Lot Essay
This imposing still life by one of the most gifted and enigmatic painters of seventeenth-century Spain possesses a striking sense of modernity while remaining firmly rooted in the tangible reality of contemporary Seville. The ‘stepped’ arrangement of everyday objects is deceptively simple, each element carefully positioned for our viewing pleasure and observed with extraordinary concentration. The tactile qualities of the objects are heightened by dramatic lighting effects, while the vivid colours and varied textures of fruit, flowers, glass and silver stand out against the austere setting and enveloping darkness behind. In its profound stillness, time itself seems suspended.
It is a still life composed of three distinct groupings, each sufficiently beautiful to stand as an independent composition. At the centre sits a large wicker basket piled high with apples, some blushing, others bruised, several still bearing their stems as if freshly picked from the tree. Curling leaves animate the composition and provide a soft counterfoil to the solidity of the fruit, as is especially evident in the isolated, spot-lit apple in the foreground. A pomegranate lies split open on a silver plate, its glistening seeds exposed, and the plate’s polished metal reflects the warm orange tones of the fruit’s peel. At right stands a delicate Venetian-glass vase containing flowers: the low water level and the fallen bloom teetering on the ledge below suggest that the arrangement has been in place for some time. Although Spanish still lifes have traditionally been interpreted as symbolic or even ‘mystical’, with flowers alluding to the transience of life, the pomegranate to Christ’s Passion and Resurrection, and the apple to the temptation of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, more recently it has been argued that such paintings were not necessarily intended to have a ‘spiritual’ dimension (Cherry, op. cit., 2026, p. 127).
This is one of fewer than twenty surviving pictures by Juan de Zurbarán, son of the celebrated Spanish painter Francisco de Zurbarán (1598-1664) and his first wife, María de Morales. Born some 80 miles north of Seville, in Llerena, Juan moved to the city in 1629, aged about nine, and trained in the workshop established there by his father. Although documentary sources record that Juan painted religious subjects – notably two large canvases of the Miracles of the Virgin of the Rosary for the Confraternity of the Rosary at Carmona, near Seville, in 1644 – none of these works survive, and he is known today exclusively as a still-life painter. In 1641 he married Mariana de Quadros, the wealthy daughter of a procurator in the Real Audencia of Seville, who brought a substantial dowry. Nearly half of this was paid in money, silver and jewellery which could readily be pawned, and it remains unclear how the dowry had been dissipated by the time Juan died. Francisco encouraged his son’s social advancement and Juan attended dance classes, where he was registered as ‘Don’ Juan de Zurbarán, a title he would later adopt when signing a painting. In 1649, Juan’s promising life and career were tragically cut short. He died at just twenty-nine, falling victim to the plague epidemic that devastated Seville and claimed nearly half the city’s population.
Only three of Juan’s still lifes are signed, and these serve as important touchstones within his œuvre, providing fixed points to trace the development of his style and evolution of his compositions. The earliest is a Plate of Grapes, painted on copper and signed and dated 1639 (private collection; Delenda, op. cit., p. 277, no. JZ-1). It consists of a single grouping of fruit, in this case red and white grapes, arranged on a silver plate, a motif that recalls the work of still-life painters active in Spanish-ruled Milan, notably Fede Galizia and Panfilo Nuvolone. The coloured reflections are echoed in the plate with pomegranate in the present work and are likewise reminiscent of those found in similar motifs in Francisco de Zurbarán’s only signed and dated still life, Still Life with Lemons, Oranges and a Rose, a composition also structured around three core elements (1633; Pasadena, Norton Simon Museum; fig. 1). Juan’s next dated work, Still Life with a Chocolate Service (1640; Kiev, Museum of Western and Oriental Art; ibid., pp. 280-1, no. JZ-10), painted on canvas and of slightly larger dimensions, presents an array of objects arranged across a shallow ledge illuminated by strong directional light. The third dated painting is Still Life with Fruit and Cardoon of 1643 (Mänttä, Gösta Serlachius Fine Arts Foundation; ibid., p. 283, no. JZ-15), a considerably more elaborate composition in which a range of objects is set against a dark background. Its pronounced tenebrism, accentuating form and heightening the sense of three-dimensionality, has been linked to Neapolitan still-life painters such as Luca Forte, whose works may have reached Seville from Naples during the second quarter of the seventeenth century.
