine Arts, 9 January-2 February 1973, no. 7, as 'Luini'.