Tableaux appartenant à M. Pierre Barbaja, Naples, 1874, p. 10, no. 165, as Guercino (valued at 3635 gold francs).
Illinois, Springfield, Illinois State Museum, The Frank W. Chesrow Collection of Italian and West European Renaissance and Baroque Paintings, 1 April - 27 May 1956, no. 13, as Guercino.
Tulsa, Philbrook Art Center; and Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Art Center, Masterpieces of Renaissance and Baroque Painting from the Collection of Colonel Frank W. Chesrow, 5-28 October 1970 and 8 November - 6 December 1970, no. 18, as Guercino.
Indiana, Hammond, Woodmar County Club, Treasures of Renaissance and Baroque Painting and other works form the collection of Colonel Frank W. Chesrow, April 1974, no. 5, as Guercino.