Compare the vase of this unusual type and size illustrated by E. Zimmermann, Chinesisches Porzellan, vol. II, Leipzig, 1923, pl. 117 and another from the Grandidier collection in the Musée Guimet illustrated in Oriental Ceramics, The World's Great Collections, Tokyo, 1981, vol. 7, pl. 55, where it is described as Japanese and attributed to the Edo period. See, also, the single vase from the Edward James Collection, West Dean Park, sold by Christie's at West Dean, England, 3-4 June 1986, lot 891.