The present still life belongs to this third phase of Juan’s career and dates from the final few years of the artist’s life (1643-9). Its carefully calibrated construction, organised around a dominant central motif, finds direct parallels in his Flowers and Fruit in a Bowl (c. 1645; The Art Institute of Chicago) and Still Life with Lemons in a Wicker Basket (1640s; London, National Gallery; fig. 2). The large wicker basket, whose tightly woven body differs from the intricate interlacing that forms a decorative braided rim, was likely a studio prop, as it reappears in the National Gallery painting as well as in a Still Life with Peaches in a Wicker Basket (Oviedo, Fundación María Cristina Masaveu Peterson; ibid., p. 284, no. JZ-18). Compared to the aforementioned paintings, the present work displays a greater complexity and individuality in its ‘stepped’ composition, a device also found in the work of the Madrid painter Juan van der Hamen y León (1596-1631). To date, it is also the only known instance in Juan’s œuvre to feature a vase of flowers, a detail thought to reflect the influence of Flemish still-life painting.
It is in these mature works that Juan distinguishes himself from his father, broadening Francisco’s repertoire by introducing new motifs and compositional devices. As eloquently noted by Cherry, ‘The emphatic contours of things and their meticulous modelling owe much to Francisco, but Juan amplified the contrasts between light and shade and cast his works in an enveloping darkness, introducing an asymmetrical accent in his compositions’ (ibid., p. 141). It is this stark lighting and stillness that distinguish Juan’s still lifes from those of his contemporaries and, despite their rarity, underscore the important role he played in the development of the Spanish bodegón tradition.
Please note that this superb still life by Juan de Zurbarán has been requested for Zurbarán: Divine Light, a major exhibition to be held at the Art Institute of Chicago from 28 February to 20 June 2027.
A note on the provenance
The painting’s early history is unknown. It has always been published as having been in the collection of the art critic Denys Sutton (1917-1991), though the circumstances in which it was acquired were unclear until now. Sutton served as secretary of the International Commission for the Restitution of Cultural Material during the Second World War and, in 1948, was appointed fine arts specialist for UNESCO. He subsequently became art sales correspondent and book reviewer for The Daily Telegraph, art critic for the Financial Times and Country Life, and served as editor of Apollo (1962-87). In 1960 Sutton married his third wife, Cynthia Sassoon, whose inherited wealth no doubt enabled the couple to acquire Juan de Zurbarán’s painting the following year.
Labels on the reverse, together with research undertaken in the Agnew’s archive at the National Gallery, make it possible to reconstruct the painting’s entry into Sutton’s collection. The still life was deposited with Agnew’s on 21 February 1961 by ‘Feversham Ld’ (Lord Feversham) and delivered a month later, on 21 March, to ‘Wiggins’ (presumably the framers), by which point Denys Sutton was recorded as the owner, suggesting that Agnew’s brokered the sale in the intervening weeks. By 1964, the painting was certainly hanging in the Suttons’ home, appearing in the background of a photograph taken that year by Lord Snowdon (fig. 3). The collection was evidently wide-ranging, reflecting Denys Sutton’s own scholarly interests, but the presence of Juan de Zurbarán’s still life is perhaps unsurprising in light of his appreciation for this school of painting. In his review for Country Life of the National Gallery’s 1947 exhibition of Spanish art, Sutton praised the ‘concentrated and almost surprising naturalism’ that he regarded as characteristic of the Spanish school. At its finest, he observed, ‘Spanish painting possesses a desire to distil the eternal’. He continued: ‘It is perhaps their sense of the transitoriness of life which make these Spanish painters translate their deep sense of the tragedy of life into the comforting appearance of a bowl’.
The ‘Feversham Ld’ who consigned the painting to Agnew’s must have been Charles William Slingsby ‘Sim’ Duncombe, 3rd Earl of Feversham (1906-1963), a Conservative politician who served as Lord-in-Waiting to King George V, and later to Edward VIII, as well as Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries. His family seat was Duncombe Park, the eighteenth-century mansion in Helmsley, North Yorkshire. The core of the collection had already been formed by 1829, the year A Description of Duncombe Park, Rivalx Abbey, and Helmsley Castle was published. The picture collection contained works by Claude, Poussin, Rembrandt, Hobbema and Wouwerman and was further enriched by the 3rd Earl’s great-great-grandfather, Charles Duncombe, 1st Baron Feversham (1764-1841), who acquired pictures by Bellini, Guido Reni, Jan and Andries Both and Peter Paul Rubens (including Old Woman and Boy by Candlelight, now in The Hague, Mauritshuis). He also purchased one of the stars of the collection, the marble statue of a seated Molossian dog, known as ‘The Dog of Alcibiades’, a Roman copy of a Hellenistic bronze original that has been in the British Museum, London, since 2001. Juan de Zurbarán’s still life is not listed in the 1829 catalogue, nor was it among pictures from the Feversham collection exhibited at York in 1879 or recorded at Duncombe in the 1882 Handbook for Travellers in Yorkshire, all of which suggests that it was acquired in the late nineteenth or early twentieth century. In addition to selling the Zurbarán in 1961, Charles William Slingsby ‘Sim’ Duncombe also sold Carlo Dolci’s Martyrdom of Saint Andrew (now in Birmingham Museums) through Agnew’s in 1962, and a Charity by Guido Reni (a replica of the picture in New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art) in 1959. These sales suggest that the family had fallen on harder times, and the viscountcy of Helmsley became extinct upon his death in 1963.
It is a still life composed of three distinct groupings, each sufficiently beautiful to stand as an independent composition. At the centre sits a large wicker basket piled high with apples, some blushing, others bruised, several still bearing their stems as if freshly picked from the tree. Curling leaves animate the composition and provide a soft counterfoil to the solidity of the fruit, as is especially evident in the isolated, spot-lit apple in the foreground. A pomegranate lies split open on a silver plate, its glistening seeds exposed, and the plate’s polished metal reflects the warm orange tones of the fruit’s peel. At right stands a delicate Venetian-glass vase containing flowers: the low water level and the fallen bloom teetering on the ledge below suggest that the arrangement has been in place for some time. Although Spanish still lifes have traditionally been interpreted as symbolic or even ‘mystical’, with flowers alluding to the transience of life, the pomegranate to Christ’s Passion and Resurrection, and the apple to the temptation of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, more recently it has been argued that such paintings were not necessarily intended to have a ‘spiritual’ dimension (Cherry, op. cit., 2026, p. 127).
This is one of fewer than twenty surviving pictures by Juan de Zurbarán, son of the celebrated Spanish painter Francisco de Zurbarán (1598-1664) and his first wife, María de Morales. Born some 80 miles north of Seville, in Llerena, Juan moved to the city in 1629, aged about nine, and trained in the workshop established there by his father. Although documentary sources record that Juan painted religious subjects – notably two large canvases of the Miracles of the Virgin of the Rosary for the Confraternity of the Rosary at Carmona, near Seville, in 1644 – none of these works survive, and he is known today exclusively as a still-life painter. In 1641 he married Mariana de Quadros, the wealthy daughter of a procurator in the Real Audencia of Seville, who brought a substantial dowry. Nearly half of this was paid in money, silver and jewellery which could readily be pawned, and it remains unclear how the dowry had been dissipated by the time Juan died. Francisco encouraged his son’s social advancement and Juan attended dance classes, where he was registered as ‘Don’ Juan de Zurbarán, a title he would later adopt when signing a painting. In 1649, Juan’s promising life and career were tragically cut short. He died at just twenty-nine, falling victim to the plague epidemic that devastated Seville and claimed nearly half the city’s population.
Only three of Juan’s still lifes are signed, and these serve as important touchstones within his œuvre, providing fixed points to trace the development of his style and evolution of his compositions. The earliest is a Plate of Grapes, painted on copper and signed and dated 1639 (private collection; Delenda, op. cit., p. 277, no. JZ-1). It consists of a single grouping of fruit, in this case red and white grapes, arranged on a silver plate, a motif that recalls the work of still-life painters active in Spanish-ruled Milan, notably Fede Galizia and Panfilo Nuvolone. The coloured reflections are echoed in the plate with pomegranate in the present work and are likewise reminiscent of those found in similar motifs in Francisco de Zurbarán’s only signed and dated still life, Still Life with Lemons, Oranges and a Rose, a composition also structured around three core elements (1633; Pasadena, Norton Simon Museum; fig. 1). Juan’s next dated work, Still Life with a Chocolate Service (1640; Kiev, Museum of Western and Oriental Art; ibid., pp. 280-1, no. JZ-10), painted on canvas and of slightly larger dimensions, presents an array of objects arranged across a shallow ledge illuminated by strong directional light. The third dated painting is Still Life with Fruit and Cardoon of 1643 (Mänttä, Gösta Serlachius Fine Arts Foundation; ibid., p. 283, no. JZ-15), a considerably more elaborate composition in which a range of objects is set against a dark background. Its pronounced tenebrism, accentuating form and heightening the sense of three-dimensionality, has been linked to Neapolitan still-life painters such as Luca Forte, whose works may have reached Seville from Naples during the second quarter of the seventeenth century.
The present still life belongs to this third phase of Juan’s career and dates from the final few years of the artist’s life (1643-9). Its carefully calibrated construction, organised around a dominant central motif, finds direct parallels in his Flowers and Fruit in a Bowl (c. 1645; The Art Institute of Chicago) and Still Life with Lemons in a Wicker Basket (1640s; London, National Gallery; fig. 2). The large wicker basket, whose tightly woven body differs from the intricate interlacing that forms a decorative braided rim, was likely a studio prop, as it reappears in the National Gallery painting as well as in a Still Life with Peaches in a Wicker Basket (Oviedo, Fundación María Cristina Masaveu Peterson; ibid., p. 284, no. JZ-18). Compared to the aforementioned paintings, the present work displays a greater complexity and individuality in its ‘stepped’ composition, a device also found in the work of the Madrid painter Juan van der Hamen y León (1596-1631). To date, it is also the only known instance in Juan’s œuvre to feature a vase of flowers, a detail thought to reflect the influence of Flemish still-life painting.
It is in these mature works that Juan distinguishes himself from his father, broadening Francisco’s repertoire by introducing new motifs and compositional devices. As eloquently noted by Cherry, ‘The emphatic contours of things and their meticulous modelling owe much to Francisco, but Juan amplified the contrasts between light and shade and cast his works in an enveloping darkness, introducing an asymmetrical accent in his compositions’ (ibid., p. 141). It is this stark lighting and stillness that distinguish Juan’s still lifes from those of his contemporaries and, despite their rarity, underscore the important role he played in the development of the Spanish bodegón tradition.
Please note that this superb still life by Juan de Zurbarán has been requested for Zurbarán: Divine Light, a major exhibition to be held at the Art Institute of Chicago from 28 February to 20 June 2027.
A note on the provenance
The painting’s early history is unknown. It has always been published as having been in the collection of the art critic Denys Sutton (1917-1991), though the circumstances in which it was acquired were unclear until now. Sutton served as secretary of the International Commission for the Restitution of Cultural Material during the Second World War and, in 1948, was appointed fine arts specialist for UNESCO. He subsequently became art sales correspondent and book reviewer for The Daily Telegraph, art critic for the Financial Times and Country Life, and served as editor of Apollo (1962-87). In 1960 Sutton married his third wife, Cynthia Sassoon, whose inherited wealth no doubt enabled the couple to acquire Juan de Zurbarán’s painting the following year.
Labels on the reverse, together with research undertaken in the Agnew’s archive at the National Gallery, make it possible to reconstruct the painting’s entry into Sutton’s collection. The still life was deposited with Agnew’s on 21 February 1961 by ‘Feversham Ld’ (Lord Feversham) and delivered a month later, on 21 March, to ‘Wiggins’ (presumably the framers), by which point Denys Sutton was recorded as the owner, suggesting that Agnew’s brokered the sale in the intervening weeks. By 1964, the painting was certainly hanging in the Suttons’ home, appearing in the background of a photograph taken that year by Lord Snowdon (fig. 3). The collection was evidently wide-ranging, reflecting Denys Sutton’s own scholarly interests, but the presence of Juan de Zurbarán’s still life is perhaps unsurprising in light of his appreciation for this school of painting. In his review for Country Life of the National Gallery’s 1947 exhibition of Spanish art, Sutton praised the ‘concentrated and almost surprising naturalism’ that he regarded as characteristic of the Spanish school. At its finest, he observed, ‘Spanish painting possesses a desire to distil the eternal’. He continued: ‘It is perhaps their sense of the transitoriness of life which make these Spanish painters translate their deep sense of the tragedy of life into the comforting appearance of a bowl’.
The ‘Feversham Ld’ who consigned the painting to Agnew’s must have been Charles William Slingsby ‘Sim’ Duncombe, 3rd Earl of Feversham (1906-1963), a Conservative politician who served as Lord-in-Waiting to King George V, and later to Edward VIII, as well as Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries. His family seat was Duncombe Park, the eighteenth-century mansion in Helmsley, North Yorkshire. The core of the collection had already been formed by 1829, the year A Description of Duncombe Park, Rivalx Abbey, and Helmsley Castle was published. The picture collection contained works by Claude, Poussin, Rembrandt, Hobbema and Wouwerman and was further enriched by the 3rd Earl’s great-great-grandfather, Charles Duncombe, 1st Baron Feversham (1764-1841), who acquired pictures by Bellini, Guido Reni, Jan and Andries Both and Peter Paul Rubens (including Old Woman and Boy by Candlelight, now in The Hague, Mauritshuis). He also purchased one of the stars of the collection, the marble statue of a seated Molossian dog, known as ‘The Dog of Alcibiades’, a Roman copy of a Hellenistic bronze original that has been in the British Museum, London, since 2001. Juan de Zurbarán’s still life is not listed in the 1829 catalogue, nor was it among pictures from the Feversham collection exhibited at York in 1879 or recorded at Duncombe in the 1882 Handbook for Travellers in Yorkshire, all of which suggests that it was acquired in the late nineteenth or early twentieth century. In addition to selling the Zurbarán in 1961, Charles William Slingsby ‘Sim’ Duncombe also sold Carlo Dolci’s Martyrdom of Saint Andrew (now in Birmingham Museums) through Agnew’s in 1962, and a Charity by Guido Reni (a replica of the picture in New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art) in 1959. These sales suggest that the family had fallen on harder times, and the viscountcy of Helmsley became extinct upon his death in 1963.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
